The received wisdom of Peter Capaldi’s first season is that it’s split in half between episodes by old hands that feel like Eleventh Doctor stories gone slightly off-the-rails, and the second half (starting with Kill the Moon) is when the Capaldi era really starts to get going, with darker, heavier stories that the Smith era could never have done, because the Capaldi seasons are more mature than the Smith ones are.
I don’t actually believe this.
The Capaldi era begins with Deep Breath, a story that is manifestly not, as a review I read once stipulated, “a Matt Smith caper” with the Eleventh Doctor taken out. Instead, it’s more of an evolution of things that the Smith era was already doing.
The fairytale vibes that ran through those years are all still here, it’s just that this time, they are being treated with more realism. Clara’s entire subplot with Danny feels like an exploration into the idea “What would it actually be like to be the Doctor’s companion” and examined as practically as possible.
Having said all of that, Forest definitely feels like a story that could’ve been made during the previous production era. Certainly, I wouldn’t mind slotting it into place in the empty space where Nightmare In Silver, written by sexual predator and general sleaze bag Neil Gaiman, used to be.
To be fair, it’s not a perfect story. There’s some weirdness with kids and taking meds, and according to Elizabeth Sandifer’s TARDIS Eruditorum post on this story, Frank Cottrell-Boyce completely botches the Blakean aspects of the story to a degree that, in her reading, is actively harmful to what the story is trying to do.
But I look at it differently. What I see when I look at this story is the hole being patched up between the Doctor and Clara, the festering wound in their friendship that they’ve been dealing with since Kill The Moon. And putting aside any unfortunate aesops or less-than-stellar engagement with the episode’s inspiration, the emotional content of this story is absolutely perfect.
So, with this in mind, let’s jump right in to my… idiosyncratic reading on this story, inspired by the mythology of my religion. People really seemed to like the Kill the Moon post, so why not balance out the one that focused so heavily on the Goddess with one that focuses on the God? Balance is everything, both in life and in magic.
This is a magical ritual too, but of a different sort.
In my post on Kill the Moon, I posited that far from being the abortion allegory some people think it is, I wrote that it’s actually got more to do with the life cycle of the two primary deities of Wicca, and the Doctor’s refusal to play his part in the cycle of life led to the delicate harmonic balance between the God (Twelve) and the Goddess (Clara) being upset.
Tonally, Kill the Moon was very much a story with great big Samhain vibes: writer Peter Harness had been instructed to “Hinchcliffe the shit” out of the first half, and you can tell, because it really does feel like something that might’ve been done in the early Tom Baker years. (Or, given the moon setting, early Troughton.)
It’s only when we are told that the moon is an egg, and there is a baby about to be born, that we start dealing with the lore surrounding Yule. Kill the Moon, then, is a story that fits perfectly between the last and first sabbats on the Wiccan Wheel of the Year: Samhain, the last sabbat of the old year, and Yule, the first of the new one.
What, then, is In the Forest of the Night?
That’s an easy one: This is a Beltane story.
Like Samhain, Beltane is one of the four cross-quarter sabbats. (They are also called fire sabbats, due to their Celtic origins and general propensity for the lighting of bonfires as part of ceremonial rituals.) But where Samhain is a festival of darkness and a night of remembrance of the dead, Beltane is its equal and opposite: a celebration of light, life, and fertility.
In Wiccan lore, Beltane is when the Horned God reaches the height of his powers. Stirred by the energies at work in nature, he desires the Goddess, with the result that they fall in love and unite – May Day (the first day of May) is their wedding day, and their marriage is consummated at the same time, when the Goddess becomes pregnant with the baby boy who will grow up to become her husband.
As regards In the Forest of the Night, this is an episode where the Horned God (the Doctor) finally fixes the harmonic balance he upset in Kill the Moon, rekindling his relationship with the Goddess (Clara), making it the perfect story to watch during Beltane. (Though it was filmed closer to Litha, AKA Midsummer.)
What’s key is how he does this – by using Clara’s own tactics from before. not by saving the day per se, but by mirroring Clara’s actions in that story. Like Clara, the Doctor broadcasts a message to the people of Earth, only this time, humanity is asked to simply leave the trees alone, rather than attempt to kill them. Once again, life wins out over death, as the man whose job it is to protect the earth fulfills his role in the cycle of life, repairing the damage from before.
And near the end, the Doctor echoes Clara’s own words to him right back at her: “This is my world, too. I walk your earth, I breathe your air.” Thus, balance is restored, and the Doctor and Clara have their rift healed. They are friends again, and over the course of the next season or so, their relationship will grow from a few sparks into a roaring fire, just like the solar flare in the last scene of the story.
But even as we celebrate this triumph, darker forces are at work. Making a cameo appearance at the very end of this story is Missy – the wicked witch of Gallifrey. She’s got a plan, and next week, we’ll get to find out what it is.
Get ready. Samhain is coming.
Leave a Reply