Across the Universe: Nothing You Can Sing That Can’t Be Sung (The Devil’s Chord)

Let’s just get one thing straight: The Devil’s Chord is not a Beatles historical.

Or rather, it’s not a Beatles historical in the usual great-men-of-history mode that the show worked in during the original Davies era and the Chibnall era.

Like, yes, the Beatles are there and the show fawns over them, what with the rapid-fire listing of album and song titles, and even things like expositing about what Abbey Road Studios was called before it became Abbey Road, or the fact that they hired a guy to play George Martin, and even went to the trouble of tracking down duplicates for the instruments the band played. For crying out loud, they even brought up the Mrs. Mills piano! How many people in the world know that the thing “Lady Madonna” was played on even has a name?!

(Well, I do, because I’m a freak.)

But the episode isn’t about them per se, it’s more expansive than that. Of course, it has to be. As RTD said in a recent interview, “I knew The Beatles’ music is way too expensive, even with a lovely Disney budget. So I thought, right, you couldn’t ever use any of their music — lo and behold, you created the plot in that second. It was instantly there. I was like, ‘Oh, that’s good. You go to watch the Beatles, and they’re singing the wrong thing, time’s gone wrong, and suddenly you’re in the middle of a Doctor Who story.’ So that was great.”

So, there we are: the Doctor and Ruby go back in time to see the Beatles record Please Please Me (February 11th, 1963) and then it turns out something has gone terribly wrong, because they’re singing some lame number about a dog. The Wrongness is immediately evident.

And then we find that music has simply been removed from the world, culminating in John Lennon and Paul McCartney, two of the greatest songwriters that ever lived, having no interest at all in working as musicians. Paul describes doing this one album and going off to get a “proper job,” (schoolteacher, according to a book I read once) while John talks about going back to Liverpool and doing god knows what…. until he tells Millie that he keeps crying.

Well, of course he’s crying! Your very reason to live has just been taken away from you!

So, instead of being an episode that goes on and on about how wonderful the Beatles are, we instead get the Doctor Who equivalent of Yesterday, or rather, what Yesterday should’ve been. Instead of “What happens to Beatles music if the Beatles themselves aren’t there to write it,” we get, “all of music is gone and even the Beatles are not immune, and now we have to work out how to fix it.”

About two thirds of the way into the episode, as the Doctor and Ruby return to Abbey Road and find the place is a ghost town, my girlfriend accurately predicted how the episode was going to end: the Beatles would be key to the solution. Because you don’t do an episode that is billed quite heavily as The Beatles One and then not involve them in the plot.

And sure enough, that’s what happens. You can see it’s coming from a mile away – the Doctor and Ruby are ensnared by a music staff, the piano is sitting abandoned in the hallway outside Studio 1, and Maestro is talking about how only a “genius” can figure out the final note in the chord.

And then John and Paul show up, as our resident geniuses. They hit the final chord, and without even realizing what’s going on, they’re the ones to send Maestro back to Hell, or whatever pocket dimension was lurking inside that piano. The Beatles saved the world, because of course they did.

Think about what the Doctor says to Paul in the canteen scene: “Don’t you think… there must be better songs? Songs that… lift you? And devastate you? And make you soar?” That’s all the great-man material we need, and this time it’s earned, because we all know what this music does for people. And it’s very specifically the Beatles’ music that does this. You couldn’t do this story with the Rolling Stones.

Like, just try to imagine what the world is like with no Beatles. You can’t, can you? That’s what made Yesterday such a failure – it reduced the Beatles to just the music, when in fact, it was music that could only have been written and played by four specific individuals. Look at Beyonce releasing a cover of “Blackbird,” a song written for the civil rights movement, in the aftermath of MLK’s assassination, and owning the hell out of it.

I don’t know if RTD has read Dreaming The Beatles by Rob Sheffield, but this episode reminds me of that. Dreaming the Beatles isn’t about the era of 1960 to 1970, it’s about the world the Beatles created, a world we’re all living in now. They may not play a single note of their own songs, but they don’t need to, because implication is enough. No Beatles leading to nuclear war? Seems pretty plausible to me, if I’m honest.

So, of course it’s John and Paul who save the day. Who else was it going to be?

People can bitch and moan about how messy the script is, and how the Beatles turn out to be extras in an episode that was billed as featuring them, but I don’t care about that. With a presence as large and as mythic as the Beatles, to do the traditionalist take on this story would be to have them take out all the oxygen in the room.

Would I have liked for them to have a stronger role in the narrative? Sure. But in the world of the story RTD constructed, where most of the screen time is spent with Maestro causing Missy levels of chaos, it makes sense to keep them at the margins. If we want them to be front and center, we have all those albums and singles for that.

All we need is music.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑