Wolf Trek: Conspiracy

Captain’s log, stardate 79442.5: Picard is summoned to a secret meeting with other captains who inform him a conspiracy has begun to replace the top heads of Starfleet. Picard takes the Enterprise back to Earth to investigate the newly found threat.


One of the more infamous episodes from early TNG, “Conspiracy” is probably one of the darkest episodes in the show, given the whole military coup bit and the paranoia inherent in the concept of a conspiracy within the highest levels of Starfleet. Oh yeah, and Remmick getting his head blown off.

According to Memory Alpha, “The original version of the script did not feature alien parasites; the conspiracy in question was simply a military coup within Starfleet. Gene Roddenberry vehemently opposed such an idea, since he believed that Starfleet would never stoop to such methods; there was just no way Tormé could get away with suggesting that the Federation was anything less than a perfect government. Thus, the alien angle was introduced at his insistence.”

So we got the alien bugs instead, in a premise that actually reminds me quite strongly of the Animorphs books by KA Applegate. The ending scene, where it is hinted that the aliens featured might be returning in the future, were meant to be the Borg… and then everyone realize cyborgs were cheaper than insects.

Hilariously, this wouldn’t be the last time Picard finds himself in the middle of a Starfleet conspiracy – just look at the events of the first and third seasons of Picard for more! I distinctly recall fans on the Trek subreddit theorizing that the parasites from this episode would be making a return. (They didn’t – instead, as we know, we got the Borg for the final two episodes of season 3.)

Even so, it’s still one of my favorite early TNGs, following up as it does on the inspection plot line from “Coming of Age,” complete with a return appearance each from Remmick and Quinn. Casting Starfleet Command into a villainous role is always fun to see happen – goodness knows I’ve done something similar in my Trek fanfic work over the years. (Specifically, volumes 1 and 2 of New Endeavours.)

As Underhill notes, “The idea of something rotten afoot in the hallowed halls of the supposedly incorruptible Starfleet Command should come as no surprise to anyone who has been following this season with any degree of care or nuance. The seed was planted arguably as early as as “Too Short a Season”, where Admiral Mark Jameson’s flawless execution of Starfleet’s hero archetype plunged an entire planet into a four decade long world war.”

The impression you get, watching this season, is that the Enterprise and her crew are the last bastion of Star Trek’s stated values of hope and idealism in the face of a violent, uncaring, and even cruel universe. In my fic work, Longhaul (my former writing partner) and I picked up that theme and ran with it over the course of the 24 stories that comprise the first and second volumes of New Endeavours, painting a picture of a Starfleet gone rogue, and only the crew of the Endeavour, and their allies like Picard, Riker, and the Diarchy of Equestria, can call themselves representatives of what Starfleet is supposed to be.

The arc villains of New Endeavours volumes 1-3 are the Changelings: that is, insectoid equines introduced at the end of MLPFIM’s second season in the story “A Canterlot Wedding,” and not the gelatinous villains of Deep Space Nine and most of PIC’s third season.

Over the course of the three books, the changelings burrow their way into Starfleet, replacing various high-ranking officers with the help of Section 31, which has gone rogue and seeks to throw out our Equestrian protagonists – Captain Gemini Shadow and her staff of ponies. Working together with the Romulan Free State, the three groups of antagonists band together and start a war at the beginning of volume 3.

A criticism of “Conspiracy” leveled by Underhill goes: “And I *really* don’t like how Picard tells us through his log entries that he’s informed the bridge crew about the conspiracy. Nowadays we’d expect to see that acted out as part of a senior staff briefing scene in the observation lounge. Why on Earth would you shunt that to the commercial break negative space? That’s a perfect opportunity to reinforce the themes about where you make your family by showing us the trust and respect Captain Picard has in his crew.”

Funnily enough, a scene of this exact sort plays out in “A Question of Love,” a pivotal story in New Endeavours 2. Admiral Nechayev has ordered Gem and crew to collaborate with them on a planned assault of the Solar Empire, (one of two mirror universe versions of Equestria) but Gem suspects Nechayev may have ulterior motives.

In my favorite scene of the whole series, she gets together with her senior officers, and the following discussion occurs:


“Sadly,” Sunset pointed out, “the real issue is where are our alliances: to those like us, no matter what universe they happen to be from, or to the uniform we wear, and the organization we swore an oath to follow?”

“That’s a very good question, Sunset, and one I’ve been thinking about a lot recently,” Gem agreed. She takes off her combadge and holds it between her thumb and forefinger. “I grew up listening to my father’s stories about what he did in space… I wanted to be just like him.”

“But I didn’t realize at the time that becoming captain of a starship would mean making difficult choices.” She walks around the table, looking each of them in the eyes. “We all swore an oath to follow Starfleet, whatever the cost… but that cost, we now know, could involve the deaths of untold millions, perhaps billions, of people. They may not share our beliefs, or our desire for exploration… but to let them die needlessly would be little more than cowardice.”

She slips the combadge into her pocket. “I am risking my career… all our careers… but I believe saving them from certain doom is a better reflection of Starfleet’s promise than what Nechayev has planned.” She looks back to the others. “What do you all think?”

All assembled slipped their commbadges off and placed them in their pockets. Even Dusk, who did so somewhat reluctantly.


Without realizing it, Longhaul and I tapped into a core theme that runs through all of TNG, and very much later, the third season of Picard. If you’re in Starfleet, your crew become part of your family – and when that family is threatened, you pull together to put a stop to it. And that’s an important thing to bear in mind, as we head into the final episode of the first season.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑