Back in 2017, I really thought we’d never see a new Steven Moffat Doctor Who story again. Then it turned out he’d novelized The Day of the Doctor (which both old and new at the same time, thanks to all the narrative changes) and then penned a bunch of short pieces for the lockdown-era Tweetalongs of various episodes from his era. And now we have this, the first TV adventure he’s written for the show since 2017, and his first since 2008 as a guest writer.
The episode’s primary antagonist is the Villengard algorithm, the famous planet where the weapons forges were later turned into a banana grove after (or more likely, because of) the Doctor’s visit, and seen on-screen in Twice Upon A Time.
Given the setting, the whole episode, for me, feels like the writing of a man reflecting on his very long association with Doctor Who. At points, Moffat writes Fifteen and Ruby like he used to write for Twelve and Clara – the sequence where she ignores his objections and hands him the cylinder containing John Francis Vater’s remains feels like a Twelve/Clara bit:
DOCTOR: You don’t understand, this is a smart mine. It is monitoring anything, any significant change. I get too worried about you, and my blood pressure goes up, and I don’t know how much leeway I have.
RUBY: Best not to worry, then. So how are we going to do this? Count of three?
DOCTOR: Please listen to me.
RUBY: No arguing, Doctor. Blood pressure.
DOCTOR: Ruby, if this doesn’t work… You are brave and you are wonderful… and I forgive you for being incredibly stupid.
RUBY: Good, then.
DOCTOR: And if it does work, I’m going to be very cross at you for a very, very long time.
The whole episode is a tour-de-force for Gatwa’s Doctor, showing beyond a doubt why he was the best choice for the role after Whittaker, not counting Tennant’s reprisal as 14. He barely moves an inch, but completely owns the episode. By the end, you really do feel like you’re not watching Ncuti Gatwa play the Doctor, you’re just watching the Doctor, and he happens to look like Ncuti Gatwa instead of Peter Capaldi or Matt Smith.
But the thing is, this isn’t just Steven Moffat ransacking his past work for easter eggs and such. There’s so much here that is aggressively new, like his potent fury at healthcare for profit, or the way soulless AI systems are gradually infecting every corner of our world, from the Willy Wonka experience that had an AI-generated script to Google search results that tell you to put glue on your pizza.
When I first watched this episode and realized what was going on (about a minute before the Doctor spelled it out) I realized that Boom is the Doctor Who equivalent of the old TNG episode “The Arsenal of Freedom.” In that episode, the Enterprise crew finds itself under attack by the automated defense systems on an otherwise uninhabited planet, and it won’t stop attacking them until Picard agrees to “buy” the weapons package in question.
Boom is the 2020s version of that episode, albeit slimmed down significantly, and with a stronger focus on death and mortality than in “Arsenal.” While mortality and legacy have always been something of a mainstay in Moffat’s work (see the finales of series five, six and seven) it really kicked into high gear when we reached late-stage Capaldi, and the episode Heaven Sent.
We all remember Heaven Sent: Twelve is trapped in the confession dial Missy gave him in The Magician’s Apprentice, and he only escapes because he successfully manages to punch through a diamond wall, finding himself on Gallifrey. The episode was a meditation on death, loss, and grieving, and the theme stayed in more or less constant view from then on, in various unexpected ways.
Death is sad, yes, but the Doctor’s words toward the end of the episode suggest to me that Moffat has come around to focusing on its brighter aspects too. He says, “We’re all dead eventually. There’s hardly any time that we’re not dead. Which is a good thing, too. We’ve got to keep the pace up, otherwise nothing would get done. Dying defines us. Snow isn’t snow until it falls.”
Around the time this episode aired, I started exploring Wicca. The first book I read was one my fiancee recommended: Drawing Down the Moon by Margot Adler, first written in 1979 and updated twice more, first in 1986 and then 2006. It’s a long, exhaustive detailed and well-researched account on the history of neopagan religions in America – primarily Wicca, but other ones are touched upon as well. It was a fantastic read, and one I highly recommend to anyone with an interest in exploring neopaganism.
Though Adler died in 2014, her legacy is contained within the pages of Drawing Down the Moon. If dying defines us, as the Doctor says, then I personally would define Margot Adler as the woman who helped me find my place in Wicca, when I wasn’t sure if I had one yet. Now, I know that I do.
It’s funny that this episode happened when it did, in the specific personal context that it did. A month ago, if you’d asked me what my religion was, I would’ve said the same thing the Doctor does about faith: “Just because I don’t like it doesn’t mean I don’t need it.”
Needless to say, my thoughts have changed somewhat. Now, I’m a practicing Wiccan. I have faith now, in my god and in my goddesses. I have heard what they had to tell me, and I am happy, because I now know that not only am I not alone, I never have been. They’ve been looking out for me all along, waiting for me to find my way home.
Moffat’s next turn at bat for Doctor Who will be this year’s Christmas special, and far as we know, it will also be his last. He said in an interview with TV Choice: “It is entirely possible that I won’t write Doctor Who again. I don’t know. I mean, after Christmas, I’m not lying. I’m not involved in series two. My contribution, in effect, is the Christmas special. I’ve got quite a lot of things that are coming in for me to do, so I might never write Doctor Who again.”
Finishing your career with a big round 50th episode is a good way to bow out… but then again, this is Doctor Who we’re talking about.
He always comes back.
Leave a Reply