In fairness, Clara Oswald’s death really shouldn’t have been a surprise. The clues were right there, all along, for us to find.
Remember back in September 2015, when a promotional image for The Magician’s Apprentice came out? This would be the one with Peter Capaldi, Jenna Coleman, and a couple Daleks doing the Abbey Road walk right outside… well, Abbey Road Studios, where the Beatles recorded from 1962 to 1970.
But there were some…. interesting things about that picture. Clues, hidden in plain sight. The Doctor Who version of a particularly (in)famous Beatles myth – the “Paul is Dead” conspiracy theory.
To quote extensively from Wikipedia:
Many versions of this theory have arisen since its initial exposure to the public, but most proponents of the theory maintain that, on 9 November 1966, McCartney had an argument with his bandmates during a Sgt. Pepper recording session and drove off angrily in his car, distracted by a meter maid (“Lovely Rita”), not noticing that the traffic lights had changed (“A Day In The Life”), crashed, and was decapitated (“Don’t Pass Me By”).
A funeral service for McCartney was held, with eulogies by Harrison (“Blue Jay Way”) and Starr (“Don’t Pass Me By”), followed by a procession (Abbey Road’s front cover), with Lennon as the priest officiating his funeral and burying him (the alleged “I Buried Paul” statement in “Strawberry Fields Forever”).
To spare the public from grief, or simply as a joke, the surviving Beatles replaced him with the winner of a McCartney look-alike contest. This scenario was facilitated by the Beatles’ recent retirement from live performance and by their choosing to present themselves with a new image for their next album, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (which began recording later that month).
“Clues” spread throughout the Beatles’ later albums hinting at Paul’s demise were later documented by fans, including everything from John and George admitting to and/or hinting at the switch via playing records backwards, to even details about album cover art. One site I remember looking at back in the 2000s held that to hold an open hand over someone’s head (as happens to Paul on the Pepper cover) is a death omen.
But the real fun starts when we get to, you guessed it, Abbey Road. The theory holds that the procession of the Beatles on the cover is that of a funeral procession:
“Lennon, dressed in white, is said to symbolize the heavenly figure; Starr, dressed in black, symbolizes the undertaker; George Harrison, in denim, represents the gravedigger; and McCartney, barefoot and out of step with the others, symbolizes the corpse.
“The number plate of the white Volkswagen Beetle in the photo – containing the characters LMW 281F – was identified as further “evidence”. “28IF” represented McCartney’s age “if” he had still been alive, while “LMW” stood for “Linda McCartney weeps” or “Linda McCartney, widow” (although McCartney and the then-Linda Eastman had not yet met in 1966, the year of his alleged death). That the left-handed McCartney held a cigarette in his right hand was also said to support the idea that he was an impostor.”
Naturally, the Doctor Who production team threw in quite a few “Paul is Dead” shout-outs in their version of the cover photo picture. And if, like me, you were a Beatles scholar, you would know what they were immediately:
-
Jenna is dressed all in black, like Paul was on the original cover.
-
She is also barefoot (again, like Paul).
-
The index finger on Jenna’s right hand is extended, just like Paul’s infamous cigarette.
-
The white 1960s style Volkswagen Beetle, aside from being parked in the same place as the one from 1969, has a fake license plate reading DWW 291F. Or, “Doctor Who Weeps,” and Clara would have been 29 if she survived.
And when did Face the Raven air? November 21st, 2015: two days before Clara’s 29th birthday. And unlike Paul, she really did get replaced with an impostor! (A Zygon, but still!)
But macabre Beatles in-jokes aren’t the only omens of death floating around this particular season of Doctor Who, and around Clara specifically. Because in this episode, we get the biggest one of all…
The raven.
Quoting again: “Because of its black plumage, croaking call, and diet of carrion, the raven is often associated with loss and ill omen. Yet, its symbolism is complex. As a talking bird, the raven also represents prophecy and insight. Ravens in stories often act as psychopomps, connecting the material world with the world of spirits.”
Obviously, a story called “Face the Raven” is going to go to town with the whole “raven as a death omen” thing. The title itself literally means, “Face death.” But for me, ravens have additional spiritual significance: where there are ravens, or crows, there is the Morrígan.
For those who don’t know her, the Morrígan is the Irish Celtic goddess of death, warfare, and prophecy. Her name is actually a title (much like the Doctor) and can mean “Phantom Queen” or “Great Queen.” She has two sisters, Badb and Macha, and all three of them are referred to collectively as the Morrigna. She can even shapeshift, and has frequently appeared in Irish myth as a raven or crow, making her the perfect goddess to invoke in a murder mystery.
But the key thing I think about regarding the Morrígan, and how she relates to this episode specifically, is in her role as a sovereignty goddess. Look again at Clara’s last words to the Doctor before she goes off to face her death:
CLARA: You. Now, you listen to me. You’re going to be alone now, and you’re very bad at that. You’re going to be furious and you’re going to be sad, but listen to me. Don’t let this change you. No, listen. Whatever happens next, wherever she is sending you, I know what you’re capable of. You don’t be a Warrior. Promise me. Be a Doctor.
DOCTOR: What’s the point of being a Doctor if I can’t cure you?
CLARA: Heal yourself. You have to. You can’t let this turn you into a monster. So, I’m not asking you for a promise, I’m giving you an order. You will not insult my memory. There will be no revenge. I will die, and no one else, here or anywhere, will suffer.
What Clara Oswald has been about, from the moment we first met her, is insisting on being in control of her own story. Of having agency, and having sovereignty. She doesn’t like it when other people presume to have some power over her, especially not the Doctor. She is a woman who expects to be in control of her own story, up to and including the manner in which she passes on and moves into the Otherworld.
Being a sovereignty goddess, the Morrigan is the ideal deity for this story. In the ancient myths, we see that she protects the sovereignty of the land, such as in the stories about the first and second Battles of Mag Truied, where she helps the peoples of Ireland fight off waves of various invaders.
She also protects the sovereignty of the people, as in the stories about the death of Conaire Mór, a king who broke his spiritual contract with the Otherworld. In the story The Destruction of Da Derga’s Hostel, Badb, one of the Morrigan’s sisters, appears to him as a crone and curses him, leading to his death not long afterwards.
In a modern context, the definition of sovereignty has shifted. It has become more personal, reflective of autonomy in the face of societies that seek to control and dominate us. As Morgan Daimler writes, “In our modern world many people feel disempowered in their lives, making the idea of reconnecting with personal power an alluring one, and something that the Morrigan can help with by pushing us to find our own sense of sovereignty. She is not, in this case, a giver of sovereignty to those who seek it, but rather she will challenge us to fight for the independence and strength we need to feel like we are in control of our own selves.”
One thing I’ve noticed about the gods, and the Morrigan in particular, is that they take a very active role in the lives of the mortals they work with. In the case of the Morrigan, she has been with me my entire life, and has watched me struggle to be my own self-advocate. Her mission, over these past few months, has been to challenge me to change that. To claim myself, and insist on my own sovereignty, as my namesake Lena Duchannes did.
I’ll give you an example from my own life. When I first formally contacted her last July, one of the things she told me during our interaction was that I needed to begin regular meditation. I have spent my entire life, up until very recently, being defined by the views of other people: my mother, my friends, my former friends. What my fiancee and I have discovered is that the Morrigan wants me grounded in my own wisdom and inner life, not in others’ expectations.
Again from Daimler: “The Morrigan stands before us and says: “Who rules your life? Dare to be your own sovereign, dare to rule over your own flesh, dare to be in control of your own self.”
And Clara Oswald has always been her own sovereign. She doesn’t need the Morrigan’s help on that score. So instead, the Morrigan flies toward Clara and leads her into the Otherworld, into eternity. When we next see her, she will have ascended beyond mortality, and joined the ranks of the gods.
But first, the Doctor has to go through Hell.
Leave a Reply