Captain’s log, stardate 79346.6: When the Enterprise rescues four stranded freighter passengers, Captain Picard soon becomes embroiled in a dispute between neighboring worlds and faces the possibility of breaking the Prime Directive.
Attempting rescue of a crashed shuttlecraft, an Enterprise away team encounter a malevolent lifeform known as Armus. Soon tragedy strikes when the alien kills Lieutenant Yar in cold blood.
This week, a two-for-one special as we cover the last two episodes of Denise Crosby’s tenure on Star Trek: The Next Generation. While I normally prefer to do these episodically, I realized halfway through writing this that it probably makes more sense if I do them together, since Tasha is a big part of both episodes.
So let’s start with “Symbiosis,” otherwise known as The Anti-Drug Episode, because it was the 1980s and the height of the War on Drugs. The infamous scene wherein Tasha lectures Wesley about drugs and how they can “make you feel good” is easily excisable from the rest of the episode: it adds nothing to the story and it just comes across as Star Trek lecturing the kids in the audience about being “drug-free,” as though Denise Crosby had suddenly turned into a DARE instructor. Hell, Data even has a reaction shot at the end that can basically be described as, “Well, that was fucking weird.”
The best possible reading I can find for that scene is one that Denise Crosby herself endorsed. Quoting from the trope page: “Many fans interpreted Tasha’s Drugs Are Bad speech as her indirectly confessing to being a former addict herself, mostly just because it makes the scene feel less preachy, Tasha hardly ever got any character development, and from what we see of her home later on, it’s definitely the sort of place where drug use could easily be rampant.”
“Symbiosis” was Crosby’s last-filmed episode – if you look real close in the background as Picard and Beverly re-enter the turbolift, you can see her waving goodbye. So watched with that in mind, it’s almost too perfect that Tasha Yar was the one who got stuck with the anti-drug lecture.
Tasha, on paper, is an exceptionally flat character, she exists to say lines like “Hailing frequencies open, Captain,” and little else. She never gets any focus episodes of her own, and while there are episodes where she’s written like the competent Starfleet officer she’s supposed to be, those episodes are few and far between.
For an idea of what Tasha might be like if the show writers actually gave two shits about her, may I suggest the book Survivors by Jean Lorrah? I read it earlier this year, as part of my ongoing read through of the TNG novel line. I am pleased to report that it is excellent: it fleshes out Tasha’s relationship with Data considerably, as well as giving us a glimpse of what her life was like before Starfleet.
The frustrating thing is that it’s a book, and therefore not canon to the TV show. Which is a fucking shame, because the book could work really well as a TV show – maybe even a two-parter. But it never happened like that, because again, the TV writers couldn’t be bothered to give too much of a shit about Tasha.
For me, the funeral scene at the end of “Skin of Evil” rings very hollow. Much of what Tasha says to the rest of the crew during her speech simply doesn’t come up in the episodes themselves. I have no doubt that in-universe, all of this is true, but as a viewer, I feel a bit cheated. I wanted to see more of Tasha’s relationships with the rest of the crew! For crying out loud, the episode opens with her and Worf talking about a martial arts competition! Why did it have to be the one where she dies where we get to see something like this?!
Honest to god, I really grew to like Tasha on my first watch of TNG, and I still do. And it’s all down to how Denise Crosby plays her. Much like Elisabeth Sladen or Katy Manning on Doctor Who in the early 1970s, Crosby was very skilled at taking this nothing character and making her into someone we loved. The scene in “Farpoint” where she yells at the crowd of jeering humans about what Starfleet is is absolutely great, and how about all of her scenes on the planet in “Arsenal of Freedom?” There’s a great character there, but they couldn’t be bothered to write her.
Or rather, Gene Roddenberry couldn’t be bothered. According to LI Underhill’s entry in Vaka Rangi about “Skin of Evil,” they write: “For what it’s worth, Denise has in more recent years specifically fingered Roddenberry as the one who told her off, and that the show’s writers actually wanted to do more with Tasha, but were being forcibly prohibited from doing so.”
Which, now that I think about it, makes a lot of sense. For all that Roddenberry is hailed by the vast majority of Star Trek fandom as the “Great Bird of the Galaxy,” the truth of the matter is that the man was a sexist piece of shit. Just look at the way TOS shot female guest characters – soft lighting and a glow effect. Or the way in one episode, a female crewmember serves coffee on the bridge to her male superiors. And that’s before you get into the miniskirts.
(First of all, coffee around sensitive electronics?! Are you fucking crazy?! And second of all, GET YOUR OWN DAMN COFFEE, JIMMY KIRK! YOUR LEGS AREN’T BROKEN, ARE THEY?!)
It’s not until Roddenberry is sidelined at the start of season 3 that you get episodes that treats its female characters like people instead of being, basically, glorified extras. Even Tasha Yar herself gets a better episode, in the form of “Yesterday’s Enterprise,” my favorite-ever episode of TNG. I watched it with my fiancee immediately after “Skin of Evil,” and when it was over, she called it an absolutely perfect piece of Star Trek.
And it’s not hard to see why. It’s the only episode in the entire show that does justice to Tasha Yar, simply by dint of giving her another, better death that’s actually worthy of her. (True, they screw the pooch with the Sela reveal at the start of season five, but I prefer to ignore that particular revelation.)
If there is anything good to come out of the way Tasha was unceremoniously tossed aside in the first season of TNG, and missed out on seeing the show launch the science fiction revolution that we are still seeing ripples of today, it’s this: in the Picard episode “Surrender,” Data reveals he still has the Tasha hologram – proving that while her character may have been treated badly, the show never forgot her.
Leave a Reply