Captain’s log, stardate 79023.4: Tensions mount as Counselor Troi’s arranged marriage nears, and her mother takes a liking to Captain Picard. Meanwhile, a plague ship threatens the planet where they are meeting.
There are exactly two characters on TNG who, when they arrive, you know the crew of the Enterprise are going to be put through all kinds of tests and challenges that go far beyond the mission statement described in the opening credits every week.
Q, obviously, was the first of these characters, asking the series to prove its mettle in a world where some people hated the show because it wasn’t TOS, (a complaint that echoes into the modern day) and in the face of late 1980s cynicism and the conservative counter-revolution that gave us Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher.
Lwaxana Troi is just as narrative-deforming as Q, but on a much less cosmic scale. If Q is the outside force that demands TNG prove its existence by confronting it with things that are much bigger than itself, Lwaxana does the exact opposite: she forces the show to engage on the human level, to ask what this sci-fi series about exploring deep space and meeting aliens has on offer for ordinary people.
This is key. As wonderful as “Where No Man” is, TNG couldn’t be that kind of show for 26 weeks out of the year. Even its transatlantic cousin, Doctor Who, understood that: The Mind Robber is great, but it’s not something you can do for more than a very limited window of time, be it five weeks or forty five minutes.
For my part, Star Trek (of any flavor) is at its best when it focuses on the human element – sci-fi as flavor and texture, but otherwise, a grounded drama about characters we can find relatable.
Case in point: Lwaxana Troi.
I am very, very familiar with characters like Lwaxana – hell, for nearly 30 years, I lived with a woman who was, in so many ways, not unlike her. Much like Mrs. Troi, my mother was overbearing to the point of smothering me, as described in the “My Beloved Smother” trope:
You probably know her. You might even live with her. A mother who tries too hard to control their children’s lives. Often (but certainly not always), they are the mothers of sons, and for whatever reasons can have a bit of trouble cutting the apron strings; as a result, no matter how old the boy (or, for added humor value, man) is, he’ll be mothered relentlessly, his mother absolutely smothering him with parental affection… and authority.
Using either carrot or stick (sometimes both), his mother will go to any lengths to make sure that, whether he wants to or not, he’s not going to be leaving his mother’s embrace any time soon. Any attempts on his part will usually result in a passive-aggressive guilt trip for trying to break away and do his own thing. Her poor son, as a result of such domination and badgering, usually ends up a Momma’s Boy. A lot of these mothers are Jewish for some reason, though they are also oftentimes Catholic, serving double duty as a conduit for Catholic guilt.
Change the gender pronouns around a bit, and you basically have what it was like to live with Kelly. She wasn’t Jewish (she was raised Irish Catholic, in fact) and everything she inflicted upon me fulfilled this trope to a tee. She would frequently suggest jobs she thought I should apply for despite having zero experience, like pharmacy tech (even though I used to work in the RETAIL section of Walgreens) or bank teller.
And when she wasn’t doing that, she was doing things like spending the majority of a shopping trip telling my girlfriend how awful I was, somehow managing to make my coming-out all about her and her emotions and feelings, making assumptions about what I would want, (or didn’t want) constantly stuck her nose into my business under a guise of “curiosity,” and generally treated me like I was a not especially bright nine year old… well into my late twenties. And she did all of this with a good-sized helping of passive-aggressive condescension.
It was not until my girlfriend came into the picture and charmed her way into Kelly’s good graces that I was able to move out and away from her. If not for Lykos, I’d still be living with Kelly, in that house, in that fucking shithole state of Missouri, miserable with absolutely no expectation of ever getting out of there short of, as Lykos calls it, “moving to Pine Box Avenue.”
Needless to say, I absolutely understand Deanna’s reaction whenever Lwaxana shows up. I’d have pretty much the same expression on my face, if I were a Starfleet officer and my mom were to materialize on the transporter pad for a visit. Much like Deanna, I’d rather deal with the Borg any day of the goddamn week.
What saves Lwaxana from being an uncomfortable, or even triggering, reminder of home is entirely down to the way Majel Barrett plays her. She is absolutely hilarious, and for all of the character’s bluster and bravado, there is a sense of genuine warmth to her, to say nothing of the fact that it’s hilarious to watch her throw Captain Picard completely off his game, to say nothing of the way she puts Mrs. Miller in her place. She is sublime.
Lwaxana is charming to watch, and you desperately want to see more of her – but like Q, she is best taken in small doses. Which begs the question: what would those two characters be like if placed in the same storyline? The show never thought to do this (it should’ve been Season 5’s Q story) but fortunately, that’s where the book line comes in.
Coming from 1991, Q-in-Law was written by Peter David, the Terrance Dicks of Star Trek novels, in that he was incredibly prolific. While I’ve not gotten to this one yet in my read through of the Next Gen novels, the synopsis sounds intriguing enough:
When two powerful rival families of the spacefaring merchant race called the Tizarin are to be joined through marriage, the USS Enterprise is chosen as the site for the wedding. Though Captain Picard is pleased by the happy duty, his pleasure is cut short by the arrival of the Federation delegate from Betazed: Lwaxana Troi—the mother of ship’s counselor, Deanna Troi.
Despite Lwaxana Troi’s romantic overtures toward the captain, the celebration seems to go smoothly until the situation is further complicated by the arrival of the notorious and all powerful being called Q—who has come to examine and challenge the Human concept of love. Suddenly, the festivities are in turmoil, the powerful Tizarin families are on the verge of war, and Lwaxana Troi is determined to teach Q a lesson in love that he will never forget…
Two totemic, powerful figures together in one story, making poor Jean-Luc’s life (and Troi’s) a living hell! Bad for him, bound to be entertaining for the rest of us! Small wonder they had to do this in a book: it’s the only way you could contain their combined power!
And apparently, de Lancie and Barrett read the audiobook version. Now I really want to read this!
Leave a Reply