Wolf Trek: The Royale

Captain’s log, stardate 80138.2: Riker, Worf and Data transport to the surface of what should be a poison-shrouded world after finding debris of a NASA space vessel, and discover a structure containing a reproduction of the literary Hotel and Casino Royale.


Sadly, this is not a crossover with Casino Royale, the first James Bond novel by Ian Fleming. Which is honestly kind of a shame, because when that book was released in America back in the 1950s, they gave it the title You Asked For It, and this was the summary on the back cover:

If he hadn’t been a tough operator, Jimmy Bond would never have risked a weekend with a woman who used her magnificent body as a weapon to destroy him …

But it was toughness that had landed Jimmy his job with the Secret Service – the job of smashing the ruthless Le Chiffre and his spy network – no matter how many women tried to stop him…

I burst out laughing when I read that summary, because it makes the book sound exactly like the same kind of trashy pulp novel that Hotel Royale (the fictional book this episode centers around) is supposed to be. Certainly I felt that way when I read it – I thought Casino Royale would be a real page-turner of a novel, given that it’s James Bond we’re talking about. And then I discovered it was actually extremely boring. (Also incredibly racist and sexist, but that’s mid-20th century art for you. Just look at the original Star Trek, every episode of Get Smart where The Claw shows up, and Doctor Who until the late ‘70s.)

Honestly, I would’ve liked to have seen Riker, Data, and Worf find themselves up against a character named Jimmy Bond – a suave secret agent played by whoever the American equivalent of Sean Connery (or, given this was made in the late 1980s, Timothy Dalton) would be. We already have two different styles of detective characters, between Dixon Hill and Sherlock Holmes, so surely Americanized Bond wouldn’t be too much of a stretch.

Speaking of Dixon Hill, this episode was one of Tracy Tormé’s other contributions to TNG. According to Memory Alpha: 

“Writer Tracy Tormé first pitched the story (then called “The Blue Moon Hotel”) to Robert Lewin during the first season, and it was one of two scripts that won Tormé a staff job on TNG. According to Tormé: “There had been a lot of talk about doing it in the first year, but finally [in the second] year they gave me the green light and told me to go ahead and do it. It became ‘The Royale,’ and I wrote a draft which was, again, a bit of a departure for Star Trek. It was kind of a surrealistic piece, with a lot of comedy and lot of subtle satire in it.”

The final draft script ended up being a page-one rewrite by Maurice Hurley, which pissed Tormé off so much that he ultimately decided not to return for season 3 despite having been invited to, believing it was time to move on to bigger and better things.

I will note that the bit about there being 52 US states by the time of the 2030s hits a lot different now, given that Donald Trump has discussed annexing Canada and Greenland, than it did when I first watched this episode in 2022, during my pre-Picard binge. Even the exploration mission that Col. Richey was a part of sounds like one of Elon Musk’s boondoggles, ala colonizing Mars.

The entire episode is terrible, but for me anyway, it comes back around into being “So Bad, It’s Good” territory. As the trope page notes, “Rather than it unintentionally Breaking the Fourth Wall like usual, something about the specifics of the work in question instead cause an enjoyable, though equally unintended, emotional response in the viewing public.”

There’s a lot of Mystery Science Theater 3000 episodes that fall into such a category, though my two favorite examples are Santa Claus Conquers the Martians from season 3 and Werewolf from season 9. The former is an objectively low-budget Christmas movie saved by the endearing performances of John Call as Santa Claus and the various actors who play the Martians, while Werewolf is saved by dint of having people like R.C. Bates (Sam the Keeper) and Richard Lynch (Noel, later in TNG’s late two-parter “Gambit”) in it.

So, given that, why is it that I find this episode perfectly enjoyable to watch, while something like “The Dauphin” is a dreary bore? The answer is that while Will Wheaton has always been a better actor than he’s ever given himself credit for, that’s not the same thing as being uniformly good. A boy of that age can only do so much to salvage weak material, he doesn’t have the experience needed to pull off something like, say, Patrick Stewart powering through “Code of Honor” with the magic of British deadpan humor.

“The Royale” is saved mainly by the fundamental weirdness of watching three 24th century beings wander around a bad hotel and be completely out of place, though none of the locals ever bat an eyelash. (My personal favorite moment is in the hotel room scene where the phone rings and Worf answers with a blunt “YES,” and then reacting to how Col. Richey died with “What a terrible way to die.” Michael Dorn is gifted with truly legendary comedy skills.)

But of course, most of the credit has to go to Brent Spiner, who is clearly having the time of his life when we get to Data fixing the dice and winning at the craps table. It’s difficult to describe Spiner’s physicality, but it’s the perfect episode to watch if you’re in the mood to see him employ the particular brand of subtle comedy he uses when playing Data, from expressions to the innocent-deadpan delivery of lines like “What sort of business do you suppose he is getting down to?” and “Baby needs a new pair of shoes.”

What I’m saying is, just in a three-week span we’ve had some bad TNG, (“The Dauphin”) sheer brilliance, (“Contagion”) and now endearingly bad with “The Royale.” This is the kind of variety you rarely see in modern television these days, what with the move to streaming and seasons that are only ten episodes long. One hopes, as it looks increasingly like the streaming bubble is closer to popping than more people want to admit, that we might return to the 26-week glory days again.

Meanwhile, stay tuned next week for the first of TNG’s many time travel-related escapades, featuring Patrick Stewart pulling double duty in “Time Squared.”

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑