I remember very little about this episode, except that it was presented with a binaural sound mix. Which is cool, speaking as someone with a degree in audio production, but it means practically nothing to me since it only ever came out on BBC iPlayer… and I’m American. We don’t have iPlayer here. But this is the price you pay for liking a British TV show from outside its country of origin, so there you are. (I’m more of a Star Trek girl now anyway.)
What I do remember about this episode is the context in which I watched it.
It is May of 2017, and I have arrived at the last week of my senior year of college. This will be the final episode of the series that I watch as a student, breaking a streak begun with The Day of the Doctor 4 years earlier. As the Eleventh Doctor’s era ended coincided with me graduating high school, here is Twelve, seeing out my college days, though my degree is delayed due to me bombing my Analog Recording class and needing to make up the 3 credit hours later on.
“Knock Knock” is watched in the study room at the end of the hallway of the dorm floor that I’ve been living in for the last several semesters, just down from the common room where I spent a good chunk of my sophomore year figuring out my gender identity and playing Doctor Who: Legacy at about 5 in the morning because I can’t sleep.
By the following Friday, May 12th, I am done with college. I return home to my parents’ house, and after taking off the rest of May to relax and unwind from the pressure cooker that is undergrad, I decide to dip my paw into the world of freelancing as a podcast editor, since that’s pretty much the only work I can get as a recently-graduated audio major on short notice.
The following three months are something of a blur, but one exciting thing does happen: the official announcement of Jodie Whittaker’s casting as the Doctor. When I learned the news, I was sitting at the kitchen table in front of my laptop with nothing better to do, and reacted with joy and excitement – at last, the Doctor is a woman! Like me!
The formal regeneration in Twice Upon A Time inspires me to write “Regeneration, Transition, and Me,” which I have always viewed as my very first serious piece of Doctor Who-related media criticism. At the end of the piece, I wrote: “I don’t know what the future holds for either of us, the Doctor and I. But I do know that whatever happens, we will face it together, following the old promise: to never be cruel, to never be cowardly, and if we ever are, to always make amends. To laugh hard, run fast, and be kind. To be Doctors.”
Ah, the innocent idealism of youth.
***
It’s October 7th, 2018. I am in a hotel in Chicago, Illinois, on the last day of a podcasting conference I’ve been attending. After spending the past couple days attending any number of panels and surviving on carry-out fast food, I’m exhausted and am in dire need of a day off before I take the train back to St. Louis, so I spend the 7th lying around my hotel room, starting with breakfast at the Starbucks literally across the street.
In the afternoon, I turn on BBC America to watch that day’s “simulcast” of The Woman Who Fell to Earth, the first proper episode of the Whittaker era. (The “simulcast” is periodically interrupted with commercials, meaning the Brits who are watching in a telegram chat I’m in are ahead of me. Yay spoilers.) I end up having to watch the episode again when I get home, just so I can properly get a better idea of what this new era is like.
My review of the episode was wildly positive, far more than I would say of the episode now, if I could be bothered to watch it again. (And I can’t be.) My optimism crashes and burns over the ensuing ten weeks – somewhere around The Tsuranga Conundrum, I realize that the era really is as bad as I think it is and no amount of redemptive reading can, or will, save it. In my review of the season, I wrote: “He is so intent upon delivering an inoffensive product to all potential viewers that he winds up robbing the show of its soul.” (Whatever else we might say of RTD and series 14, no one can argue that the show hasn’t regained its spark.)
Writing all these episode reviews led me to explore becoming a proper media critic, which I defined as “having a site where I post things that isn’t Tumblr.” A friend at the time, Sam Maleski, “graciously” afforded me the privilege of posting stuff on their blog, DoWntime.
But what really kicked up my desire to become a media critic was joining the Eruditorum Press Discord server in November 2018. I’d gone up to Minnesota to visit my grandma for Thanksgiving, and as we began the drive back south, El did a soft launch of the server for her Patreon backers. I enthusiastically jumped in, pleased to be among like-minded folks, particularly the woman responsible for turning me on to criticism in the first place… and, indirectly, setting me on the course that my life has taken over the past several years.
I found TARDIS Eruditorum in December 2014, and I know this because I have the purchase receipt from December 28th which says I bought the first 3 volumes of TARDIS Eruditorum with Christmas money. Which implies I found the blog, and its recent coverage of the Smith era, not long before then. Eruditorum filled a specific niche in my life that I hadn’t realized was missing, and over the next few years, the community that blog spawned became my life.
All the work I’ve done with Arcbeatle, the fact I’m living in Ithaca with my fiancee, whom I met because El’s adoptive daughter introduced her to me, the half dozen or so different blogging projects I’ve written about Doctor Who, the non-Who projects I’ve got in the pipeline… none of this would’ve happened if 20 year old Lena Mactíre didn’t happen across Eruditorum one day in December 2014.
So, as my Doctor Who criticism career comes to an end, I think now is the time to thank El for all she’s made possible. As I write this I’ve only met her very briefly, at an interview she had with Margaret Killjoy, but hopefully (by the time this goes up on WordPress) I’ll have managed to have some coffee or something with her.
If nothing else, hope springs eternal.
Leave a Reply