Wolf Trek: The Neutral Zone

Captain’s log, stardate 79461.7: Data uncovers three frozen humans from the 20th century, and brings them back to the Enterprise for Dr. Crusher to revive. Meanwhile, the Enterprise is ordered to investigate a new Romulan threat.


“The Neutral Zone” opens with Worf and Data recovering the cryogenically-frozen bodies of three Earth humans: Sonny, Ralph, and Clare. The three of them have been on this lost wreck of a ship since the mid-late 20th century, and all three of them are surprised at where they eventually end up.

How they react to their new situation is a study in contrasts. To quote from Underhill:

“Clare stands for uncertainty in the face of massive change and upheaval. She shuts down once she begins to process how everything she knew about her world and how it worked no longer applies, but she’s helped in coming to terms with that by Deanna.”

“Offenhouse meanwhile is deliberately a reactionary, and thinks he can force the 24th Century to conform to his Will and his belief systems. Naturally, he’s a high-powered business magnate concerned with stocks and investments who uses terms like “upwardly mobile” and is obsessed by power. But he’s not shown to be an out-and-out villain either, as is demonstrated in the scene on the bridge during the climax where he calls Tebok’s bluff. He does have talents that are still valid, he just needs to come to understand he has to remove them from the blinkered and toxic context he’s used to viewing them through.”

“And tellingly it’s Sonny, the musician, who doesn’t have any sort of trouble at all adjusting to his new life. Artists are a kind of shaman for modern ages, and they’re frequently the sorts of people most readily able to accept new realities and new ways of thinking. Sonny goes with the flow, as he says as much.”

Offenhouse would probably have been a Reagan voter in the elections of 1980 and 1984, going by his general attitude and the way in which he orders the crew (including Picard) around like he’s on an episode of The Love Boat or something instead of TNG.

So, I must admit, there’s a certain amount of schadenfreude involved in watching Picard take him down several pegs. In many regards, Offenhouse represents the exact kind of person Q was thinking of when he put Picard on trial at the start of the season: an assholic dipshit who believes he owns the world.

“A lot has changed in the past three hundred years,” Picard says to Offenhouse. 
“People are no longer obsessed with the accumulation of things. We’ve eliminated hunger, want, the need for possessions. We have grown out of our infancy.” What he’s saying is still largely true, but of course, there’s a lot of context he’s leaving out.

Just as when Picard pulls a similar line in First Contact, we know that the truth isn’t quite as rosy as it appears. Just witness what we’ve seen in the last episode – Starfleet being taken over by hostile aliens. Or, hell, witness what’s coming down in another 20 years, with the destruction of Romulus and the Federation’s abandonment of an entire species.

Of the three of them, I have to say I sympathize with Clare the most. Family would be my first port of call if I was in her position – amusingly, the original version of the episode had her be related to the actors who played the first six Doctors on Doctor Who, though the remastered version replaced those names with various production staffers instead.

As for what becomes of our little trio of wayward humans, we have to turn to Trek’s considerable novel line for those answers. According to Memory Beta:

Clemonds later became a popular entertainer and ushered in a revival of late 20th and early 21st century popular music, performing throughout the Federation and becoming known for going to obscure starbases and planetside bases to entertain Starfleet personnel who were in distant postings, not unlike American entertainers of the 20th and 21st centuries who visited troops in war zones.

In 2368, after hearing of the Enterprise’s discovery of the USS Bozeman, lost for 90 years in the Typhon Expanse, Raymond decided she could try and help the time displaced crew adjust to the 24th century. She joined the Federation Department of Temporal Investigations’ Temporal Displacement Division as a counselor.

Funnily enough, no less than Ralph Offenhouse himself has the longest post-2364 biography. He reappears in the novel Debtors’ Planet, published in 1994. The story is set in 2369, during TNG’s sixth season, and Offenhouse has become the Federation’s ambassador to the Ferengi, given his previous life as a financier.

Memory Beta elaborates:

Offenhouse returned to the USS Enterprise-D in 2369 when a Vulcan probe revealed that the Ferengi were rapidly advancing the people of Megara to a technologically advanced state. He helped determine that the Cardassian Union had hired the Ferengi to advance the Megara to a technologically advanced state, so that the Cardassians could use the Megarans as a client state to attack Federation interests.

Some time later, our guy Ralph becomes the Secretary of Commerce under Federation president Nanietta Bacco. So, given all of the above, I’d have to say our time-displaced trio are doing pretty well for themselves! I still have a while to go before I get there in my read through of the TNG novels, but I’m looking forward to seeing him again, bewilderingly. He’s just fun to watch!

Fun fact: “The Neutral Zone” is one of only two TNG season finales not to be the first half of a two-part episode. The intent was for the first episode of season 2 to pick up from the Romulan plot, but it didn’t happen thanks to, once again, the writers strike of 1987 and 1988. All this would go on to have knock-on effects for season 2 as well, which we’ll cover when we get to those episodes.

The abrupt ending is a little disappointing, but it’s an optimistic note all the same. Onward we go to season two!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑