It’s been a very long time since I’ve been able to say this, so I’ll say it now:
I enjoyed watching Doctor Who.
Like, over the past several years, I very quickly and rather publicly fell out of love with Who and fell into Star Trek. (If you read my old Adventures in Narrative Substitution series, you can see the out-of-love-falling happen basically in real time.) And in the span of two episodes, I am now so firmly back on team Who it’s giving me whiplash.
The show is good, you guys. Hell, I’d even go so far as to say that this is the best the show has been in seven years, ever since Moffat took his final bows. (And now he’s back for an encore next week?!)
Which says two things: Thing 1 – Doctor Who got really bad under the previous era. Thing 2 – RTD is exceptional at making us forget all about that era, even when he follows on from concepts introduced in it.
So, I can forgive the admittedly clunky opening scene in the TARDIS console room because, as my wonderful pal Frezno observed in their first impression post, the show isn’t made for me anymore, or at least, not entirely: “The show hasn’t been this explanatory and introductory about its basic fundamentals since The Pilot with Peter Capaldi. The Gen Alpha kids for whom this is the new exciting show on Disney+ have no idea who the fuck Peter Capaldi is, having been Earth Babies in 2017 when we were talking about 12 and Bill and Nardole.”
Basically, I haven’t watched a show this outside of my generational wheelhouse since the pilot episode of Friendship is Magic all the way back in 2010. And then, as now, I don’t care because the show really is that good.
Anyway, on to the actual content of the episode. Last year, RTD said this: “Sometimes, little surprises happen, way beyond anything we could predict. The other day, someone in Star Trek: Picard suddenly said one of our episode titles out loud! Okay, that’s hardly surprising in a show where someone’s always saying ‘This could be… The End of the Galaxy!’ But it was odder than that.”
And then it turned out that the line in question was “Space Babies,” as said by Jack Crusher (no, not that one, the other one) and Will Riker in the episode “No Win Scenario.”
BUT WAIT, THERE’S MORE! Because here we are in 2024 and we get the Doctor implying that the Star Trek universe is a real place that him and Ruby can travel to, and if that wasn’t enough, a subsequent interview with Collider from RTD, and he had this to say: “I’m coming to love Star Trek with an absolute passion. I love the old show. I always watched the old show, but when Star Trek: Discovery came along, I kind of became a proper fan.”
Disco, which is airing its final season even as we speak, feels like a show tailor-made for Russell T Davies, given that he is a gay man who is all about increasing queer representation on television and making it good – Disco has done this in a variety of ways, and it’s not hard to see why Davies likes that show. I do too!
Add in the fact that the adult crew of the baby space station all wore Trek-adjacent uniforms, (complete with the TNG arrangement of command red, operations gold, and sciences blue) and the fact that the next episode is The Beatles One, and you get the impression that, as my fiancee noted when we watched these episodes together, “this is the platonic ideal of Who for Lena.”
And it is. After so long away, I feel like the show is welcoming me back, by calling out to the other two things I love very much (Star Trek and the Beatles) and saying “Hey, you’re back! And we brought your other faves too! Maybe stick around a while?”
And I intend to, because I love this show again. Gatwa and Gibson are absolutely electric, and if this is what their chemistry is like onscreen, I can only imagine what it’s like in real life. These two are brilliant together, and the next six weeks are going to fly by! After so long with a TARDIS crew that felt simply too big, it’s nice that we’re back to a duo again. It feels right.
Space Babies, as an episode, is strange. Because on the one paw it’s very much “standard Doctor Who opening story,” with a plot of about the density of a shoestring, but at the same time, this isn’t just RTD rehashing New Earth or something like that. This is RTD doing a space romp but with more than a little of Steven Moffat in there. It feels like a direct followup from the Moffat era in exactly the way the previous era never did.
As I said in the Wild Blue Yonder post, I noted that the episode felt a lot like various Capaldi era stories – Heaven Sent, Flatline, and Listen. Space Babies feels very much like the RTD version of The Beast Below, albeit sillier and with the political commentary lower in the mix. There’s definite intentionality in having the babies live on a station that’s still in operation, even if the government that built it has washed their hands of them. It’s post-Roe Doctor Who.
Sure, we can talk about the puerile humor of having the Bogeyman be literally made of baby snot, or the fact that the station gets moving entirely because of a giant fart, but… why? This is the guy who invented the Slitheen, remember? Gross out humor has been his thing for 19 years. We know this. (Though that he uses Moffat’s tricks of returning to seemingly innocuous things only to reveal how important they actually are is really quite clever. A perfect fusion of their respective storytelling methods… like a hybrid.)
One more bit of knocking against Chibnall, and then I promise I’ll shut up: after several years of Doctor Who being pitched as, and written like, bad Prestige Television Dramas like [insert Generic Netflix Slop here] I am glad to have the show be willingly, joyfully silly again. The spark that’s been missing from the show in 2018 is finally, blessedly back, and it’s brighter than ever.
Next time: Meet the Beatles!
Leave a Reply