At one time, I might have spent the bulk of this essay discussing how this episode is the first shot in the bow of a move away from the celebrity historical model that’s dominated the new series since the show returned in 2005 – a format inaugurated by, funnily enough, Mark Gatiss. But that’s the traditionalist way in, and I want to do something different. (Besides which: as of Rosa, celebrity historicals are back in vogue.)
So instead, let’s start with the obvious – this is a Doctor Who episode that engages with, albeit somewhat indirectly, with the show’s own fictionality.
This is kind of a huge deal. We are used to Doctor Who treating its internal world as reality – kind of like our world, only with more alien invasions. But by doing an episode explicitly about a fictional character, this changes.
True, Robin and his Merry Men are treated as being real within the story, and Robin even says to the Doctor, “I’m as real as you are,” but what that line is really saying is brought up just a few lines earlier: “Perhaps others will be heroes in our name. Perhaps we will both be stories. And may those stories never end.”
In a roundabout way, Gatiss is acknowledging an essential truth, not just of Doctor Who, but in all of fiction. The characters we create, or watch, or read about, are not real in the sense of being actual people we can visit, but they are real in our imaginations. And we, as people, can use them as inspiration as we move through the world.
Just consider the character of the Doctor. He is a hero, but he’s the people’s hero. As Moffat put it:
“When they made this particular hero up, they didn’t give him a gun — they gave him a screwdriver to fix things. They didn’t give him a tank or a warship or an X-Wing fighter, they gave him a call box from which you can call for help.”
“And they didn’t give him a superpower or pointy ears or a heat ray. They gave him an extra heart. They gave him two hearts, and that’s an extraordinary thing. There will never come a time when we don’t need a hero like the Doctor.”
In all his incarnations, the Doctor is kind. Compassionate. Loving to all lifeforms, be they human or alien. He’s open-minded, curious about the world around him, and he is always ready to help if he’s needed. No person is too small or worth caring about, everyone is important to him.
And the best part is? All those qualities that make the Doctor special come from us. We can be all those things too. The alien nature, the magic box, all that is window dressing. Who the Doctor is, at his core, is the best of humanity.
I’ve been thinking a lot lately about the kinds of heroes I’ve admired over the years, the kinds of people I want to be when I grow up. And most of the people I admire, interestingly, come from various fictional worlds. I want to be wise, empathic, diplomatic, and well-read, like Captain Picard. I want to be inventive, like Violet Baudelaire. I want to have Twilight Sparkle’s skill at friendship, and the Doctor’s penchant for doing the right thing, even if it’s hard. (Especially if it’s hard.)
In all the fictional worlds I’ve visited and loved, I’ve come to look at the characters as teachers. People who are, in their own ways, helping me to become a better person. I am always growing and learning, and there are always new things to discover. I will fall short, sometimes, but if I need a boost, I know that the Doctor, Twilight, or Captain Picard will always be there to help me back up again.
“When did you start believing in impossible heroes?” asks the Doctor early in the episode.
“Don’t you know?” replies Clara, two steps ahead as always. (To answer his question: around the time they met and saved the day together in The Bells of St. John. For me, The Eleventh Hour.)
It’s funny, watching this episode, and not just because it’s one of Gatiss’s best comedy scripts. This story wouldn’t work as well with Eleven, because he’d be as enthused at meeting Robin Hood as Clara is. You need the contrast that Twelve provides for it to work, and Capaldi is magnificent in it – I could watch scenes like the one in the dungeon where the Doctor and Robin snark at each other for several minutes straight all day long!
And in truth, I will admit that in my early years as a Who fan, I didn’t rate Gatiss’ scripts very highly. I went through a period, early on, where I couldn’t stand him. But once I started to look at his work more critically in Back to the Eleventh Hour and The RTD Rewind, I realized that he’s actually really good at what he does. (Just look at the complete 180 I did regarding The Idiot’s Lantern as an example.)
Is he the best writer the show has ever had? No. Do I think he has what it takes to be showrunner? Also no, but I find that sort of armchair theorizing may be a bit old hat now that RTD is in charge, and may seem to be for the foreseeable future. (I don’t think he’s going to leave with Gatwa, anyway.)
At the point the show was in during 2014, in the immediate aftermath of the 50th and the end of the Smith era, he’s in tune with the vibe, and he hits his marks in two of his three Capaldi scripts. I’m not sure he’s a voice we need to hear from again, but it was nice to have him around at the time.
Leave a Reply