Captain’s log, stardate 78984.6: “When a group of Ferengi present Captain Picard with the derelict remains of his old starship, he begins to lose himself in the past.”
Yes, I know, another Ferengi episode. They have a reputation for being universally awful, but even with that, there are still good aspects. With “Last Outpost” we had the obvious comfort of the regulars in their roles, and this week, we have some wonderful development for Captain Picard. Specifically in the answer to the question, “What did he do before the Enterprise?”
We know now that to become captain of the 1701 herself is a tremendous honor for Starfleet officers, and it speaks to the quality of Picard as an officer that he was able to achieve that. And, for obvious reasons, his Enterprise era, and the shadow of it, are why he is so famous and beloved. But there was another part to his story, and in this episode we get our first glimpse – welcome aboard the USS Stargazer.
Picard’s time aboard the Stargazer is an interesting one, but rarely depicted on TV. For a deeper dive, we have to turn to the expanded universe, and in particular the Stargazer series of novels, all written by Michael Jan Friedman. The first book in the series, The Valiant, depicts the death of the Stargazer’s original captain and Picard’s reluctant ascendancy to command, while the remaining six books in the series explore various events in 2333, the first year of Picard’s command.
Another book in the TNG novel line, The Buried Age, concerns itself with giving Starfleet’s side of the Battle of Maxia, and what Picard got up to following the court-martial. He became an archaeologist, and it was only through coming across Guinan again (following their meeting in Oblivion) that he eventually finds his way back to Starfleet, and takes command of the Enterprise.
It’s an intriguing period in Picard’s life, and having read all the books in the series, I dearly wish that some version of it would pop up as a streaming show one day, rather than being relegated to non-canonical novels. If we’re going to do prequel series like Strange New Worlds, why not give us a younger Picard, finding his way into command, making mistakes and bad judgement calls, even as he grows into the man we know he’ll be?
Obviously, there’s the issue of recasting Picard, which you’d have to do since an 80 something year-old Patrick Stewart wouldn’t work in the role of Jean-Luc in his thirties. On the other hand, if Leonard Nimoy was able to give Zachary Quinto his blessing to play Young Spock in the Kelvin films, why can’t Patrick Stewart do the same for a potential Young Picard?
Sure, the ending of the series would be something of a downer, but it all depends on how you do it. Depicting of the Battle of Maxia on screen would be easy enough, now that everything is done with CG rather than physical models, and you could even have an epilogue set 9 years later, as Picard (perhaps played by a de-aged Patrick Stewart, utilizing archival audio) assumes command of the Enterprise. Or, alternately, restage the 2364 scenes in “All Good Things,” and have the episode end on that very first log entry from “Farpoint.” It would bring the story of Picard full circle, once and for all.
Besides, you’d even get to use the name Star Trek: Picard again. Just change the context!
Of course, such a series will pretty much never happen, even in a world as prequel-heavy as Kurtzman-era Trek has been. The fandom has coalesced around getting Star Trek: Legacy made, following the adventures of the Enterprise-G and her crew, in what Terry Matalas described as a kind of neo-TNG type show:
“Boy, wouldn’t you want to check in with the Klingon Empire? Wouldn’t you want to check in with Deep Space Nine and The Doctor [from Voyager] and everything that went on with the Berman-verse? So that’s kind of where I see is to explore the galaxy and sort of get back to the Next Gen roots of storytelling is what I would see as a kind of version of Star Trek I’d like to see, with this group of characters that we’re seeing.”
I have to admit, the idea is appealing, and I sincerely hope it happens. The fanbase is eager for it, as are LeVar Burton and Jeri Ryan, Akiva Goldsman, even Kurtzman himself! But TV costs money, and with the way “peak TV” has turned out, I don’t know that we’ll get Legacy in the form some people might want it: 26 streaming episodes across 7 seasons. Still, one can hope.
Moving back to “The Battle,” it’s honestly kind of a shame that the more interesting plot line regarding Picard and his relationship to the Stargazer is so inextricably bound with DaiMon Bok and his pointless revenge quest. And because this is episodic television, we don’t get anything else with the Stargazer until freaking season two of Picard, for reasons I will elaborate on when we get to that point in our journey.
For now, let us simply say that while I will always have a soft spot for “The Battle,” it is entirely because of what it shows us about Picard and his early career before the Enterprise. Jean-Luc is a deeply interesting character, and half the reason I’m rewatching his adventures for the second time in a year is because I love him that much.
The other reason, of course, is so my girlfriend can see why I’m so obsessed with this show. TNG is why I am a proud Star Trek fan, and I’m really enjoying going on this journey with her, rather than alone.
Everything’s better with two.
Leave a Reply