Off the Beatle Track: Yellow Submarine (Album)

Recently, I have been reading Up Periscope Yellow by Al Brodax, his account of how the Yellow Submarine movie (and the weekly cartoon show for ABC that preceded it, The Beatles) was made. It’s a hilarious book, and incredibly charming – all four Beatles make cameos, and it’s really interesting to see the phenomenon of this band from a completely different perspective.

One thing you learn quickly is that Beatlemania was a real thing. Like, even full-grown adults like Brodax and his team at King Features fell under the Beatle spell. There’s no ambiguity here, they touched absolutely everyone, even professional animators. And something like that is exceedingly rare. So when something like that comes along, of course you want to celebrate it. Brodax saw an opportunity with the Beatles, and pursued it.

Yellow Submarine is by far and away the best of his two Beatles cartoons – I’ve seen episodes of the show, and it sucks. There’s a reason why Apple Corps pretends it doesn’t exist. (Well, that and it’s flamingly racist in a way that would jar spectacularly with how the band has historically been marketed over the decades.)

But anyway – this post isn’t about the movie, but about the album. I didn’t mention this last time, but the White Album was the last-ever Beatles album to be issued with a genuine mono mix. Thus, Yellow Submarine is the first album to be mixed specifically for stereo, one of only three for which this is the case. (Or four, if we count Get Back.)

Like Magical Mystery Tour, Yellow Submarine is primarily a film soundtrack, with the six movie songs on side 1, while side 2 contains the orchestral score by George Martin, not unlike the American version of A Hard Day’s Night.

Unlike any of the previous soundtracks we’ve looked at though, only two of the songs featured here were written specifically for the movie: “Hey Bulldog” and “All Together now.” The title song, of course, comes from Revolver, “Only A Northern Song” and “It’s All Too Much” were both recorded during the Pepper era, and “All You Need is Love” was a single.

So, okay, we have a contactual obligation album composed primarily of songs the Beatles had lying around, including two songs that were previous released on other albums. That probably means it sucks, right? It’s a throwaway record.

Except no it’s not, because what the Beatles would dismiss as throwaways are still absolutely incredible tracks. So let’s look at those “four humiliations,” as John refers to them in Brodax’s book, and give them a fair shake, along with all the other songs on this album:


Yellow Submarine: If you’re going to write an entire movie based on a Lennon-McCartney song, “Yellow Submarine” is probably your best choice. The song just lends itself ridiculously well to this kind of movie, and I love how it’s used in the film, coming in after the prologue. The Blue Meanies have just taken over Pepperland, Old Fred flies off to go and find help, and this song comes in to save the day! If only real life worked like that…

Only A Northern Song: George wrote this song as a dry, sardonic response to the way he was being treated as a songwriter, and it becomes the first song in what might be called his anti-Beatle phase. He was genuinely sick of being in the band by 1967, a feeling that only got stronger as the years went by. Hard not to blame him, honestly.

All Together Now: Another children’s song from Paul that’s almost exactly as innocent as you’d hope it would be, except for one line after the first chorus. It’s hard not to like this song anyway, even if Paul thought it was a throwaway – listen to the way the tempo gradually speeds up over the course of the track.

Hey Bulldog: Good grief do I love this song, it’s absolutely fucking great. One of the best rock songs the Beatles ever did, and it’s buried on what is by some distance the least-loved album in their catalogue. I could listen to it all day! Ringo and Paul have the time of their lives in the rhythm section, the guitar solo is amazing, and the end where John and Paul screw around and bark?! It’s hard not to get swept up in it!

It’s All Too Much: Remember the feedback at the start of “I Feel Fine?” This is that, taken up to like eleven or something. It’s kind of amazing – one of the best songs of the psychedelic era, and again, it’s buried here on a soundtrack album. It’s utilized well in the movie though, as kind of an epilogue over the happy ending.

All You Need is Love: According to Al Brodax’s book, the sequence in the movie where this song was used to defeat the Glove was animated first, and it’s not hard to see why – it’s the centerpiece of the whole movie, and I love it. It’s another way of expressing the meaning of the lyrics! This is why the Beatles are so beloved, and always will be.

Pepperland: Honestly, this track reminds me of my childhood, when I was about seven or so, and watching this movie on DVD. I’ve always liked classical music, and I honestly believe Yellow Submarine is part of why. It’s pure utopia, this piece. George Martin really was an amazing arranger.

Sea of Time: I remember the beginning of this piece mainly from watching the movie trailer a zillion times, where it played over a scene of some smokestacks before cutting to “Eleanor Rigby.” The rest of it I don’t recall, but I know it’s in the film. I should watch it again, now that I have it on Blu-Ray.

Sea of Holes: Shortest sea we see in the movie, and yet it has the coolest background music. Nice and eerie, with some nice reversed effects in places.

Sea of Monsters: I will never not associate this piece with the movie scene where poor Ringo ends up getting ejected, and the rest of the Beatles have to send the cavalry to rescue him. He shouldn’t have pushed the button!

March of the Meanies: Tense and ominous and spooky, exactly what the Blue Meanies deserve. There’s a particular passage at 35 seconds in that I really like, it pops up a lot in this track.

Pepperland Laid Waste: The sound of the apocalypse, here. Or rather, the aftermath of the apocalypse. Martin does a great job illustrating the fleeting moments of joy that pop up here and there, only to get smashed down by the Meanies. And that leads us perfectly into the finale…

Yellow Submarine in Pepperland: Reprising our title song, here comes the titular submersible to save the day, in a truly grand orchestration that I can’t get enough of. It’s cheerful and whimsical, with just a touch of the nautical, and a perfect ending to this oft-ignored, unloved album.


Yellow Submarine, by Beatles standards, is their weakest album. Only six songs by the band, four of which were glorified cast-offs, and the rest of the tracks are instrumental pieces by George Martin. And whenever discussion comes up about this album, that’s usually the end of it. Even at the time, people thought it sucked. No wonder, 30 years later, they came out with the Yellow Submarine Songtrack, AKA all the songs featured in the movie, with no Martin stuff.

But look at what you get on this album: an anthem about the power of love, an immortal children’s classic, two great George numbers that illustrate his growth as a songwriter since the days of “Don’t Bother Me,” one of the best rock songs the Beatles ever did, and Paul’s second-ever attempt at an actual children’s song. And you get George Martin’s beautiful score as well, so if you like what he’s done for Beatles songs, you might like this!

Is it their best album? Not at all. Is it better than most people give it credit for? Absolutely. That’s my story, and I’m sticking to it.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑