Captain’s log, stardate 79003.8: Q returns to the Enterprise, testing Commander Riker by giving him the power of the Q.
As I have gone through TNG with my girlfriend, I have noticed that she and I are on opposite sides regarding Q as a character. I love him, and she absolutely despises him, with a vehemence that would honestly be rather shocking other contexts.
She has described him as being very arrogant with absolutely no redeeming qualities… which is funny, because she’s already seen the episode where Q begins to grow as a character. But that’s not until season three, so for now, I will have to provide a defense of Q by jumping back and forth across his timeline, as I so often do in my analytical work.
In season 1, it’s easy to hate Q – goodness knows Jean-Luc certainly does. This is a man who, to quote the captain himself, “At our first meeting you seized my vessel! You condemned all humans as savages, and on that charge you tried us in a post-atomic twenty first century court of horrors, where you attacked my people!”
And it’s true, he did do that. And he will go on to do much worse in the very next season. But, as no less than John de Lancie himself said, he believes that Q has a vested interest in “making sure that this man succeeds.” (According to the TVTropes page, anyway.) He just has a very strange, and admittedly off-putting, way of expressing it.
To explain this phenomenon, I think it’s worth comparing Q with Discord, the character played by John de Lancie across eight of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic’s nine seasons.
Explicitly created by Lauren Faust as a Q analogue, de Lancie’s voice performance in The Return of Harmony episodes (in which Discord debuts) does give one the feeling that the worlds of Star Trek and My Little Pony have intersected. One of the comic books even has a few panels set aboard the bridge of the Enterprise, with Discord wearing Q’s judges robes, implying that the two characters are one and the same.
(Certainly, this is the interpretation I’ve always run with in my fanfic work.)
So! With that in mind, let us proceed by assuming that this is the case, and Q really does spend a good amount of time visiting the ponies as often as he does the Enterprise crew. Over the course of Friendship is Magic, Discord is gradually reformed from the villain he started out as into more of a Trickster Mentor type figure, much like his inspiration. He’s still chaotic, but there’s more of a purpose to it now, a method behind the madness.
With so much room for character development, Discord becomes one of the most well-rounded characters on the show, outside of the main six. He forms friendships with all of them rather than just Fluttershy, and even proves to be the reason behind the return of Grogar and previous FIM villains over the course of season 9 – plunging Equestria into near apocalypse, it turned out, was his way of making sure that Twilight was ready to take the throne of Equestria and become its monarch.
Going by the timeline I established for my fics, Discord first breaks out of his stone prison in 2361, on stardate 38710.2. Two years later (2363) on stardate 40050.1, Princess Celestia tasks the Bearers, and Fluttershy in particular, with reforming Discord so that he can become a useful ally for the government. They are eventually successful. (This is depicted in “Keep Calm and Flutter On,” from FIM Season 3.) True, this doesn’t account for the way he acts in “Farpoint,” (which happens a a year after “Flutter On” in my notes) but I can explain this.
“S.D. 41153.7: Eager to return to the wider universe after a thousand years on Equus and (as Celestia calls it) “make some friends,” Q manifests aboard the USS Enterprise for the first time, as they are en route to Farpoint Station.” Q’s various costume changes and shifts in personality, in reality, were remnants of an earlier draft of the Q Continuum where all of the Q were discrete entities with John de Lancie’s face, but in my theory, this is just Discord doing his usual schtick that he does with the ponies – in “Twilight’s Kingdom” alone, Discord dresses up like Mary Poppins, a four star general, an alicorn, a toucan, a cop, and a stripper in a cake. (Yes, really.) Changing outfits is simply how he rolls.
More from my lore notes on Farpoint: “There, Q meets Captain Jean-Luc Picard, and decides to see how humanity has fared since his imprisonment by placing the entire species on trial. Picard serves as humanity’s representative.” I realize Q shouldn’t possibly know what humanity’s been up to since he was imprisoned sometime in Earth’s 14th century, but A) he’s an omnipotent being with a nonlinear relationship to time, and B) he probably got a cliff’s notes version of humanity’s development from somewhere, and is basing his “dangerous savage child race” argument based on that, like a high school student writing a paper on Sherlock Holmes based off the Robert Downey Jr movies and not Conan Doyle’s writings.
Here’s where things get really interesting. In my notes, the events of FIM’s fourth season finale, “Twilight’s Kingdom,” occur between “Farpoint” and “Hide and Q.” In “Twilight’s Kingdom,” Discord actually betrays the ponies after being sent to stop Tirek, only to be betrayed himself in part two.
Toward the end of the second episode, he tells Twilight: “Tirek tricked me into believing that he could offer me something more valuable than friendship. But there is nothing worth more. I see that now. He lied when he said that this medallion was given as a sign of gratitude and loyalty. But when I say that it is a sign of our true friendship, I am telling the truth.”
This is a crucial moment in Discord’s development, and after this, he is always an ally to the ponies of Equestria, never a villain to be fought. By the time we get to “Hide and Q” and Q’s testing of Commander Riker, I like to think he had the events of “Twilight’s Kingdom” at the back of his mind. He still acts like an egocentric asshole, but he’s an egocentric asshole who nearly got himself killed by a centaur with an attitude problem, so he decides to “make friends” the only way he can, by seeing what Riker does with phenomenal cosmic power.
Having had a taste of it himself by allying with Tirek, he might even be wondering if humanity can prove to be better than him at the whole “not going mad with power” thing, and sure enough, he’s proven right. In the text of the episode he frames all this by saying he’s concerned about humanity surpassing the Q, but I think that’s just cover. He doesn’t want to admit that he’s lost some confidence since the whole Tirek thing went south.
Obviously this head canon is ridiculous: TNG was made some 20 years before FIM, and I highly doubt that FIM’s writers have thought about these two characters to anywhere near the extent that I have, but that’s okay. Truth be told, I discovered JDL as Discord long before I saw him on TNG, so I’ve always sort of looked at Q through Discord’s lens. This is an entity who is trying, in his own way, to become a better person, whether through the help of some pastel ponies or Starfleet officers.
Then again, aren’t we all?
Leave a Reply