Wolf Trek: Datalore

Captain’s log, stardate 79061.7: When the Enterprise visits Data’s home planet, they discover another android of the same construction. However, when ‘Lore’ is activated it quickly becomes clear he is nothing like Data, and the Enterprise is soon in extreme danger.


With this episode, we are now halfway through the first season of TNG, and despite what fandom consensus will tell you, I think this season of the show is much, much stronger than most people give it credit for. Yes, there are bad parts: “Code of Honor” springs to mind, or the very next episode, “Angel One,” where the entire premise is A WORLD WHERE WOMEN RUN THE GOVERNMENT!!!!

But there is also a lot of brilliance. Check out “Where No One Has Gone Before,” or “The Big Goodbye,” the first ever holodeck episode. And now you have TNG’s lucky thirteenth episode, “Datalore.”

“Datalore,” very simply, is one of Brent Spiner’s finest hours in early TNG. He had a very difficult job in this episode, since he plays not only Data, but also Lore, and Lore pretending to be Data. And apparently, all this was his idea! And it’s not hard to see why – playing an evil version of a character is really fun! Just look at Trek’s long history of mirror universe episodes for example.

That said, Lore is more than “evil Data.” He’s what Data would be if A) he could process emotions, and B) lived only for advancing his own self-interest, whether it’s murdering the colonists or the crew of the Enterprise. Where Data looks at humans with curiosity and aspiration, Lore sees cannon fodder.

I really, really love the way Spiner plays Lore: A smug, insufferable, smirking jackass who can, when needed, play innocent perfectly. Just watch the way he initially interacts with the bridge crew, as Geordi is teaching him how the helm console works, then watch him a few minutes later, when he subdues Data with a spiked glass of champagne. It’s amazing!

The best performance of the episode, though, is during the last third of the story, when Lore goes onto the bridge in Data’s uniform and pretends to be him… except he makes a lot of mistakes. As Spock observed in TOS’s “Mirror, Mirror,” “It was far easier for you as civilized men to behave like barbarians, than it was for them as barbarians to behave like civilized men.”

This is equally true of Lore’s brief impersonation, from referring to Riker by his last name rather than by his rank, to the way he doesn’t understand what Picard’s “make it so” means. And of course, all the times where the mask slips, like when he says, “Beautiful, isn’t it?” about the giant snowflake, which Wesley picks up on. It’s brilliant acting from Spiner, and even though I’ve seen this episode several times already, even I can’t help but be briefly fooled by the switch.

The rest of the regulars favor slightly less well. I understand that for the plot to work, the senior staff can’t believe Wesley when he tries to warn them about the impersonation on the bridge, but come on. For all that our acting ensign can drive us nuts, he’s still a smart kid, and he deserves a lot better than three successive “Shut up Wesley!”s in a row, including from his own mother. (At least Patrick Stewart gives us a look of befuddlement during all this.)

One amusing anecdote from the making of this episode concerns one Chief Engineer Argyle. Played by Biff Yeager, he’s the longest-lasting of season 1’s rotating cast of engineering heads, and may have even been considered to become a regular… until he started mailing himself fan letters. He was, of course, subsequently fired.

And let’s be real, can you imagine anyone other than Geordi La Forge as chief engineer? I sure can’t! The man belongs down there, and before long, he’ll even get the chance to prove it in “The Arsenal of Freedom.”

One aspect of the episode that doesn’t get a lot of attention, and really should, is this scene in the ready room:

PICARD: I’m also a bit troubled by it describing you as imperfect.
DATA: Human language gives me difficulty too, sir. Imperfect could mean I lack certain abilities he possesses.
PICARD: I wonder. But the point of this is, whether you and it have approximately the same capabilities.
DATA: We do, sir, and your referring to him as an it suggests that I, too, fit into the category of a thing.
PICARD: I see your point. My apologies.
DATA: Gladly accepted, sir.

It’s a very subtle moment, but Data’s gentle chastising of Picard for referring to Lore as a machine, and the lesson in personhood it provides, is one of the first shifts in Picard’s characterization. This moment is what allows him to grow, and to defend Data’s right to live in “The Schizoid Man,” and of course, to support his friend in court in “The Measure of a Man,” and to campaign for the rights of sentient lifeforms in general during season one of Picard. Jean-Luc is a bit of a prickly character in early TNG, but the ready room scene plants the seeds for the compassionate man he’ll become by season three.

Then there’s the fact that a TV show in the late 1980s is even discussing the concept of preferred pronouns. In 1988, no one making this show could’ve possibly known how important that concept would become 36 years down the line. Today, as the transgender community becomes even more visible, the simple act of identifying one’s pronouns in Twitter bios, email signatures, and other places has made it easier for us to feel more comfortable with being ourselves among our cisgender friends and family.

As someone who often uses neopronouns to refer to loupself, the correct form of address matters to me. Plus, as a trans woman, I get exhausted when I go home to visit family and am confronted with an avalanche of he/hims, when what I want is she/her. (Or just loup, but good luck explaining neopronouns to my 80-something year old grandma.)

Needless to say, I completely get where Data is coming from the ready room scene, and I am profoundly glad that something like misgendering is not only being shown in sci-fi from the late 1980s, but that it’s treated casually. Picard apologizes, Data accepts, and the conversation moves on. With all the drama being made around pronouns of any sort these days, it really says something that Trek, for all of its many shortfalls with regard to queer rep, got this one right on the first try.

So, to the shitheads out there who complain that “STAR TREK IS WOKE NOW!!!” I say, “Star Trek was always woke, dipshits.” (Sometimes.)

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑