It would be easy, looking at the bare facts of casting and plot, to accuse RTD of pandering only to the people who last watched the show in 2008 when he was last in charge. Certainly, I’ve seen some rumblings on Twitter to this effect – RTD is perfectly happy to call back to his own era and the one just passed, without apparently acknowledging anything about the eras that happened from 2010 to 2017 beyond a throwaway line or two.
But in my opinion, this is doing Davies a disservice. This is a man who deeply loves this series, and has more than likely watched every single episode that has aired since he left, from The Eleventh Hour to The Power of the Doctor. This isn’t just RTD playing the old hits in a slightly different way, this is RTD building off of what his predecessors did, in the same way The Day of the Doctor was Steven Moffat building off of what Davies himself did in his first era.
To whit: this episode, for me, is a great big Capaldi era shout-out. The most obvious is Heaven Sent – that was the show’s first-ever two-hander, where the only characters for the vast majority of the episode were the Doctor and the Veil creature. Heaven Sent is widely regarded to be one of the Capaldi era’s best stories, so it’s no surprise that RTD would return to that well and put his own spin on the two-hander concept.
For a two-hander to work, you have to have really good actors to carry all that dialogue. In Moffat’s conception, this ended up with the Doctor spending almost the entire episode monologuing to an imaginary version of Clara, and thus the audience for 50 minutes. Such a premise shouldn’t work on paper, but it does, because Peter Capaldi was the best actor to play the Doctor ever. No one but him could’ve pulled that off, and I say this as someone who has written quite a bit about how excellent Matt Smith is.
Davies, thankfully, recognizes the strengths of his actors just as well as Moffat does, and he knows that Tennant and Tate have absolutely amazing chemistry, so that’s what he gives us for 60 minutes: Tennant and Tate, playing not only the Doctor and Donna, but also their evil alien doubles, the Not-Things. It is genius. Chibnall could never have done anything like this – for crying out loud, the nearest equivalent in the Whittaker era was written by Ed Hime.
So, plot-wise, this is the Davies era version of Heaven Sent, except not entirely. While there is a beautiful sequence where Not!Donna successfully tricks the Doctor into expositing and crying about the Flux incident from last season, (which feels like a million fucking years ago, nevermind two) it’s still not really about the Doctor and the various traumatic experiences he’s had for the last millennium.
Meta-commentary, generally speaking, isn’t really something Davies goes for too often, at least not to the extent that Moffat did. We know the Time War was a metaphor for the show being cancelled in 1989, and the Flux may be a similar metaphor for the Chibnall era almost getting the show canceled, but the average person doesn’t.
But I digress. If the plot is strongly reminiscent of Heaven Sent, the antagonists come from a much stranger place: Flatline. Out of all the monsters in the Capaldi era, I wasn’t expecting the Boneless to make a comeback… but here we are anyway!
Well, okay, comeback is the wrong word. The Not-Things are very much unique. But at the same time, if you’ve watched as much Who as I have, you know where the shout-outs are coming from, and the Not-Things are absolutely devoted to the Boneless. You can’t convince me otherwise.
Here’s what made the Boneless work so well: Just like the Not-Things, they were creatures that borrowed human form without entirely understanding what it was they were copying at first, though given the scenes where they advance down the tunnel and the Doctor comes out of the TARDIS to kick their two-dimensional asses, they were getting the picture quickly enough, at least.
The Not-Things are RTD’s version of the Boneless: once again we have an alien species that isn’t used to three dimensions (or any dimension really) and so they are the epitome of Uncanny, just like the Boneless were, but with the added twist that these are uncanny versions of characters we know, rather than one-off extras.
And because the Not-Things are uncanny versions of the Doctor and Donna, that means RTD can do things with them that Peter Harness couldn’t do with the Boneless. This results in things like using the jump-cuts between scenes to make us think that Donna is talking to the actual Doctor and vice versa… but watch carefully, and you can pick up who’s fake and who’s not.
When Not-Donna said, “I did what you said,” I turned to my girlfriend and said, “I don’t think that’s the real Donna.” She agreed, and the twin usage of the phrase “My arms are too long” only confirmed our suspicions. The gradual reveal that the Doctor and Donna were being copied on purpose carries shades of not just the Boneless, but of the Midnight entity from RTD’s previous era, another antagonist that had no physical form of its own.
The last of the Capaldi stories this resembles is another unexpected, but welcome, choice: Listen, specifically the sequences in which Clara and the Doctor travel all the way to the end of the universe, where there is no one left alive… and someone knocks on the door. Imagine that scene stretched out across 60 minutes, and you have this episode: in its totality, a great big tip of the proverbial hat to the Capaldi era.
Why is acknowledging the Capaldi era so important? Aside from the fact that it’s some of the best Doctor Who ever, it was not an era that was particularly beloved with the general public, for reasons we don’t have time to get into. So, Davies constructing a story built out of three different Capaldi episodes and throwing in a few nods to the Whittaker era is a subtle, but well-deserved statement of intent: all of Doctor Who is canon, not just the parts RTD himself was involved with.
Two weeks in, it’s abundantly clear that the 60th anniversary specials are taking a completely different tack to The Day of the Doctor, and I’m not just saying that because we have three specials this year and not just one. Davies is picking bits and pieces from all of modern Who, not just his bits, be it in dialogue, enemies, or how the stories themselves are conceptualized. Even the Toymaker is a re-imagined classic series villain now played by a name actor, just like Richard E. Grant’s version of the Great Intelligence. If you’re gonna steal, steal from the best.
So as it goes, I’m okay with the 60th specials being lighter on callbacks and references than Day was. We got all that out of our systems with Power of the Doctor, and from the looks of things, it’ll be a clean slate later this month when the Gatwa era finally arrives. That’s as it should be. We can only hang on to the past for so long, lest we be consumed by it.
Catching up with these now! Fantastic point about what the Flux represents, though surely not how Chibnall intended it.
A typo: I didn’t know Peter Harness wrote Flatline… 😛
LikeLike
Oh yeah, oops! What can I say, I was probably fried when I wrote this!
LikeLiked by 1 person