Off the Beatle Track: A Hard Day’s Night (US)

Our third American album comes not from Capitol Records, but United Artists. This is the soundtrack album to the movie A Hard Day’s Night, including not just the eight songs featured in the movie, but four instrumental pieces performed by George Martin and his orchestra to serve as additional incidental music. It was released in June 1964, a full two weeks before the British album of the same name.

Per The Beatles Bible:

United Artists had discovered in autumn 1963 that EMI had failed to cover film soundtracks in the contract with The Beatles. Despite the band not having become popular in America at the time, the company realized they could capitalize on their phenomenal fame in Britain, and negotiated the rights to make a feature film about them. Producer Walter Shenson’s brief from UA was simple: “We need a film for the express purpose of getting a soundtrack album,” he was told. “Just make sure there are enough new songs for a soundtrack album and don’t go over budget.”

The end result, of course, was A Hard Day’s Night, one of the best music movies ever made, as we’ll get to when we cover the Beatles’ various cinematic projects. The soundtrack album as released United Artists, for me, is a much stronger album than the canonical British version, since all the non-film songs appear on other albums, where they can flourish without the more beloved movie tracks weighing them down. And you get more of George Martin – never a bad thing, since I’ve always felt he’s more than earned his status as the Fifth Beatle. I could listen to his orchestral work all day!

With that said, let’s go song by song:


A Hard Day’s Night: By far this song’s most distinguishing feature is its opening chord, the best attention-grabbing sound on a Beatles album ever. Written to order so as to provide a good accompaniment for the movie’s opening credits, the title comes from one of Ringo’s many malapropisms, and features John and Paul trading verses, and for the first time, the sound of George’s new 12-string Rickenbacker in the guitar solo. (Which was, incidentally, recorded at half-speed then sped up when played back.)

Tell Me Why: The happiest song ever recorded about confronting your partner for some kind of failure, right here. As an aside, those falsetto vocals are, “Is there anything I can do?” (It took me an embarrassingly long time to realize this.) It appears in the last scene of the movie, when the band are performing their big concert.

I’ll Cry Instead: John sings about his inability to be emotionally honest with himself in the aftermath of a nasty break-up, coupled with a promise for revenge. Sheesh. This song was meant to accompany the police chase scene in the last third of the movie, when John, George, and Paul go to track down the missing Ringo before the concert starts, but director Richard Lester changed his mind because the lyrics were too depressing, so we got a reprise of “Can’t Buy Me Love” instead. Minor audio note: the American mono version of this song contains an extra verse that doesn’t appear on either the stereo version or the British mono mix.

I Should Have Known Better (orchestral instrumental): The first of the instrumental cuts on this album, I really like it. George Martin did a great job translating the energy of the original into this rearrangement, and I love the way the guitar and brass parts play with the melody. It’s honestly kind of jazzy? Which I love.

I’m Happy Just To Dance With You: George’s vocal spot on the album, I occasionally forget that he didn’t actually write this. I like it anyway, and I like the way he sings it.

And I Love Her (orchestral instrumental): Out of all the instrumental renditions on this album, this one is by far and away my all-time favorite. It’s slow and stately, and those little piano flourishes throughout the track are delightful. Honestly, I think I want to play this at my wedding next year.

I Should Have Known Better: What’s that? Another Beatles song with harmonica on it! Pretty sure this is the last of those. Also listen for, again, George’s solo here, he gets a lot of mileage out of that 12-string. One of my favorites of his solos. ❤

If I Fell: One of my favorite John ballads, this song gets played early in the movie to cheer up Ringo, but nowadays I associate it with all the times I’ve listened to it with my girlfriend, since it’s part of one of our couples mixes. Sonically, it’s a wonderful display of John and Paul’s talent for harmonizing. That’s a sound you’ll never forget, even sixty years later.

And I Love Her: One of the prettiest love songs the Beatles ever wrote, this. The opening riff was apparently George’s creation, right on the spot – an earlier version on Anthology 1 lets us hear it on electric instruments, minus the riff, and I have to say, something really is lost without it. This song belongs on acoustic guitars. Audio note: this version of the song runs slightly slower than the version on Something New, or the British mono mix of AHDN, 2:34 vs 2:31. It’s subtle, but if you’ve got a keen ear, you’ll hear it when Paul’s vocal comes in. Also listen for his single-tracked vocal during the verses.

Ringo’s Theme (This Boy) (orchestral instrumental): As I mentioned last week, “This Boy” has long been one of my favorite early period Beatles songs, and this rendition (used in the movie during Ringo’s big solo outing where seemingly everything goes wrong for him) is really great. I especially like the way the guitar handles John’s bridge section!

Can’t Buy Me Love: An energetic Paul song for the ages, it’s most well known for accompanying the scene in the movie where the Beatles screw around in a field for two minutes, and it’s amazing. And check out the double-tracked guitar solo! I love it when Paul gets to rock out.

A Hard Day’s Night (orchestral instrumental): We end where we began – the movie’s title song, performed this time by George Martin and his orchestra. Given how important Martin and his musical arrangement skills will become in defining the Beatles’ sound, I’m really glad he gets a chance to shine on this album. Only Yellow Submarine does anything similar. Hilariously, this version of the song gets used in the last third of the movie, when Paul’s Grandfather is attempting to sell his forged photos. He even gets to run! Bless. The arrangement here is a bit more jazz than rock, but there’s nothing wrong with that! The energy remains the same.


As I said previously, the British version of this album is somewhat uneven – the film songs are great, while the non-film songs (or at least John’s songs) range from mid to problematic in the extreme, making the second half an exceptional letdown.

This is not true of the American version. All the Beatle tracks are film songs, and all of them (with the exception of “I’ll Cry Instead”) are great hits in their own right. Add in the 4 songs that George Martin did orchestral arrangements for, and you have a solid accompaniment to one of the best music movies of all time, and a much stronger entry in the Beatles catalog than the UK version is.

That’s right, I said it. Ours is better.

SO THERE! HA!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑