The RTD Rewind: Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead

At long last! After 4 solid weeks of stories that ranged from mediocre to awful, Steven Moffat comes in with one of his all-time best stories, and given his high batting average, that’s really saying something.

There are times, watching these older episodes, that I really wish I got to watch it on broadcast. Rose is one of them. This one is the other. What must it have been like in 2008, looking at River Song and wondering what her story was? While I admit I’ve not seen Moffat’s version of The Time Traveler’s Wife, I will say I remember thinking, “Why? He already did that, it’s called series 5-7 of Doctor Who.”

And it all starts here. There is simply no understanding the entirety of the Moffat era without this story. And having written two books on the subject, I can’t help but look at this story without the weight of the future bearing down on me.

Part of this just comes down to the fact that by 2008, Moffat had been offered, and accepted, the role of showrunner. This gave him a lot of leeway in which to work, so we get a story that basically functions as a preview of the Smith era: Crash of the Byzantium? Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone. Picnic at Asgard? A short story by Jenny T. Colgan in The Legends of River Song, featuring 11. (Mind you, we now know that the Darilium bit refers to Husbands, a 12 story, but even so…)

It’s wonderful, seeing Alex Kingston again as River. To see her hint at things I know are coming. In a way, she’s the Moffat era in microcosm: you either love her or you hate her. And I, naturally, adore her.

But at the same time, seeing her here is bittersweet. She’s not the future anymore, she’s the past. A wonderful past, to be sure, but a past that began thirteen years ago. As I write this we are now nearly ten years on from the end of the Smith era, ten years since that Christmas where I yelled at the TV and sobbed because my Raggedy Doctor was going away, and I didn’t know how to cope.

The context in which I am watching this story is inescapable – in 2008, the Doctor was David Tennant and Catherine Tate was the companion. In 2023, it’s the same again. Sure, it’s only for three weeks, but what does it matter? The past has returned with a vengeance. And if things had shifted, if I’d started following Who more closely just a little bit earlier, this era might be the one that I am thrilled about revisiting, even for 3 weeks. And for a lot of people, that is the case. And I am happy for those people! I got to have my moment a decade ago, when Matt Smith was the incumbent and sharing in an anniversary adventure with David Tennant and John Hurt. For the RTD fans, and in particular those who came to the show during series 4, this is their moment, and I’m not going to spoil that for them.

From what we know about the upcoming specials it’ll be pretty heavy on the RTD love, which is understandable, given that A) Davies is writing it and B) you gotta have something to attract the viewers’ attention after how badly the Chibnall era handled things. May as well be the return of the era that was big in the UK.

Yes, it’s a nostalgia play, but unlike Fugitive where it was an old song being played limply by a bad tribute band, this is the genuine article revisiting the past and making something new out of it: the Doctor Who equivalent of “Now and Then.” (November is a big year for British pop culture icons hitting the big six-oh, isn’t it?)

I just hope, in some fashion or other, that my era gets acknowledged. Special 2, from what I’ve heard, is entirely studio-based – we may yet see other Doctors pop up, and I know I would give anything to see Matt Smith back in his bowtie and tweed, like the old days. Hell, I’ll even settle for a mishmash of archive footage or something. Even the smallest crumb, to acknowledge that 2010-2017 happened, would be lovely.

But if not, that’s okay too. I still have The Day of the Doctor. I still have Back to the Eleventh Hour. I still have my memories, and my copies of the episodes. I still have the soundtracks, and the poster, the computer wallpapers, my model sonic screwdriver. Hell, I may even watch Day this week, if I’m not too busy doing Thanksgiving stuff. And if I want new-to-me Eleven adventures, I can always snag the Jacob Dudman audios from Big Finish.

A friend of mine from an old server shared with me the cast list for the second special. Tennant and Tate were there of course, along with three names that were redacted. My friend’s theory was that at least two of them could be Doctors, and given Eccleston will never do anything with RTD again and Jodie’s era having ended only last year, that means the only other two options are Smith and Capaldi. Only one way to find out.

Editor’s note: It was, in fact, David Tennant and Catherine Tate again.

Whatever happens though, I’ll enjoy the journey, no matter where it takes me. And if it doesn’t stop by my favorite place, that’s fine. I can always revisit it myself, on my own.

Because those moments are precious to me, like they are for River. The Doctor helped me grow into the woman I am now, I wouldn’t be here if not for him. That silly, raggedy man in tweed and a bow tie means more to me than I’ll ever be able to put into words, even if I had an infinite number of books available in which to do it.

We’re all stories in the end…. just make it a good one.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑