Wolf Trek: Coming of Age

Captain’s log, stardate 79289.1: Wesley is at Relva 7 to take his Academy entrance exams, while an inspection team board the Enterprise and it soon becomes clear they are investigating the capability of Captain Picard.


I really, really like this one. As I said a few weeks back in the “When the Bough Breaks” post, Wesley Crusher is a much better character than his early episodes this season would imply. Yes, he’s a wunderkind but even teen geniuses have to come back down to Earth eventually. While I’m still not completely sure what textual evidence exists to keep him from getting into the Academy at the end, I think it’s probably just as well that he’s not there yet. It humanizes him, and makes him more relatable for the audience at home.

L.I. Underhill, who used to write about Trek for Eruditorum Press, touched on this episode in 2014. They said:

“Captain Picard knows that to accept promotion would mean accepting stasis, and as an explorer at heart that’s not something he can support (and isn’t it interesting that Picard seems to equate Starfleet Command with toxic stasis?). But the word choice in both the script and Patrick Stewart’s delivery is very careful and particular: There’s a lot of talk about “where he belongs” and “what his path” is, and never about growing out of the Enterprise and leaving it behind. […] In fact, note the only criticism Remmick can come up with of Picard’s leadership is that his crew is “too familial” (and how telling it is that Starfleet Command would take issue with that).”

This is really interesting to me, not least because it puts me in mind of the movie Generations. Yes, it’s terrible, but the scenes where Patrick Stewart and William Shatner are on screen together are great, especially the part where Kirk explicitly tells Picard not to leave the Enterprise… except Picard is, eventually, forced into doing exactly that, and by the time we get to Star Trek: Picard, you can see that our Jean-Luc has gotten old and bitter entirely because he’s no longer on the bridge, making a difference.

A few weeks ago we talked about the history of Starfleet’s badmirals – flag officers who go stir crazy, and express that stir-craziness by doing things like inventing automated starships that inevitably turn murderous and kill everyone. The way Starfleet Command is portrayed here, by and large, becomes the standard by which it’s used in every 24th century Trek series that follows, including Picard, where it becomes literally antagonistic.

This should not come as much of a surprise. Star Trek, much like its British cousin Doctor Who, is about traveling, going to new places, and seeking out the unknown. And you can only really do that in a starship – even DS9, the one and only Trek show about a space station, where the weird comes to you, still had a ship attached to it so the characters could go places.

Whereas you can’t go anywhere once you take a desk job at Starfleet Command: you exchange a life of adventure for a life of simplicity and safety, and eventually, you’re there for so long that you forget what it was like to be on a starship in the first place. No one joins Starfleet because they want to be a vice-admiral, they join because they want to be in command of a starship, and get the comfiest chair on the bridge.

And Picard, quite rightly, turns down Quinn’s job offer. Sure, he would’ve been well within his rights to accept – he’s had a notable career in Starfleet already on the Stargazer, and even serving as an Enterprise captain for just a year would still put him on the same legendary pedestal as Kirk, Pike, and April. But he doesn’t, because he’s an explorer at heart… and because Picard already had an experience with a badmiral, in the Stargazer novels by Michael Jan Friedman.

In the book Gauntlet, the first book in the series, Admiral Arlen McAteer of Starbase 32 assigns Picard to hunt down the White Wolf, an infamous pirate… except that he’s been set up to fail. Why? That’s a bit of a long story, but I’ll try to summarize it as best I can.

In Friedman’s first Stargazer novel, The Valiant, Picard becomes acting captain when that ship’s original CO, Daithan Ruhalter, is killed during an ambush by an alien race known as the Nuyyad. Gauntlet opens a few months after Picard was formally made captain of the Stargazer by Admiral Mehdi, whom McAteer hates. So, to get revenge on both of them, McAteer gives Picard the White Wolf assignment, expecting that our boy Jean-Luc (and I can call him that because he’s fucking 28 years old at this point) will fail and be disgraced.

This being Captain Picard, McAteer’s plan fails completely. And we’re all okay with that, because Friedman gets on with the job of making him easy to hate pretty quickly:

“Soon, McAteer reflected, his garden would be free of useless undergrowth like Admiral Mehdi and unwanted weeds like that upstart Picard. It would only contain what he wanted it to contain, what he had handpicked and placed there personally.

He smiled just thinking about it. Picard had no chance to catch the White Wolf. None. He would look inept, inadequate—and even more so when the pirate was brought to justice. And he would be brought to justice. The admiral had absolutely no doubt of it.”

I like to imagine that when he gets Quinn’s job offer at the end of this episode, Picard remembers men like McAteer and is like, “No, I’m not going to let myself become a self-interested social climber like that guy. I’m gonna stay right here where I belong.”

Equally, it is very telling that Starfleet Command is not very big on the whole familial camaraderie thing. On a starship, unless you’re working under a total asshole like Gabriel Lorca or Liam Shaw, the crew becoming a found family is basically inevitable. It happens with all the crews. But once you’re off the ship and on your own, you start to get lonely.

In season 3 of Star Trek: Picard, Geordi actually has the temerity to argue that a starship crew isn’t a family… and then his daughter, Sidney, snaps him out of it by calling him out. Good for you, Sidney!

All of this is to say that Starfleet Command sucks, and the arc they’re seeding here (to be wrapped up in the penultimate episode of the season) will end up paying big dividends, story-wise, much later on.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑