The Midnight Hour: When I’m Not Looking, You’re Not There (Listen)

It’s interesting, how this episode has aged over the past decade. It was transparently Moffat writing the cheap show for the season, acting in the curious position of being his own guest writer – though given the concept, it’s easy to see RTD green lighting something like this, in some alternate timeline where he just never stopped being showrunner.

And in some regards, Listen now feels like Late Moffat in much the same way Boom does. And for that matter, as Terror of the Umpty-Ums did. You don’t remember that one because it was a lockdown piece featuring Thirteen, but it did exist, and it’s fucking delightful, not least because it does more to make Thirteen feel like an actual person with interiority and a characterization beyond Live Laugh Love Starmerian Labour voter.

Anyway. Boom, like Listen, has a one-word title relating to an action being taken, or not being taken, by the characters in the story, and it’s the cheap one: a few simple sets and a small main cast – the Doctor, the companion, and a couple of guests. (Or in the case of Listen, Samuel Anderson playing two different characters.) It’s filled with Moffat’s quotable one-liners, and what Listen lacks in biting political commentary, it makes up for in relationship drama and interesting revelations about the Doctor.

And it’s that last point that I really want to talk about. We have had a lot of Big Revelations about the Doctor over the past ten years, from secret incarnations we were previously unaware of to the Timeless Child and whatever the absolute fuck the Division was supposed to be. And all these revelations, when you come down to it, boil down to three men (Moffat, Chibnall, and Davies) each trying to answer the question presented in the title of the series: Doctor who?

We all want to know why the Doctor is the person that he is. Moffat’s way of doing that was to spend the entire Smith era deconstructing the conception of the Doctor presented in the Eccleston and Tennant eras, first by depicting what happens when the Doctor becomes so huge, and so frightening, that he becomes the thing the villains must protect the universe from, and then (in the Capaldi era) reconstructing the character by pinning down his absolute essential elements, and going from there.

And it starts with the War Doctor. 

As I wrote in volume 3 of Back to the Eleventh Hour, I am immensely glad that Eccleston eventually chose not to return for The Day of the Doctor, because it gave us War. On the face of it, War is the Davies-ian conception of the character taken to its logical extreme: the darkest Doctor ever, so dark that he even stopped using his name because he didn’t feel he was worthy of it.

But of course, it’s not as easy as all that. What is key to Moffat’s conception of the character is that, even at his lowest point, the Doctor will always be the Doctor, at least in personality and habits if not necessarily in name. That’s what makes Ten and Eleven’s acceptance of him at the end of Day so important. They’re reminding themselves of what they already know to be true.

In Listen, we are told exactly how the Doctor came to be, and it goes back to the revelations contained within Day. One night, a frightened little Gallifreyan boy hid in a barn, and was visited by a woman who would go on to scatter herself across his timeline, ensuring he becomes the man she would go on to travel with. She tells him the following:

Clara: “I know you’re afraid, but being afraid is all right. Because didn’t anybody ever tell you? Fear is a superpower. Fear can make you faster and cleverer and stronger. And one day, you’re going to come back to this barn. And on that day you’re going to be very afraid indeed. […] But that’s okay. Because if you’re very wise and very strong, fear doesn’t have to make you cruel or cowardly. Fear can make you kind. Fear makes companions of us all.”

That’s all the origin story you need. Everything with the Timeless Child and Division? Unnecessary. (Best thing to come out of that was using it for the same angst beats normally associated with the Time War.) The Doctor isn’t some special Chosen One type figure, he’s just a very old man, or woman, with a magic box who goes around trying to be the best he can be.

This is exactly the characterization Davies is running with in the Gatwa era: Fourteen and Fifteen are post-Moffat, both temporally and in terms of personality. The experiences they had as Eleven and Twelve mattered to them, and affect them even to this day. (It is very funny to me that ideologically, the second Davies era feels more like a logical followup to the Moffat era than Chibnall’s era ever did.

I have to admit: it feels like vindication, watching RTD pick up on Moffat-era concepts and building off from them, whether that’s things like Kate Stewart heading up UNIT or the Doctor’s characterization. I spent so long enduring Moffat Hate, both on Tumblr during the Moffat era, and on Twitter under Chibnall, and it feels so nice to see it get some love.

But then, this should come as no surprise. Just read the tribute that Davies wrote for Moffat in issue #515 of Doctor Who Magazine, during the gap between The Doctor Falls and Twice Upon A Time:

“I love every episode the man’s written. I love the other episodes he’s rewritten and I think few people know how many that is. I love the detail, I love the scale, I love the people, I love the jokes. I love the fact that Steven himself is quite down on The Beast Below. The whole of the UK on a spaceship? The whole of the UK is a spaceship? I’d retire there and then, complete. Nope, for him, it just wasn’t good enough.”

That love is so strong, not only did RTD ask Moffat to come back for an episode of series 14, he’s even writing the 2024 Christmas special. All of that love for all of that brilliance, of which Listen (to drag us back to the nominal topic of the essay) is just one small piece, but a very important one.

Steven Moffat has written 50 Doctor Who stories, or will have by the time Joy to the World comes out. And it will take time for RTD to get anywhere close to that. But for my money, the numbers are only half the story. The brilliance is the other half.

And when it comes to brilliance, he’s untouchable.

Thanks for everything, Steven Moffat.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑