The scariest thing about Midnight isn’t the scenes where Sky steals the Doctor’s voice and almost gets him kicked out of the train car. It’s everything that happens before this moment – ignore Sky and the Doctor, focus on the rest of the cast and their reactions. They freak out about Sky repeating everyone and then talking in sync, and it doesn’t take very long for them to decide that the surest way of saving everyone is to murder Sky by tossing her out the door and into the sun, the same with the Doctor once his voice gets stolen.
What makes this so scary isn’t even how fast it all happens, but the fact that it happens at all. Make yourself look suspicious in any way whatsoever, and the next thing you know everyone is looking at you wondering if you’re the evil alien or the werewolf or whoever, and there’s nothing you can do to defend yourself.
I say this because I have been in this exact position several times before. You see, back in the day I used to play online Werewolf, and across the six games I was in, I only got killed by the wolves once. In four games I was executed on the third game-day, and in one, I would have been had someone else not come in with damning evidence that a third person was the real werewolf, not me.
Now, there is a caveat: two of my four executions were not actually because of things I did that made me look suspicious. One of them was simply the result of bad information that said I was evil despite being really innocent, and there was nothing anyone could do to turn the execution vote away from me and toward the person I suspected of being evil. The second time, the villagers had gotten themselves all worked up and thought the group had a mole, and since I was the only one who wasn’t verified good, I got the axe.
And this is just in a relatively innocent setting like a social deduction game – in the real world, this is all too common. Just look at the way the Nazis dehumanized Jews back in World War II, or what seemingly the entire western world is doing now with the Palestinians. As this episode is illustrating in miniature, it is all too easy for ordinary people to suddenly turn against one another for any reason at all… and none of us are immune.
Like, don’t tell me you wouldn’t abandon morality and reason in favor of your own selfish desires like the rest of the passengers did. Because you would, if kicking out Sky looked like the right thing to do. She’s suspicious, so she has to die. That’s what’s really terrifying about Midnight, is that the passengers are right to want Sky kicked off the train car. Once she’s pulled out at the end, the entity goes away and the Doctor is freed, but even before that happens, it’s clear that kicking Sky out is the only way to save everyone else. Given the right circumstances, we are all capable of becoming like the passengers.
Moving away from uncomfortable moral truths, we find what got us here in the first place. Per Shannon Patrick Sullivan, “Davies was inspired by the aggravating childhood habit of mimicking another’s words, and by the idea of an alien race which seemingly spoke gibberish, as suggested by the 1991 Star Trek: The Next Generation episode Darmok.”
This is surprising, because aside from the concept of an alien communicating in a way that the other characters are confused by, there’s exactly nothing “Darmok” has in common with Midnight, aside from the fact that the respective lead actors were once in the Royal Shakespeare Company, though not at the same time.
What Midnight most resembles, to me, is an earlier episode of TNG: “Allegiance” from season 3, wherein Captain Picard finds himself transported into a glorified prison cell with three other prisoners, and there is much suspicion and accusations thrown around as the four captives try to figure out who among them may be villainous. At one point, even Captain Picard himself is under suspicion!
Being Star Trek, of course, “Allegiance” never gets anywhere near as dark as Midnight does. Captain Picard’s various speeches as he tries to marshal the prisoners into acting reasonable are actually allowed to work, and his life is never placed under threat like the Doctor’s is. (Also there’s the B plot in which Picard is replaced with an alien imposter, who does things like sing sea shanties and romance Beverly Crusher, which does a lot to relieve any tension.)
One thing is pretty clear though: Captain Picard wouldn’t have an easier time of things if he got stuck on a train car with a bunch of passengers and a voice-stealing monster around. The Doctor only survives at all because the Hostess realizes that the Doctor’s had his voice stolen (Sky using his catchphrases gave the game away) and sacrifices herself and Sky to save the rest of the group.
Shockingly cynical as Midnight is, that doesn’t mean it isn’t enjoyable – it’s one of the scariest episodes of the show, period. It’s funny to watch it now, in light of Wild Blue Yonder, which serves as something like a sequel to this story. It’s the same basic concept (the Doctor is stuck in an isolated location with a monster around) but it’s a version of the story that takes into account the Capaldi and Whittaker eras as much as late Tennant.
I’d still rate Midnight higher though, for one very simple reason: the negative light humanity is thrown under in this story is devastatingly accurate. Just look at the COVID pandemic when Republicans yelled about the evils of mask mandates, or when Boris Johnson violated Britain’s lockdown rules so he could throw himself a party like a high schooler whose parents are away for the weekend as opposed to, you know, THE HEAD OF THE FUCKING BRITISH GOVERNMENT.
While I don’t subscribe to Davies’ cynicism all the time, I can at least understand the point he’s making. The inverse, of course, is that for every selfish human, there are those who stay true to their values and principles, no matter the situation. For every Professor Hobbes, there’s a Captain Picard.
And I know which of those two people I’d rather be.
Leave a Reply