Released in June 1966, this is the last Capitol original to feature new Beatles music, including three tracks from the yet-unreleased Revolver album, plus a few songs from the UK version of Rubber Soul, two Ringo songs (an all time record for him!) and the double A-side singles “Day Tripper” and “We Can Work It Out,” two of the coolest mid-‘60s Beatles songs ever. And this is an era that’s responsible for Rubber Soul, Revolver, and the “Paperback Writer”/“Rain” single.
But remember: this album came out in 1966, which for all the Beatles’ many artistic achievements during that year, (there’s even a book by Steve Turner about it) outside of music this was a pretty terrible year in their history. Between the entire disaster surrounding John’s “more popular than Jesus” comment leading to record burnings in the southern US, the nightmarish tour of the Philippines, and a string of dates in America where they were threatened with violence by the Ku Klux Klan, you can kind of see why they were more than happy to hole themselves up at Abbey Road for the rest of their career.
Which brings us to the cover art for this particular collection of songs. In a year where the Beatles were seemingly courting controversy everywhere, they came out with an album cover that was so disturbing, Y&T actually got recalled for a brief time so Capitol could sort out the problem.
This is the story… of the Butcher Cover.
Per The Beatles Bible:
The artwork showed The Beatles wearing butcher coats, surrounded by raw meat, false teeth, and disembodied doll parts. Although interpreted by some as a commentary on Capitol’s tendency to chop and change their album running orders for the US market, the shoot, by photographer Robert Whitaker, was not originally intended for an album cover, and was part of a wider triptych known as ‘Somnambulant Adventure’.
Despite the president of Capitol Records objecting to using it as the album sleeve, it went ahead anyway. John said in 1974:
“I don’t like being locked in to one game all the time, and there we were supposed to be sort of angels. I wanted to show that we were aware of life, and I really was pushing for that album cover. I would say I was a lot of the force behind it going out and trying to keep it out.”
Given that this is the same guy responsible for the equally infamous Two Virgins cover, with him and Yoko engaging in full frontal nudity, I would say that tracks. Courting controversy was John’s big thing, after all.
In the end, the Butcher Cover was replaced with a new photo featuring the boys gathered around a trunk… except on the first try, the new picture was pasted over the old one. But obviously, the Butcher ones are the rare ones, and they tend to command a lot of money on the auction circuit.
Beatles Bible again: “The rarest unpeeled original pressings are known as ‘first state’ covers, and command the highest prices – particularly the rarer stereo pressings. The first documented sale was of a mono copy in 1974, which fetched $457. [$2,876 in 2024 dollars. -L.M.] The value has steadily risen since, and in 2006 a copy sold for $20,000.”
As with the rest of the Beatles’ American releases, Yesterday And Today was deleted from the band’s catalogue in the late 1980s, when the band’s music (very specifically their British albums plus Capitol’s Magical Mystery Tour) was released on CD. In 2014 though, all of their American releases were put out on CD, with the original running orders, though the music was sourced from the 2009 UK remasters.
In fact, Yesterday And Today was the first American Beatles album I ever owned – it was May 2015, and while browsing the CD racks at Best Buy, I found a Beatles album I’d never seen available for sale before… this turned out to be Yesterday And Today, complete with the trunk cover sticker on the front… except this time, you could peel it off, and I did!
A few years later, I bought the entire US Albums collection with my Christmas money, so now I have two versions of Yesterday and Today – one with the trunk cover, and one without. It’s kinda cool, honestly.
And, at long last, on to the music:
‘Drive My Car’: This song was written around the time the Otis Redding track “Respect” came out, and you can hear the influence, particularly in the piano. That opening guitar hook, for my money, is as distinctive as the opening chord of “A Hard Day’s Night,” and it gets the album off to a strong start.
‘I’m Only Sleeping’: One of my favorite John songs ever, this psychedelic ode to sleeping was recently the subject of a music video — said video has since won a Grammy. One of my favorite aspects of the song is the first use of reversed guitar on a Beatles record, including the solo, and it sounds really cool. And, like so many Beatles innovations, it was a complete accident, thanks to a tape op at EMI putting the tape into the machine wrong. (Having done exactly that myself, easy mistake to make.)
‘Nowhere Man’: While most people probably associate this song with the animated sequence set to it in the Yellow Submarine movie, when I was about nine I thought this song was about George W. Bush, because he was president at the time and my dad hated him with a passion. Now I know it isn’t – it’s just John being insecure again. George’s lead guitar parts in this are great, especially the end of the solo. Harmonics!
‘Doctor Robert’: In which John writes the first song in the entire Beatles repertoire that is entirely about drugs, because it was 1966 and everyone was on drugs in those days, John Lennon in particular. (I’m pretty sure he was on all of them.) It’s absolutely hilarious and I love it.
‘Yesterday’: On the opposite end of the emotional scale entirely, we have “Yesterday,” the most covered song in the history of popular music. I adore this song, and goodness knows I’ve had cause to think of it quite a bit over the years, when applying it to my own relationships. Fortunately, I don’t think I’ll be singing this song about Lykos and I anytime soon. Or ever. ❤
‘Act Naturally’: The only cover song on this album, there’s really not a ton of stuff to say here – just Ringo doing a song by Buck Owens. That said, it is kind of funny that it’s Ringo singing this, since he was “acting naturally” in his famous ‘Ringo goes parading’ sequence in A Hard Day’s Night. Country and western suits him really well, which isn’t a surprise – his stage name came from a John Wayne movie!
‘And Your Bird Can Sing’: No matter how hard I try, I can’t listen to this song without thinking of the early take on Anthology 2, where John and Paul attempt to record vocal overdubs and fail because they can’t stop laughing. (Perhaps for that reason, John’s vocal is instead treated with ADT, or artificial double-tracking, another innovation from the recording sessions for Revolver.) It’s a great rock song anyway, I especially like the lead guitar part.
‘If I Needed Someone’: A great George song, it really shines on this album, since it’s not immediately followed up with one of the worst Beatles songs John Lennon ever wrote.. The best mix is easily on the expanded version of Red from 2023, where it gets a new sparkle and shine that the original stereo mixes didn’t have.
‘We Can Work It Out’: Released as a double A-side with “Day Tripper” toward the end of 1965, “We Can Work It Out” proved to be the more popular of the two songs, as that was a Paul song, with John contributing the bridge. During recording sessions, George Harrison suggested performing the bridge sections in ¾ waltz time, to go with the minor chords used in those sections.
‘What Goes On’: A country flavored break-up song this time from Ringo, and probably the only country song I can stand. Listen close to John during this song: at one point you can hear John say, “We already told you why!” A Hard Day’s Night reference there.
‘Day Tripper’: “Tripper” was, at once, a drug song (specifically LSD) and a reference to people who go on trips and then come home in the same day. Personally, I’ve always liked “Tripper” more, as it was the first Beatles song I learned to play on guitar.
Yesterday and Today, in the final analysis, is emblematic of the Beatles’ American LPs. Controversial, not really much liked outside of their home countries, hated by the band because they took all the hard work the Beatles did in putting their albums together in favor of grab-bag mix and match compilations that were assembled not in the name of artistic integrity, but money. The almighty dollar ruled all in the early 60s, and still does today.
And yet. As I’ve been saying for a while now, there’s something ineffably charming about these red-headed step-children. They are albums in their own right, with their own sounds and their own vibes. So what if they’re not what the Beatles would’ve approved of? They’re still good art. It’s just a different way of listening to the music we all love, and that’s no bad thing. Not unlike, say, compiling a playlist and hitting the shuffle button.
If I had to list my favorites, they’d be: Meet The Beatles, The Beatles’ Second Album, Beatles ’65, and Yesterday and Today. All great song choices, which tell a different story about the band, and one that for so long, has gone unheard. I’m glad that now, with the US Albums set, these all-American Beatles albums can finally get their moment in the sun.
USA! USA! USA!
Leave a Reply