Across the Universe: Friends to Go (Dot and Bubble)

That moment where your devotion to the idea of using Beatles lyrics to title your blog posts feels like a mistake, because then it means you can’t use the perfect Duran Duran title instead. Two of them, actually: “Networker Nation” or “Bury A Friend,” which I realize is a Billie Eilish cover. So instead, we get a song title from Paul’s 2005 solo album Chaos and Creation in the Backyard. Which slaps, by the way.

So anyway, the episode.

On paper, this episode really shouldn’t work. In the hands of a lesser writer, the opinions of a late middle aged man on social media would boil down to, “Maybe we should all talk to each other instead,” but RTD is better than that. Instead, what we get is an episode that becomes “social media bubbles can radicalize you and turn you into a racist.”

And, well, considering YouTube’s algorithm has been accused of radicalizing people by putting fascist shit in their recommended videos list, Davies has every right to be concerned. And that’s before you factor in the right-wing shithole Twitter has become ever since Musk bought it.

At first, Dot and Bubble makes you think this is a future where people have really got into virtual reality and video chat, to the point that Lindy here can’t even walk without help from the arrows that tell her where to go… but the ugliness is right there, bubbling under the surface, so the last scene (where Lindy’s ENTIRE SOCIETY is revealed to be a white ethnostate) really shouldn’t be a surprise at all.

It’s right there, in front of us! Not just how absolutely everyone we see other than the Doctor is white, but even how Lindy interacts with the Doctor. She can deal with Ruby because she looks like her, but the Doctor?! She hates him. Virtually every line of dialogue she has regarding him is a micro-aggression, and when she calls the cops on him, we cross the line straight into aggression.

And it’s not just limited to race either. Even Ricky September, a white person, is not immune: he tells Lindy a little bit too much about himself (that he turns the bubble off and spends his time reading in an apartment instead) and the nearest opportunity she gets, Lindy gets him killed. Anyone who doesn’t spend all their time in the bubble, like she does, is suspect.

What’s notable is that this is the first, and so far only, episode to deal with the fact that the Doctor isn’t white anymore. As my fiancee observed when we watched this one together, the privilege he had when he presented as a white man is gone now. Even The Witchfinders, the one Whittaker-era episode that deals significantly with how the Doctor’s newfound womanhood affects her, didn’t actually prevent her from saving the day. Fifteen is denied even that, simply because of the color of his skin.

And Gatwa, for what it’s worth, acts the hell out of that material. The way he breaks into hysterical laughter, then screams, and then that final, tearful shot followed by the smoldering fury as he walks into the TARDIS and closes the door… damn. He is a very compelling performer, Ncuti Gatwa. Right up there with Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi for me in terms of just how much fun it is to see him do Doctor stuff.

As my very dear friend Miranda observed on Twitter, “The Doctor has lived so long with the privilege of swanning about without ever having to meaningfully engage with that aspect of humanity. Even as Twelve and Thirteen they never had to. Of course Fifteen was going to be desperate. […] I think the episode makes it clear these aren’t people to show empathy to. Which is why the Doctor being desperate to save them doesn’t take away from the episode for me. They are terrible, they are backwards, they are self serving and they can barely toddle by themselves.”

Yes. The best science fiction holds a mirror up to our society and says, “This is what you are now.” Star Trek did this in 1969 with “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield,” the episode where the Enterprise encounters a planet where people are black and white on different sides of their faces. The two groups are so enraged at the mere existence of one another that they end up genociding themselves, rather than make peace.

“All that matters to them is their hate,” Spock says, toward the end of the episode. And the same statement applies just as well to the denizens of Finetime. It doesn’t matter to them that they’ll all probably die in the woods, the Doctor isn’t white, and to them, their Aryan “utopia’ is more important than even their own lives.

Which is fascism summed up, basically.

Speaking of racism, lemme give a shout-out to some jackass on Twitter who posted a screenshot of Ricky September and said, without a shred of self-awareness, “Dot and Bubble accidentally gave us the best Doctor we’ve had since Capaldi.”

My guy. Gatwa was right there. When called on this, he tried to cover it up by saying something like, “It depends what kind of Doctor you prefer. Ncuti feels more in line with the emotive, expressive New Who Doctors which is less my kind of thing. I like that this guy felt a bit calmer, more reserved.”

Translation: “I liked this dull-as-dishwater jock because he’s white, and I am trying to avoid outing myself as a racist and failing at it miserably.”

Which is hilarious, and oh so typical. The exact people who need to be told that their view of the world is sickeningly awful are the same ones who, by and large, manage to miss the point of an episode that is explicitly about their awful views.

“I understand the themes of the episode, I just enjoyed his performance,” says this fuckhead. TELL US WHAT THE THEMES ARE THEN YOU IGNORANT ASSWIPE.

Anyway. Dot and Bubble was fantastic, and proves beyond a doubt why RTD needed to return. Chibnall could never write this.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑