The Midnight Hour: All You Ever Do is Walk Away (The Woman Who Lived)

This is an episode that I have far less pleasant memories of watching for the first time. A friend of mine from the furry fandom, Sparky, came down from Liverpool to visit me at school, and we watched this episode together on my laptop. It was, to be blunt, one of the most uncomfortable and awkward experiences I’ve ever had.

In retrospect, I should’ve guessed he was a piece of shit from the word go. He just had a deeply unsettling aura during my one and only visit with him, something that was only confirmed in January 2019 when I learned he was a sexist, racist, transphobic asshat. And of course, he was a big-time Doctor Who fan. Because apparently, I haven’t met enough people in this fandom who turn out to be awful during the first week or so of January in any given year.

The week this story aired, I was in Plymouth visiting another friend of mine, Karyn. She and I first met back on the MLP roleplay site Fillydelphia, and after we re-established contact with each other in 2013, we’ve been friends ever since. I still fondly remember that long drive we took from London to Plymouth, where we spent the whole time shooting the breeze.

Once in Plymouth, we stopped off at a grocery store for pizza, and then went to her house, where we talked some more. (That was also the week where I first ate Jammy Dodgers and jelly babies, visited Plymouth Sound, and bought a paperback copy of Beautiful Darkness at a Waterstone’s. Also she introduced me to Hot Fuzz.)

So anyway, the episode. It’s… a weird one, to be sure. The writer, Catherine Tregenna, was best known for her work on Torchwood before making the jump to Who, and it really shows. While there is an alien menace to defeat, it feels very shoehorned in, as though Tregenna remembered only at the last second that she isn’t writing for Torchwood anymore, and so the lion-like alien pops up for a few action sequences.

As TVTropes observes, “Leandro has no character development or personality; we never get an explanation for why his kind are invading Earth, or any true information about them.” He’s like the Doctor Who equivalent of that occasional Monty Python character who says “This is my only line,” before the scene cuts away to a different sketch.

Because of the refusal to conform to the traditional structure of a Doctor Who story, this is an episode that instead spends a lot of time ruminating on the Doctor’s choice, at the end of the previous episode, to save Ashildr’s life by making her immortal using Mire tech.

The end result? Ashildr spends the next eight centuries never aging, living a life she can’t even remember, except for the voluminous diaries she’s kept. She doesn’t even remember her original name, so she calls herself Me and does things like “commit highway robbery” to stave off the inevitable boredom.

And that really is what most of this episode is about: the Doctor and Ashildr having a discussion about the paternalistic “duty of care” he has. Toward the end, Ashildr decides that just as he protects the Earth from various alien invaders, she’ll protect the Earth from him, looking after the people he leaves behind:

ASHILDR: Someone has to look out for the people you abandon. Who better than me? I’ll be the patron saint of the Doctor’s leftovers. While you’re busy protecting this world, I’ll get busy protecting it from you.

DOCTOR: So are we enemies now?

ASHILDR: Of course not. Enemies are never a problem. It’s your friends you have to watch out for. And, my friend, I’ll be watching out for you.

DOCTOR: Ashildr, I think I’m very glad I saved you.

ASHILDR: Oh, I think everyone will be.

Incidentally, this conversation is why the title song for this story is “All You Ever Do is Walk Away.” It comes from the Magnetic Fields’ 1994 album Holiday, from which the song titles for the last two posts (“Deep Sea Diving Suit” and “The Trouble I’ve Been Looking For”) were also taken. The album begins with a song called “BBC Radiophonic Workshop,” from whom we got the Doctor Who theme music.

Lyrically, it definitely feels like a song that fits the Doctor perfectly, especially in his twelfth incarnation:

Sad as a painted clown, a beautiful boy in an ugly town

but when your circus closes down don’t walk away from me

you’ve been asleep too long, the birds are bruises in the dawn

the pounds of flesh between us stretch as far as you can see

But all you ever do is walk away and I know if you’d only go slow

you could see what it means to be making the scene with me

But all you ever do is walk away and I think if you tried

you could find a little time

for the life I can see in your eyes, don’t go. Don’t go.

Sometimes you just explode and no one alive can break your code

You have a language of your own, an unconnected road

The people you called your friends, the places you won’t go again

The decades lost in finding them, you’ll have to let them go.

But all you ever do is walk away and I know if you’d only go slow

With the benefit of hindsight, the dramatic irony and foreshadowing laden in the quoted conversation is thick as can be, given what happens the next time the Doctor and Ashildr cross paths. They may be friends, but it’s a friendship where at least one half of the couple clearly doesn’t like the other. A friendship of inconvenience, we might call it.

Still, at least Ashildr is honest with the Doctor about the fact that she resents him for what he did to her. That puts her above the more manipulative types I’ve known over the years like Sam Maleski, who spent a long time carrying on one of these friendships of inconvenience with me until he was dramatically unmasked as a piece of shit.

Which just goes to show, Ashildr’s line about “Enemies are never a problem. It’s your friends you have to watch out for,” is truer than most of us want to admit.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑