Time for another entry into the world of Mike Flanagan! This time around, our subject is the other show in the Haunting series, set this time at Bly Manor, a manor in the English countryside. It takes place in the late ‘80s, and follows an American au pair as she accepts a job to take care of the Wingrave children after the unfortunate death of their previous governess.
I’ve always had something of a fascination for upper-class British life. Some of that might just come from spending much of my childhood watching Disney’s Mary Poppins, coupled with some of the things I’ve written in my various fan fictional worlds: Gemini Shadow, the main protagonist in most of my fiction work, always called Shadowfall Manor her home, and the house in Bly pretty much fits my exact mental image of what Shadowfall looked like.
Needless to say, watching Bly Manor didn’t feel quite as alien to me as it might have to Dani Clayton – I’ve written stories about places like that before, so for me it felt like coming home. (Along with, it has to be said, flashbacks to when I attended Regent’s University in London for a study abroad program. There I was, a poor American from the Midwest, attending the same school as a bunch of classy Brits.)
What strikes me about Bly Manor is just how light it is, relatively speaking, for a Flanagan show. This isn’t Fall of the House of Usher where characters die in some spectacularly graphic ways, or Midnight Mass where you get to see people self-immolate, or Hill House with its scenes featuring bugs crawling out of cat corpses. The house in Bly Manor isn’t actively malicious like the one in Hill House – the ghost that haunts it does what it does because it doesn’t know what else to do, and it took Dani’s sacrifice to put things right.
The Wingraves, by and large, are far more put together compared to the Crains – sure, Henry’s an alcoholic and neglectful, but he manages to pull himself together and become a devoted father figure to Miles, and an actual father to Flora. Where the Crains spent a good chunk of their adult lives trying and failing to deal with the traumas they experienced at Hill House, Flora and Miles eventually grow up having no memory of that eventful summer, and no one seems too inclined to break that illusion. Who can blame them?
Having watched several of Flanagan’s shows before this one, Bly Manor retroactively sticks out to me because of just how much of its cast is familiar. Owen, the cook, was last seen in the Mactíre house as the sheriff of Crockett Island, and before that, the step brother of Victorine Lafourcade in Usher. After seeing those two have a go at each other in that show, it’s kind of a trip to see them in love here.
Then you have Henry Thomas, going from Frederick Usher to Riley’s dad in Midnight Mass (where all the facial hair made it impossible for me to tell it was him) and then to Hugh Crain, and now here, as lawyer Henry Wingrave. (For what it’s worth, I thought his RP accent in this show was pretty convincing, but I’m also American, so what the hell do I know.)
As with Hill House, Lykos and I caught a lot of resonance with our actual lives. The lead character, for example, is named Dani, the name Lykos first went by when we started dating. At one point we meet her first boyfriend, Eddie, a total asshole who looks a bit like pre-transition me, but acts like Lykos’s abusive ex-boyfriend.
But it’s not until Dani and Jamie get together, and especially the extended epilogue at the end of episode 9 where we see them live their lives in Vermont, that the resonance really becomes clear. The conversations those two share sound a lot like ones she and I have had, before and after I moved in with her, and we even live in the Northeast! (I floated Vermont as a possible place for us to move to entirely because of this show.)
I kind of think of Bly Manor as being Our Show, in much the same way that Wolfwalkers is Our Movie. One of the final scenes of episode 9, in which an older Jamie tells an adult (and American?!) Flora about how to live on in case her husband dies, might as well have been delivered to Lykos and I. I looked at her and said, “We are watching this the night before we get married,” and she agreed.
I think if I had to pick my favorite Flanagan shows, this one would take it, with Midnight Mass in second. And I never thought I’d get into horror. Perhaps because, as Adult Flora says at the end, this isn’t a ghost story, but a love story that just happens to have ghosts in it. It’s the kind of story I needed at a time where it feels like so much else in my life is crumbling around me at any given moment. It’s a reminder that love can endure, even when the conflict involves a ghost with no face murdering you because you got in her way of her nightly walk.
I had a difficult 2023. Injuries, being out of work for several months on end, a series of entirely avoidable unfortunate events that led to me inadvertently hurting people I once called friends, and those friends cutting off all ties with me… it was an absolute hell of a year, and while I hope 2024 is better, January has indicated it’s not exactly off to a rousing start.
(But at least my leg isn’t broken again. I’ve got that going for me.)
But I have hope. I still have my writing career, and as long as I’m on my best behavior, I don’t see that changing any time soon. Bly Manor, in its way, shows me that there’s value in hoping for the best, even if the best (as Lemony Snicket once wrote) like an interesting piece of mail, rarely arrives, and can be lost easily.
If Jamie and Dani can survive ghosts, I can survive 2024.
Happy New Year.
An interesting write up. I enjoyed this show immensely and hope to continue watching it again and again. Hopefully you are recovered from you injury. Pain can make us do stupid shit eh.
LikeLike