Off the Beatle Track: Yellow Submarine Songtrack

It’s 1999, the very last year of the 20th century. That year, a restored version of the Yellow Submarine movie was released to VHS and DVD, meaning that (among other things) American audiences now got to see the “Hey Bulldog” sequence, which had been cut from the American print of the film in 1968.

Accompanying this was an expanded and remixed soundtrack album, called the Yellow Submarine Songtrack. As the title implies, there’s no George Martin music here, just 15 Beatles songs – all but one of the tracks featured in the movie, either in full or in excerpts. Technologically, this album is worth mentioning because it was the very first time any Beatles music had been remixed, rather than simply remastered. (This will be important later.)

At this point, I should probably explain the difference between a remix and a remaster: a remaster is simply a new master of an existing track. All the various mixing decisions of the original have been preserved, all that happens for remastering is noise removal, equalization, compression, or limiting if needed.

In the case of Beatles remasters, the engineers assigned to the project in question usually take the original multitrack source tapes and transfer them into a digital format so they can be tweaked. The results are then sent to Paul, Ringo, and the families of John and George for approval, and if they’re happy, then the project is released to the general public.

A remix, on the other paw, is a very different kettle of fish. A remix is a completely new mix of a song, wherein various elements are changed from how they were on the original master. In the case of the Songtrack, they hired mix engineer Peter Cobbin a senior engineer at Abbey Road, in place of the retired George Martin.

Cobbin completely remixed every song on the album, to create a stereo mix for each track that made more sense for compact disc rather than vinyl. Cobbin could do it because he had access to the original multitrack tapes for each song, rather than the final album masters, allowing him to move stuff around. Among other things, Cobbin’s efforts meant that for the first time, songs from the Rubber Soul album now had vocals panned in the center rather than hard right.

The Songtrack was re-released for the Yellow Submarine DVD and Blu-ray release in 2012, in packaging similar to 2009 Beatles remasters of 3 years earlier. This is the version I have, and will be writing about.

With that said, let’s take a deeper dive:


Yellow Submarine: This is probably my favorite mix of the song – the sound effects are here, but not overbearing. The vocals during the choruses are spread out all over the stereo field, and you can hear John doing his shouted responses to Ringo’s lines more clearly!

Hey Bulldog: While not my favorite mix of the song (that honor goes to the 2023 remix from the expanded Blue album) this one is probably my second favorite, and it’s the one I would usually go with in my playlists. John’s lead vocal comes through nice and clear, compared to how he’s buried on the mono mix.

‘Eleanor Rigby’: While this has always been a great song, I really like this mix. The strings are a bit dry compared to the Anthology 2 version, but you adapt! The big thing here is the legit double-tracking on Paul’s vocal during the choruses – on other mixes of the song, they still use ADT instead. (Artificial Double Tracking.)

‘Love You To’: I like the way George is in the center here. He sounds great, and so does the rest of the song! Lots of double-tracking here, I think, which I like.

‘All Together Now’: At last, the vocals are in the center! It seems a little bit lop-sided though, since the guitar is panned all the way to the left, though it does get better once John’s lines come in. As Beatles songs go, I’d say this one is very underrated, it’s kind of great.

‘Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds’: Until 2017 this was the best stereo mix this song ever got, though I do notice the flange effect on John’s vocal is a bit less pronounced. Still, it’s not bad, though I do find I’m preferring the Giles Martin version more these days.

‘Think For Yourself’: This has long been one of my favorite Rubber Soul songs, and I am so glad that it finally has a decent stereo mix. It’s very crisp-sounding, and I’m glad that George’s vocal is allowed to spread around the stereo field. I do kind of wish the drums had more presence though.

‘Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’: The song is as energetic as it’s ever been, but I find the mix here is a bit flat? The louder crowd noises are nice though. I question the decision to move George’s lead guitar off to the side.

‘With A Little Help From My Friends’: The switch between tracks is seamless, but I do notice a bit of low end drops out of the crowd as we switch songs. Still, the mix is good, especially for the late ‘90s.

‘Baby You’re A Rich Man’: This has to be one of the most obscure Beatles songs out there, and it’s really great, especially when we hit the chorus. It’s like John is everywhere!

‘Only A Northern Song’: This song was always great, but it’s so nice to hear it in true stereo. It accompanies one of the trippiest scenes in the whole movie, and it periodically astounds me when I remember it was made during the Pepper sessions.

‘All You Need Is Love’: I really enjoy the way the vocals are spread out during the introduction. On most mixes of the song, it’s easy to tell that John’s vocal was run through ADT, but on this version, he’s entirely single tracked during the verses. The guitar solo sounds a little weird to me though.

‘When I’m Sixty-Four’: I really like this mix – the instruments are spread out really nicely around the stereo field, and Paul’s lead vocal is nice and clear.

‘Nowhere Man’: The second and last Rubber Soul song on the album, and until 2023, this version was my go-to stereo version of the track. It’s probably second favorite now, and I still really like it! I love the way the vocals are spread around the left and right channels, and the lead guitar sounds phenomenal.

‘It’s All Too Much’: One of the best mixes on the album, to be sure. The drums woke me right up, and shortly, so did everything else! Cobbin really pulled out all the stops on this track, and it shows! I don’t know if Giles Martin will ever remix this song, but if he does, this is the one to beat!


The Songtrack, much as I like the George Martin tracks on the original album, is miles ahead of the original 1969 album for me. You get way more Beatles music compared to that, and it’s all so great! It’s a wonderful encapsulation of the band in their psychedelic era, just like the movie was.

The Songtrack also proves that when handled well, this music can be remixed to suit modern ears, and without losing any of the qualities that we associate with Beatles songs. This is when their music truly becomes timeless. The songs on this album are no longer products of the late ‘60s, they sound just as fresh and modern as anything else. What a wonderful way to cap off the 20th century, and usher in the beginning of the 21st – by ensuring, without a doubt, that this band and their music are immortal.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑