Claim Yourself: New Girl/A Hole in the Sky

It’s been a very long time since I was the new girl in school like Lena here, but I have been new to various close-knit communities, be they on Discord or in real life, like when I moved to Ithaca’s local eco-village. The one common denominator between groups like these, regardless of where they are, is that if you’re not part of the In Group, you become a social pariah.

There’s a certain amount of gatekeeping that goes on in small, close-knit communities like Gatlin in general, and Jackson High in specific. People like to be around Their Own Kind, whether that means conservative Christians, leftist fans of science fiction shows, or what have you. Depending on the community, sometimes you’ll be given a chance to prove you can fit in. But if you ever cross a line, you’re out.

For example: Before I moved to the village where I currently live, I was made to complete a Membership Checklist, which included doing things like coming to visit the village for five consecutive days, go on a tour, and learn more about the kinds of things that would be expected of me as a resident.

I wanted to make sure all my i’s were dotted and t’s were crossed, so as to not make trouble for my girlfriend, who once received a sternly-worded email from one of the folks in charge of these things for not doing this with two of her previous roommates.

And while it worked, I will admit I still feel a certain amount of discomfort living around here. This village caters to well-to-do whites, most of whom are in their 40s, 50s, or 60s. While there are families with kids, there’s not too many. I don’t feel like a genuine part of the community, and much like Lena with regard to Jackson High, I don’t want to be either. I’m only here because my girlfriend is.

All of this is to say that like Lena, I understand how it feels to be in a place where you don’t first the typical idea of who should belong to a community – at least my neighbors are nicer than Emily and Savannah, both whom uncomfortably remind me of girls I went to high school with. (They probably grew up to become Trump voters.)

Anyway. One of the things I like about this book is how skillfully Garcia and Stohl weave the story of To Kill A Mockingbird (mentioned early in the chapter as Ethan’s summer reading assignment) into the early plot of the book.

Both novels are set in small, isolated Southern towns (Maycomb and Gatlin) with deeply conservative residents, while the narrators (Scout and Ethan) are the children of respected, educated family members: Ethan’s parents were professors, while Atticus Finch is a lawyer. Both the Finch and Wate families also employ Black housekeepers: Calpurnia and Amma respectively. There’s even a character named Link!

Macon, naturally, is explicitly compared to Boo Radley – the townspeople refer to him derisively as Old Man Ravenwood, and he’s described as never leaving his house for any reason whatsoever. (Except later, we discover that Macon isn’t so much a Boo Radley as the Caster version of Atticus Finch, as Ethan himself realizes.)

Lena doesn’t have an exact equivalent in Mockingbird, so she inherits a lot of the social pariah aspects that her uncle gets. Just look at the way she’s talked about by Savannah and Emily in the lunchroom scene: judgmental as fuck, in that catty, vicious way you see in teen movies all the time. (Mean Girls springs to mind.)

The basketball team Ethan plays with at the end of the chapter isn’t much better – though he does catch a glimpse of Lena driving Macon’s hearse. And not a second after Emory makes another comment about her, it starts raining. I like to think that’s Lena’s revenge.

***

After Ethan gets a scolding from Amma about his inability to get to school on time, chapter 3 gives us our first glimpse of Ethan’s father – he is described as being a writer, and a recent widower. His wife, Lila Evers Wate, died in an accident the preceding April, and he’s been holed up in his study ever since.

The comparison is never made directly, but if anyone in this book is a Boo Radley, it’s Mitchell Wate. Here’s how Ethan describes him:

“As he stepped into the kitchen light, the half-smile faded to a quarter, and then it was gone. He looked even worse than usual. The shadows on his face were darker, and you could see the bones under his skin. His face was a pallid green from never leaving the house. He looked a little bit like a living corpse, as he had for months now.”

Understandably, poor Mitchell suffers from severe (and undiagnosed) depression. One would think he’s working on the book to give himself something to do, and indeed, that’s what Ethan thinks. But is he really? We’ll answer that question later.

The main action of the chapter takes place the next day, when Lena finally arrives for her first day of school. Her introduction has to be one of my all time favorites:

“But all I could see was a beautiful girl in a long gray dress, under a white track jacket with the word Munich sewn on it, and beat-up black Converse peeking out underneath. A girl who wore a long silver chain around her neck, with tons of stuff dangling from it—a plastic ring from a bubblegum machine, a safety pin, and a bunch of other junk I was too far away to see. A girl who didn’t look like she belonged in Gatlin. I couldn’t take my eyes off her.”

My favorite line, though, comes a couple paragraphs later: “She had the greenest eyes I’d ever seen, so green they could’ve been considered some new color altogether.”

Eye color is significant in the Caster world – green eyes denote someone who is Light, or Unclaimed, in Lena’s case. Gold eyes are for Dark Casters, like Lena’s cousin Ridley. The way Lena’s eyes are described here hint at her true nature as a magic user, as Casters are described as being not quite human.

Poor Lena spends the entire scene being leered at and judged by everyone except Ethan, but to her credit, she doesn’t give any of them the time of day. That’s always been one of my favorite things about her – she doesn’t try to change herself to fit in with everyone else. Even the one time she does, in Beautiful Darkness, there are extenuating circumstances.

While Lena’s decision to sit in front of Mrs. English’s desk may have been more out of ignorance about Jackson social protocol than anything else, I still like that she does it, even after Ethan tells her about Mrs. English’s glass eye. It shows she’s an independent spirit, just like the fact that she reads for fun, rather than because she has to. Her love of reading and her independence remind me so much myself, both when I was fifteen (the same year this book came out) and now. It’s part of why I’m named after her.

At the end of the chapter, Ethan grabs Link’s keys and ditches basketball practice to go after Lena.. during an absolutely torrential thunderstorm. Join me next week for chapter 4, where Ethan and Lena have their first conversation.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑