“A cosmos without the Doctor scarcely bears thinking about,” said the Master in the show’s 20th anniversary story, The Five Doctors. 25 years later, we finally find out exactly what a universe without the Doctor would look like, and as one would expect, the results are extremely very not good.
Without Donna taking the job at HC Clements, the Doctor is killed when the Thames basically falls on top of him. The rest of the episode then presents various alternative explanations for the events of series 3 and 4: Sarah Jane’s group and Torchwood fill in for the Doctor… with devastating results. (Everyone dies offscreen, basically.)
In the aftermath, the UK goes through various totemic shifts: Southern Britain is rendered uninhabitable when the Titanic crashes into Buckingham Palace, and then later, the country turns fascist as labor camps are built, and a new policy of “England for the English” is instituted.
Filling the Doctor’s role in the narrative is Rose Tyler, who finally makes her proper return here after spending the entire season haunting the narrative by appearing in TV screens mouthing the Doctor’s name. Rose has obviously undergone truckloads of character development since we last saw her, becoming the nearest thing to the Doctor that UNIT has left… which is interesting, since in another few seasons the same thing will happen to Clara Oswald.
Then again, as we pointed out all the way back in the Doomsday post, Rose Tyler was basically the OG Clara anyway. Next time she’ll be back in her former role as The Doctor’s Companion, but here, Billie Piper turns in a performance that is miles away from the beleaguered shop assistant that we met in March 2005, and I love that for her.
It’s funny, watching Turn Left not only in the immediate aftermath of the 60th anniversary, (the Doctor’s line about something tying him and Donna together rings differently now, and it makes me very glad that particular story thread got a revisit) but in the aftermath of Moffat-era Who, which was very concerned with the death of the Doctor. The finales of series 5, 6, and 7 all dealt with it to one extent or another, and even the Capaldi era touched on it toward the end, as the Doctor wondered exactly why it was he kept on living for.
In a series like Doctor Who, especially in its modern conception where the Doctor is a totemic figure around which the rest of the narrative orbits, it is at least interesting to watch the resulting apocalypse unfold. Davies’ take is very expansive, even if we stay with the Noble family for most of the story, there are still hints and discussion of what’s happening beyond their perspective.
Watching Turn Left and remembering how Series 5 ends, I am left to wonder whether there might be more similarities beyond Donna and Amy than the fact that they’re both redheads.
Let’s start with the obvious: they both have personalities that can be described as blunt. But for Amy, this bluntness is a front she puts on, so she doesn’t have to deal with the pain that’s resulted from being abandoned by everyone, from her parents to her aunt Sharon to the Doctor himself. For Donna, this bluntness was a reaction to the heaps of emotional abuse thrown her way by Sylvia.
For another, neither of them have any particular romantic interest in the Doctor: Donna is an older woman for one thing, so any romantic subtext there would just look strange, and in Amy’s case (kissing scene in Flesh and Stone aside) she’s already got a love interest: Rory Williams, the future Last Centurion.
Third of all, both of them are incredibly important to their respective season arcs: Donna, in the episode after next, will go on to save the universe with a terrible price tag attached, while Amy is able to remember the Doctor back into existence, sparing the Earth from experiencing something akin to what happens in The Name of the Doctor two seasons early.
But as with Rose and Clara, the comparison is imperfect. In Davies’ world, to ascend to the Doctor’s level of narrative importance is to cross a boundary that no mortal should ever cross… a boundary that Moffat’s companions not only breach in their own ways, but they are in fact rewarded for it. Davies brings his companions back down to Earth, Moffat lets them fly.
Or at least, that’s how it was before 2023.
The end of The Giggle, to my knowledge, is only the second time in the history of modern Who in which the Doctor ends up with a family. And it makes perfect sense for the Tennant Doctor to close out this chapter of modern Who as a part of the Nobles, in the same way that much of series 6 was about the Eleventh Doctor becoming part of the Ponds. So, yes, I would say that Donna is reminiscent of Amy: it just took 15 years, and RTD watching the Moffat era itself, for the last piece to be fitted into place.
But there is a big ‘but’ here, and we all know what that is: the final scenes of Journey’s End. As wonderful as it is that the meta-crisis issue was dealt with eventually, there’s still no reason on Earth why it had to happen in the first fucking place. Even if, say, having Tennant and Smith act alongside each other in Journey’s End as Tennant and Gatwa do in The Giggle wasn’t on the table, I’m sure RTD could’ve found other ways to deal with Donna having the Doctor’s knowledge and skills, up to, and including, allowing her to give that up in a way that didn’t undo a season’s worth of character development.
We shouldn’t have needed to wait 15 years for a happy ending, we could have been provided one at the outset. It’s still inexcusable, it’s still violating, it’s still completely unnecessary.
One can only hope, looking to the future, that nothing like this ever happens again.
So then, what of the rest of this story? You definitely get the sense that this is RTD doing a season finale to end all season finales, what with the return of not just the Daleks, but Davros too, on top of the three-way crossover between Doctor Who, Torchwood, and The Sarah Jane Adventures, and the resulting cavalcade of companions and recurring characters, from Harriet Jones to Trinity Wells and everyone in between. It’s Davies’ best finale ever, or at least his best since Bad Wolf/Parting.
Shame, then, that the mind-wipe damns it.
Leave a Reply