Off the Beatle Track: The Esher Demos

We now enter 1968, the second-to-last full year of the Beatles’ time together, to find them at a crossroads. With Brian Epstein dead, the boys are left to manage their own affairs, so they start their own company (including a record label) called Apple, blissfully unaware that in about nine years from now, Steves Jobs and Wozniak will go on to do the same thing for their nascent computer company.

While they’re doing this, John has met, and is now dating, Yoko Ono, who keeps John company during recording sessions by moving a bed into the studio and establishing herself as a go-between for John and the other three Beatles. (Having now experienced for myself the sheer agony that is being without your partner for even ten minutes, I completely get what J&Y were thinking here.)

With all that going on, the band returns home from a trip to India in the spring of 1968, and reconvene at George’s house in the London suburb of Esher, eager to share the new songs they’ve been working on with each other. With only acoustic guitars at hand and George’s new tape machine, the band spends the day singing and playing songs together, like the world’s coolest campfire sing-along session.

The resulting tapes become known as the Esher demos, and floated around in bootleg circles for decades. The quality wasn’t great, but for those who knew where to find them, what you had was basically the White Album unplugged. A few selections eventually made it on to Anthology 3, but the full tapes didn’t come out until 2018, as part of the anniversary releases. Arranged to mirror the main album tracklist, the demos are a fascinating listen, with a few surprises thrown in. So, let’s go through them:


Back in the U.S.S.R.: Written by Paul as a Soviet Russia-inspired parody of Chuck Berry and the Beach Boys, this early take finds him with an almost complete first and second verse, save for a few wording changes, and even working out what the guitar solo will sound like on the finished album.

Dear Prudence: In which John shows off the fingerpicking style of guitar playing, taught by Donovan, by writing a touching ballad to Prudence Farrow, sister of actress Mia, to cheer her up when things went south for her during the India trip… as John himself explains toward the end of the demo. With just him and his guitar, singing softly, this version of the song really brings home just how good John is at ballads.

Glass Onion: My personal favorite song on the White Album, the demo version here was first released in 1996 on Anthology 3. This version is slightly longer and in stereo, and illustrates that John has most of the first verse written, along with the chorus, but that’s about as far as he’s gotten. It’s still pretty great though.

Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da: Next we get to Paul’s take on ska, and on this demo you can hear that influence a little stronger, since Paul tries to do a ska type vocal. It doesn’t really work, though. It’s still a promising track though, and follows the progression of the album version perfectly, since the lyrics are complete.

The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill: John’s story song about a stereotypical American Macho Man… except he’s also a mama’s boy. Some people find this song to be very tiresome, but I’ve always liked it. The demo version here includes the sound of barking dogs, and a complete set of lyrics.

While My Guitar Gently Weeps: While the best acoustic version of this song will always be on Anthology 3, this demo is pretty good as well, even if some of the lyrics are very different from the album version we all know and love. The structure is largely identical to the album, save for the lack of a solo.

Happiness Is A Warm Gun: One of the rare John songs to be composed from bits of three separate ones, this version of the song is lacking the “she’s not a girl who misses much” section, and consists largely of the “mother superior” section on a loop, since the lyrics aren’t done yet.

I’m So Tired: The other Lennon song to center around sleeping, or rather, insomnia brought about by how completely in love he is with Yoko. The lyrics here are largely as on the album version, though the demo is in a higher key. New to the song is a spoken-word section that ultimately doesn’t make the cut.

Blackbird: Paul’s ballad in response to the civil rights movement, this demo sounds largely identical to the album version, and follows its structure pretty closely.

Piggies: George’s first attempt at political commentary, which just gets even funnier in light of the rumors about David Cameron fucking a pig. The lyrics are largely the same as the album version, save for a change in what the pigs eat: pork chops here, rather than bacon.

Rocky Raccoon: This story song of Paul’s begins with the first chorus and second verse, giving something of an in-medias-res vibe to proceedings. The rest of the song is here though, even if the key is different from the final.

Julia: John’s touching acoustic ballad to his late mother, presented here in a different key from the album version, but containing the same finger-picking style as on “Dear Prudence.” It’s just as beautiful and haunting as the album version, and one of my favorite demos.

Yer Blues: Being used to the punk rock song that is the album version, hearing it here as an acoustic number is kind of a trip. Lyrically, about everything is here, though the “my mother was of the earth” lyric will get changed for the better known version between now and then.

Mother Nature’s Son: One of my favorite late-period Paul ballads, the acoustic-only accompaniment honestly does way more for me than the brass overdubs on the album version. Probably would’ve fit in well on Wild Life, if he’d released it in the early ‘70s as a solo artist.

Everybody’s Got Something To Hide Except For Me and My Monkey: As before, being better acquainted with the faster rock version, hearing it done on acoustic is very strange. Decent song though.

Sexy Sadie: Originally written about the Maharishi in relation to John’s disillusionment regarding him, George made him change it. The Anthology 2 version, vocal-wise, actually reminds me of John’s solo work from the Plastic Ono Band and Imagine eras, and I can catch some of that here too.

Revolution: So there’s been how many different versions of this song over the years? A lot. This one might be one of my all time favorites – with the handclaps serving as percussion, the whole vibe of this song makes it feel more like a forerunner to “Give Peace A Chance” than either the album or single versions do. Like, you can definitely tell the two songs were written by the same guy.

Honey Pie: I’ve never really liked Honey Pie much. It sounds a bit too much like something the British equivalent of Freddy Nagel would sing. But it means something to Paul, and this acoustic version isn’t bad.

Cry Baby Cry: The last of the White Album songs on the Esher tapes, this lullaby of John’s is largely complete, lyric-wise. I’ve always liked it, though I do miss the rat-a-tat-tat of Ringo’s drums as on the album version.

Sour Milk Sea: George returns with the first Esher song that doesn’t appear on the White Album. It was given to Jackie Lomax as a single, and was released in August 1968. I really like it, I wish the boys had done this properly. I’d take this over “Revolution 9.”

Junk: A Paul McCartney ballad, describing the contents of a junk shop. He tried to include it on White and Abbey Road, only for it to eventually land on McCartney, his first solo album. This version isn’t too different from the final, save for the occasional squeaks of microphone feedback.

Child of Nature: A song by John about his experiences in India, it’s a really pretty song, suggesting he finally found inner peace after so many years of strife. In a way, it’s his version of “Mother Nature’s Son.” It won’t survive in this form though – John took the melody and wrote new lyrics for it in 1971, turning it into “Jealous Guy.”

Circles: A haunting George tune featuring organ and lots of minor chords, this track wouldn’t see a proper recording until 1982, when it appeared on his Gone Troppo album from that year. It’s a bit too gloomy for my taste, and I like “Blue Jay Way.”

Mean Mr. Mustard: We all know this song best as one of the pieces for the famous medley on side 2 of Abbey Road, but this demo was where it began, and I really like it. It was also the basis for an amazing fan-made remix.

Polythene Pam: Another Abbey Road song, and the only version of it that could be described as complete, since “Bathroom Window” hasn’t been written yet. It rocks right along, acoustic guitars aside.

Not Guilty: Another George song that he tried to get on the White Album, only it didn’t happen. Instead, it came out on his own eponymous album, 1979’s George Harrison. My favorite version though is from Anthology 2, where it becomes the rocker it was always meant to be. John and Paul really missed a trick, not letting George have this one.

What’s the New Mary Jane: Closing out the Esher demos is a song that feels more like one of John’s poems from In His Own Write or A Spaniard in the Works than any Beatles song he ever did. As it goes, at least it’s an actual song. Kinda wish they’d used this instead of “Revolution 9,” if I’m honest.


For a long time, even up to May 2018 when Rob Sheffield wrote a column about the demos in Rolling Stone, the Esher tapes were viewed as the last time the Beatles could be heard playing music for the sake of it, and sounding like true friends. But as we know from watching Peter Jackson’s Get Back documentary series, the sessions for the album that became Let It Be were quite enjoyable too, especially once they left drafty Twickenham for their basement studio at 3 Savile Row.

That’s not to minimize the very real personal disasters and clashes that were hitting the band at this point in time, far from it. The group started to fall apart as soon as Brian Epstein died, it just took a while for everyone to realize what was happening.

But no matter the struggles going on in their personal lives, there was always the music. Once you get those four men in the room playing music together, they lock into place, and magic happens. That’s part of what makes this band so beloved – there is no one, in the entire history of recorded music, that can touch them.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑