As I’ve argued before, one of Steven Moffat’s big innovations when he became showrunner of Doctor Who was to make the show more overtly feminist. Moffat has been advocating for women in powerful roles since literally the 1980s, when he wrote the character Lynda Day for the TV series Press Gang. (Which was, incidentally, his first ever TV project.) And if the response to his recent miniseries, Douglas is Cancelled, is any guide, that feminist ethos is not limited to his Doctor Who work.
For Doctor Who, the best way to even the gender odds was to change the dynamics of the Doctor-companion relationship. For most of the show’s history, the companion, usually female, has generally been subservient to the Doctor, who is usually male. While isolated examples of a more balanced relationship do exist within the classic series (Barbara, Jo Grant, Sarah Jane, and Ace all spring to mind), it’s not until we get to the new series, and the work begun by Russell T Davies to bring the show into the new, post-Buffy landscape, that the groundwork was truly laid for what Moffat goes on to do.
There was, of course, a lot of pushback from certain corners of the fandom regarding this move. This particular group of fans loudly complained about the show becoming “Clara Who,” deriding former head writer Steven Moffat for having the absolute audacity to begin breaking down and repairing the show’s demonstrably unhealthy gender dynamics. In the minds of these people, a woman’s place is in the Security Kitchen.
Starting with series 8, Moffat and his writing staff then proceed to spent the next season and a half proving these people wrong. We begin with Flatline, which first aired the day after I turned 20. In the story, Clara is tasked with becoming a substitute Doctor while the definite article is stuck in a shrinking TARDIS. That would be difficult enough, if not for the strange two-dimensional beings murdering people.
Aside from having a truly brilliant idea for a monster design (it’s the kind of thing the Scribble Creature from Fear Her wished it could be) it’s also a brilliant turn for Clara, and by extension Jenna Coleman, as she gets to carry the sonic and psychic paper. She even gets a companion and introduces herself to him as the Doctor… but Rigsy can call her Clara.
By this point in her development as a character, Clara’s known the Doctor in all his regenerations, so she knows exactly how to emulate him in order to get herself into the plot. She knows how to poke around and ask questions other people wouldn’t think to ask, how to get people to run when she tells them, and of course, she knows about Rule One: the Doctor lies. She lies to Danny about why she’s not at lunch, lies to the Doctor about Danny, lies to Rigsy and the other community service workers so they’ll follow her and have a better chance at survival than they would otherwise.
But none of that is what makes Clara an excellent Doctor. Or at least, not alone. Clara gets two key scenes in relatively quick succession toward the end of the story which really hammer home how good she is at this. In the first of these, Rigsy hijacks a train intending to sacrifice himself to buy Clara time so she can stop the Boneless, but Clara doesn’t let him. Instead, she throws a hairband over a switch (rendering his presence aboard moot) and points out how pointless his sacrifice is by saying:
“And I really like that hair band, but I suppose I’ll just take it, will I? And every time I look at it, I’ll remember the hero who died to save it. Come on. You’re not getting off that lightly. There’s work that needs doing.”
The subtext is obvious: “We can only get through this if you’re here to help us.”
And, true enough, Rigsy’s presence is key to the next scene, wherein Clara comes up with an idea to charge the TARDIS back up and bring the Doctor back into the fight. She has Rigsy paint a door on the back of a poster hung on a wall, knowing that the Boneless will try and restore it to three dimensions, and hides the shrunken TARDIS behind it. It’s a brilliant plan on her part, based as it is on sound deductive reasoning. Small wonder the Doctor calls her exceptional! (And, it bears pointing out that this is the exact kind of trick that you see in Looney Tunes shorts with Wile E. Coyote and the Roadrunner. And it works!)
But there’s a dark side to Doctoring, as the two episodes which immediately precede Flatline make abundantly clear. Being the Doctor isn’t like being, say, the captain of the USS Enterprise. There is no one out there in the universe who can do what the Doctor does, exactly the way he does it. He is utterly and entirely alone, and that was true even before Gallifrey got lost.
But of course, because one can’t help but idolize the Doctor, it’s not surprising that companions would go on to try and do what he does anyway. Rose and Donna each have their turn, and each of them are slapped down and punished for trying: Rose gets banished to an alternate universe, and Donna gets her memory wiped. It’s only when Moffat comes around that “being the Doctor” comes to be seen as a good thing… albeit, a good thing with some very significant risks.
Just look at what happens in Face the Raven, when Clara and the Doctor discuss the former’s impending death by Quantum Shade:
CLARA: Why? Why shouldn’t I be so reckless? You’re reckless all the bloody time. Why can’t I be like you?
DOCTOR: Clara, there’s nothing special about me. I am nothing, but I’m less breakable than you. I should have taken care of you.
CLARA: I never asked you to.
DOCTOR: You shouldn’t have to ask.
This is what makes Twelve’s statement of “You were an excellent Doctor, Clara. Goodness had nothing to do with it” at the end of Flatline so chilling. It suggests he sees in her the flaws he has in himself, and over the course of the next season or so, he tries to keep her as safe as he can. He may not see himself as a good man, but he thinks she’s a good woman, and he doesn’t want her to die in the way that he so often does – by protecting an innocent.
Clara, of course, will have none of this. As she says a little later, “Heal yourself. You have to. You can’t let this turn you into a monster. So, I’m not asking you for a promise, I’m giving you an order. You will not insult my memory. There will be no revenge. I will die, and no one else, here or anywhere, will suffer.”
Because that’s the thing about Clara Oswald. This woman understands this man better than anyone else in the universe, including the man himself. So, of course she flies off from Gallifrey on a stolen TARDIS with a quasi-immortal companion at the end of Hell Bent.
What else is she going to do?
Leave a Reply