Off the Beatle Track: The White Album

Officially called The Beatles, absolutely everyone, including the Beatles themselves, more often refers to their 1968 eponymous album as The White Album, due to its stark white cover – only the band’s name appears, either embossed (as on the original LP and the 2018 remix) or written in grey text, as on the 1987 and 2009 CD releases. Designed by Richard Hamilton, it was a deliberate contrast to the colorful psychedelic explosions of Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour, and became equally distinctive.

The simplicity of the cover, though, belies an album that is as rich and complex as any other Beatles release. With that intentional step away from psychedelic excess, the White Album shows the band beginning a path back to their roots as a mere rock band, albeit an exceedingly talented one. After all, what’s left to prove? They’re the biggest band on the face of the earth, and the masters of their own destiny now. They get to do whatever the hell they want.

For years, the White Album had the reputation as being the album where the first cracks begin to show in the band’s unity. The sessions were fractious, with Ringo even leaving the band at one point. Things were not helped by Yoko Ono, John’s new girlfriend, spending most of her time at the studios during recording, changing the entire atmosphere. Coupled with the band increasingly spending their time pursuing their own interests rather than working together, you really do get the impression that the received wisdom is right about this album.

But not according to Giles Martin, son of George Martin. When he remixed this album in 2018 for its 50th anniversary, even he thought this was the tension album, and said so to the BBC, but listening to the album’s session tapes led to an epiphany:

“The biggest thing was I always believed the White Album was an unhappy and fragmented record made by four solo Beatles, all working in different rooms. And it wasn’t that. If you listen to the outtakes, it’s a hugely collaborative process.”

“Listen to the sessions — they were very warm. And that’s the surprising thing. I think we thought the ‘White Album’ was this disparate, angry record — and it has certainly elements of that — but, in essence, the four of them made an album together they wanted to make.”

Some people have said, including Ringo and George Martin, that the album’s length is a turn-off: rather than have a double album that takes an hour and 20 minutes to listen to with songs that aren’t that great, why not have a single disc filled with the best pieces? Many have tried to compile such an album, but for my money, all of these people are mistaken. Just listen to Paul on the subject:

“I think it was a very good album. It stood up, but it wasn’t a pleasant one to make. Then again, sometimes those things work for your art. The fact that it’s got so much on it is one of the things that’s cool about it. The songs are very varied. I think it’s a fine album.”

I’m with Paul on this. Yes, listening to it is an undertaking, but there’s so much about it that’s rewarding. You get to hear about all the things the band are into at this moment, you get to listen to them experiment and invent new genres just because they can. It’s a complex piece of art, the White Album, and I love it. One of my top five albums, if I’m honest.

On to the deep dive:

Disc 1


Back in the USSR: Now that we can hear it in its finished form, this Paul McCartney rocker is one of the best album openers we’ve had in some time, and it really shows off just how deep his voice has gotten since “I Saw Her Standing There.” It’s oozing with confidence, this song, and states quite clearly that the psychedelics are over, once and for all.

Dear Prudence: John’s touching ballad to Prudence Farrow was lovely in its acoustic form, and it really shines now with its proper instrumentation. That’s not Ringo on the drums though – it’s Paul, because Ringo briefly left the band when these two songs were being recorded.

Glass Onion: Ringo is back! And you can tell, just from how confidently he starts the song off the two-beat thing that he does. The rest of the song, written as another response to Beatles fans who read too much into his lyrics, was always one of my favorites. Just listen to all those callbacks! This is great! (As for why the snare sounds the way it does in the third verse? That’s Ken Scott screwing up. The other Beatles liked it. Source: he told me himself!)

Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da: I think I might be the only person in the world who actually likes this song, goodness knows the Beatles sure didn’t. (Except Paul.) Allegedly, the piano intro came about because John was high and pissed off, so he just did it, right there. My favorite part is the fourth verse, where Desmond is described as “staying at home and doing his pretty face,” which just leads me to believe that she’s a trans lesbian. Source: the very next line, where she’s described as being a singer with Molly’s band.

Wild Honey Pie: I really hate this song. It should’ve been taken off, and indeed I used to do exactly that as a kid, before I became a completionist and favored an “unabridged” White Album.

The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill: Written about an ignorant shithead American who took a break from meditation sessions to go shoot tigers, John really hated this guy, and it shows in the lyric. John is really good when he’s being snide, I find. And yes, that’s Yoko popping up toward the end of the last verse. Hi Yoko!

While My Guitar Gently Weeps: If you want proof that George is increasingly outgrowing the Beatles, this should be argument enough. This is one of my all time favorite songs of his, serving as it does as a commentary on the band’s rapid disintegration. I would also like to congratulate Hatsune Miku for finding a time machine and performing the solo on this track, because otherwise, I’d have to complain about George having terrible taste in friends. (Eric Clapton is a racist piece of shit, and I really question George glossing over this over the ensuing decades.)

Happiness Is A Warm Gun: Derived from a gun magazine, this double entendre about guns and sex is honestly kind of difficult to listen to, given the circumstances under which John was murdered. It’s a good song, but a little depressing in hindsight.

Martha My Dear: In which Paul writes a cheerful piano ditty named after his sheepdog Martha, though the lyrics imply this was about his break-up with Jane Asher. Given their turbulent relationship since freaking Rubber Soul, I’m surprised it took them this long to split.

I’m So Tired: The inverse of “I’m Only Sleeping,” as John is kept awake at night, pre-occupied with thoughts of Yoko. More audible in the mono mix is Paul’s backing vocals under the chorus. More of him experimenting with his deeper singing voice!

Blackbird: Hearing Paul’s deeper vocal here, and then his higher vocal where he still largely sounds like he did in 1964, really brings home just how good his range was, and for a really long time. It’s not until you hit his Off The Ground album, from 1993, where he starts to sound middle aged.

Piggies: I still really like this song, but it’s even better now that we have pig sound effects added in. You have to love the classical music instrumentation backing George’s sarcastic lyrics about the pigs. Thinking about the British political situation, are we, George? I feel like this is a anti-Tory song.

Rocky Raccoon: Paul’s American accent sucks, but on the other paw, it’d just be weird if he did it with his normal Scouse accent, so… points for getting into character, I suppose. Fun fact: this is the last Beatles song to feature John on harmonica. That mainstay of the early days, back for one last rodeo. Bless. ❤

Don’t Pass Me By: Staying with the country theme, this song is the first one to be written by Ringo alone. The country vibe fits Ringo very well, given that (I believe) he took his name from the John Wayne movie Stagecoach.

Why Don’t We Do It In the Road: In which Paul shows off his lower register again, because why not. I love this quality of his voice, and it’s honestly too bad that this version of it doesn’t last after about 1970.

I Will: At the completely different end of Paul’s register is this touching love song, featuring my favorite melody of his. We don’t often get straight love songs like this on Beatles records anymore, so it’s nice to hear them go back to basics again.

Julia: One of two tribute songs John wrote about his mother, this one is easily my favorite, with just a touch of Yoko in the lyrics. After all this time, John found someone he could be himself with, and begin to heal. I know from experience how important that is. If only he’d lived longer…


Disc 2


Birthday: The Beatles do a birthday song to start off the second half of the album, and I really love this one. I listen to it every year on my own birthday, and it’s a fantastic way to start the day off! Like my favorite band in the world is singing “Happy birthday” just for me. ❤ Love ya, boys.

Yer Blues: Now that’s more like it! John’s blues number rocks as hard as anything else on this album, and I unabashedly love it. He wrote it as a parody of British blues music, and as parodies go, it’s a million times better than “Run For Your Life.” (And, IMO, better than anything the Stones have ever done.)

Mother Nature’s Son: Another really pretty acoustic ballad by Paul, though the horn section doesn’t really do it for me. A version of the song without those overdubs is available on Anthology 2, and I know which I prefer.

Everybody’s Got Something to Hide Except For Me and My Monkey: There’s a definite sense that the India trip completely re-energized John Lennon, the man is all over this album, and this is one of his best screaming rockers. Not done one of those for several albums now, and it’s really fucking great.

Sexy Sadie: In which John gets snide again, and it’s kind of amazing to behold. I admit I prefer the slower version of this song from Anthology 2, but this is pretty good too. As before, the way he sings here reminds me of some of his vocal stylings during the early part of his solo career, particularly Plastic Ono Band. (We’ll get to the solo stuff later on, I think.)

Helter Skelter: Staying with the hard rock theme of the past few songs, here is Paul casually inventing heavy metal, entirely so he could outdo the Who. Paul’s sheer determination is one of my favorite things about him, this song is probably one of the hardest (if not the hardest) rock songs they ever did.. and it’s about a carnival attraction. Bless. ❤ No “I’ve got blisters on my fingers!” though, if you’re listening to the mono version like I am. Stereo mixes only.

Long, Long, Long: In which George does a late-60s Dylan pastiche, except it’s about God. “I think all love is part of a universal love,” he explained to Rolling Stone years later. “When you love a woman, it’s the God in her that you see.” And you know what? He’s right. I might be an atheist, but I can sure see something of God in my girlfriend.

Revolution: This is the song that kickstarts the political angle to John’s songwriting that he’ll carry with him into his solo records, though by the mid-70s, he’ll end up softening his harder stances, likely out of fear of further persecution from the Nixon administration. There are two major versions of this song, and personally, I prefer the faster one. (Especially the live vocal one, where Paul and George do the shoop-be-do-wa vocals again.)

Honey Pie: Once again, Paul doing a pastiche of British music hall traditions, though to me it sounds like something I’d expect from a transatlantic version of Freddy Nagel, he of “Honkin’ the Horn for Honey” and “Sophisticated Swing” fame.

Savoy Truffle: George with another rock song, as he returns to guitar following spending a couple years learning the sitar. This time it’s about a box of chocolates, and Eric Clapton’s resulting cavities from eating too much of it.

Cry Baby Cry: John does a nursery rhyme song, including some lines from the actual nursery rhyme “Sing a Song of Sixpence.” My favorite thing about it is Ringo’s drum part, especially the snare hits between repetitions of the title phrase in the chorus. Paul’s little bit at the end remains creepy as fuck.

Revolution 9: Sophie says she likes this one, and for the life of me I don’t understand why. I’ve always found it kind of unnerving and creepy. Lennon said he was trying to paint a picture of a revolution using sound, and… well, he succeeded. I guess.

Good Night: And at long last, Ringo comes in to end the album with a sweet lullaby, wishing us all good night. Written by John for Julian, my personal favorite version of the song is available on the super deluxe White Album set: John, Paul, George, and Ringo singing the song together, over the sound of John’s fingerpicking guitar part. It’s lovely, and I dearly wish they’d used this take on the album instead. At a time when the band seemed to be falling apart, this burst of group unity is exactly what they needed.


The White Album is a controversial record, and absolutely everybody has a different thing to say about it. It’s raw, it’s uncompromising, it pulls no punches, and it’s heavy, but there’s a sweetness to it as well. The fact that it’s so long, and plays with so many different genres of music, means that there’s something for everyone. That’s part of what makes everyone’s attempts at doing a single disc version so interesting, because what one person hates, another might love.

It’s not quite a preview of what the band’s respective solo eras would sound like – the specific qualities of Beatles music pervades these songs, even on occasions where it’s just one or two of them playing. But at the same time, you do get something of a sneak preview of the future.

It remains amazing to me just how much the band changed in the five years between the release of this album, and the earlier With The Beatles. You’d never guess those two albums were made by the same band, they come from completely different sonic planets. But as I say, when you reach the level of stardom the Beatles did, you can do pretty much anything you like. Just look at Taylor Swift re-recording her old albums, or Duran Duran doing a Halloween record.

I think I would say that the White Album is the Beatles’ most human record. Which might sound strange, but when you live in a world where they are held up as being titans of the music world whose fame reaches heights unseen by anyone before or since, it’s nice to have an album where you realize just how human they really were. They make mistakes, they make snide comments at other members of the band, they have fights and disagreements… and when the moment comes, they show love, kindness, and generosity, things that feel in short supply these days.

That’s the magic of the White Album for me: the human experience, summed up in 90 minutes of music.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑