And now for something completely different. I wrote this piece as part of Julia Serano’s initiative to protest against the Democratic Party beginning to capitulate to Republicans on the issue of transgender rights. Let’s hex some fucking fascists.
I remember 2015. The year Caitlin Jenner came out. Laverne Cox was on Orange is the New Black and everyone was talking about “the transgender tipping point.” In Britain there was an adorable sitcom called Boy Meets Girl about a cis guy, Leo, who falls in love with Judy, an older trans woman. The pairing shouldn’t work but it did, because the writers cared about getting it right.
Things looked good in the last year or so of the Obama administration, and then… well. The 2016 election happened, and everything went to Hell in a hand basket. I remember the week of 11/9 like I remember so many other horrible nightmarish days: far too clearly. I wandered around downtown St. Louis in a daze, headed for my internship at a radio station, and wondered who on the train and in the street had voted to send trans people like me into four years of damnation.
Republicans have spent the last 8 years turning the country against my community, just like they did with marriage equality in the Bush-Kerry election of 2004. And even though Biden won in 2020 and did more for my community than any other president, things didn’t actually get better. Most of Biden’s initiatives got blocked. And the ones that didn’t are going to be repealed anyway by the Trump regime in January.
But here’s the thing: that part doesn’t surprise me. For my entire existence on this Danu-forsaken planet, all 30 years of it, Republicans have been the Party of No. Anything a Democrat does, they’re against, and it gets undone ASAP… if the Democrat is allowed to do it at all. Which, a lot of times, they aren’t. It’s not just enough to win elections anymore, you have to have judges too, and Democrats spent way too much time sitting on their hands while the GOP took over the court system.
Last summer, in the aftermath of Harris becoming the Democratic nominee and a new surge of optimism, I wrote a piece on Patreon about the Democrats finally listening to the blunt advice given by Bruno Gianelli in an episode of The West Wing:
“I am tired of working for candidates who make me think I should be embarrassed to believe what I believe, Sam. I’m tired of getting them elected.”
”We all need some therapy, because somebody came along and said “liberal” means soft on crime, soft on drugs, soft on Communism, soft on defense, and we’re gonna tax you back to the Stone Age, because people shouldn’t have to go to work if they don’t want to.”
“And instead of saying “Well, excuse me, you right-wing, reactionary, xenophobic, homophobic, anti-education, anti-choice, pro-gun, ‘Leave it to Beaver’ trip back to the fifties,” we cowered in the corner and said “Please, don’t hurt me.”
At the time, I wrote that the Harris campaign felt like a breath of fresh air. After 30 years of letting the Third Way Clinton Democrats call the shots, we finally had a taste of something new, and I allowed myself to feel hopeful that she would win the day, and I could look forward to watching her inauguration on January 20th.
But then something happened. It wasn’t just that Harris started doing rallies with Liz fucking Cheney, it wasn’t just that seemingly half the Democratic National Convention this year was Republicans talking about how awful Trump was. Hell, it wasn’t even that Tim Walz went from calling Republicans weird in stump speeches to barely being seen at all.
It was that Sarah McBride, who got a prime stage speaking slot in 2020, was unceremoniously pushed aside to make room for those aforementioned Republicans. It was that when questioned by Bret Baier during a Fox News interview about whether she’d continue to support trans healthcare as president, simply responded with “We’ll follow the law.”
The Democratic Party, the only party billing itself as the Ally of All Queer People Everywhere, had started to push back on us.
And it only got worse after the election. You got Seth Moulton being quoted in the New York Times talking about how he doesn’t think his two daughters should be forced to compete against “formerly male” athletes. You got almost the entire House Democratic caucus keeping their collective mouths shut about Nancy Mace’s bathroom bill and Mike Johnson’s bullshit bathroom rule, AOC excepted.
But you know what really took the cake? What really had me sitting up and realizing that if something isn’t done, every trans person in America is fucked?
Watching Sarah McBride, the only trans person to serve in national office, roll over and talk about “not being here to talk about bathrooms,” and framing the issue as a “distraction.” The way she talked about “reaching across the aisle,” as if there’s anything worth reaching across for when the people on the other side WANT YOU AND ME DEAD, SARAH.
And before someone tells me that she shouldn’t be expected to carry our collective weight, allow me to point out that this woman got her start in politics through trans activism. She wouldn’t be where she is without us. So for her to sit here and stab us in the back like this, at the moment where we need leadership and support the most?
Gotta say, I’m pretty fucking tired of being betrayed by people I thought I could trust. If the only trans Congresswoman in America can’t be bothered to stand up for her community, what chance do the rest of us have?
For too fucking long, the Democratic Party has taken our votes for granted. In the two-party system that we have, we can’t afford to split off into our own party because that would be a great way of ensuring Republican victories at every level of government for the rest of time. So we hold our noses and vote for Democrats, because the alternative is fascism.
But I want to say something to all the Democrats out there who are looking at the trans community and deciding that maybe the Thing to Do, the Magic Secret to Winning Again, is to throw us under the bus. That if they “move to the center” on trans issues, they might get leverage to do other things that they want to do, because surely, Republicans can negotiate in good faith!
First of all, that has NEVER worked. Not even once. Because if you give the GOP an inch, not only will they take a mile, they’ll take a hundred miles because now they know you can be manipulated into doing what they want. All they care about is power, and doing whatever it takes to keep it.
Which leads me to my second point: all “moving to the center” does is mean you start advocating policy positions that were in the GOP platform back in the Bush years. (41 or 43, I don’t care.) We saw this happen with immigration, and I swear to Danu and Cernunnos, if I see this happen with queer rights I will flip my shit.
And then I’ll change my registration to the Working Families Party instead, because I refuse to support a party that throws me and my people to the wolves for the sake of scoring political points that they’re not going to fucking win anyway.
Because that’s the other thing: MOVING TO THE RIGHT NEVER WORKS. THEY JUST VOTE REPUBLICAN. This past election, the Clinton Democrats told Harris and Walz to stop being themselves and play the same old hits. They ran the exact campaign that the consultants wanted them to, and what did it get them?
A loss. They stole defeat from the jaws of victory again.
No more.
Call your senators, call your representatives, and inform them that if they start backsliding on trans rights, you will not be voting for them next election. Vote third party, stay home, vote for a primary opponent, or hell, become that primary opponent. Tell them you will not tolerate anything less than full-throated support of trans people in the next four years, or else they can kiss their incumbencies goodbye.
The Republicans have made it clear that their end goal is to exterminate all LGBTQ+ people. The Democrats need to respond by protecting us using every means at their disposal, up to and including fighting dirty, because the days of “norms” are long over.
Because if they don’t?
Our blood is on their hands.
We’re not fucking going back. And neither should they.
Leave a Reply