It’s funny, isn’t it, how time changes us all.
When I started my Doctor Who criticism career six years ago, I was living at home with my parents, unemployed and miserable because I’d experienced a traumatic breakup in early 2019. Then I started writing what became the first Back to the Eleventh Hour book, and my luck began to change.
I got a job. I started hormones. I met my fiancée. I published two books, finished a third, launched an original sci-fi series, ran three blogs, expanded my criticism remit to include other things I loved, moved to New York, changed my name, found my religion, and now, I’m writing these words. My swansong as a Doctor Who critic.
True, I said I’d cover the rest of Gatwa. And I will. I also have some pieces on the Eleventh Doctor’s EU material to write. But for all intents and purposes, this is where the story ends. This is my Abbey Road: last in spirit if not in fact.
“Do you know what the hardest thing about knowing you was?” Bill asks of the Doctor toward the end of this story. She clarifies: “Letting you go. Letting go of the Doctor is so, so hard, isn’t it?”
And you know what? She’s right. Letting go is hard.
At one stage this post was going to be my lead into a series where I would look at the entirety of classic Who, from An Unearthly Child to Scream of the Shaka. But then I realized I couldn’t feasibly write about the classics the way I did the modern series, partly because the stories are so much longer and also because large chunks of the 60s are missing, and some of those recons suck.
But the truth of it all is? I’ve run out of things to say.
I completely vibe with the sense of sheer end-of-the-rope exhaustion that pervades this story, because barring the Gatwa project, that’s pretty much how I’ve felt writing about Doctor Who this year. I lost my spark for it, and I know it.
Now bear in mind: I still love the show. I always will. It’s the reason I became a writer in the first place. I have a career because of this show. I met my fiancée because of this show. I’ve made friends because of this show. But I’ve reached the end of what I feel I can productively say about it, so why not quit while I’m ahead?
After all, this is a pretty good story to wrap things up on, as far as it goes. It has our first glimpse of the Thirteenth Doctor in it, and for all that I have problems with her era, that first appearance is a moment I will always love. It’s nice to have a tie back to where I began as a critic – I’ve come full circle, the long way ‘round. There’s even a Pandorica reference! And “I Am the Doctor!”
And as I look back at my oeuvre, I have to say, I’m pretty impressed with what I’ve managed to accomplish. As of this writing, I’ve written something about every single regular episode of post-2005 Doctor Who, from Eccleston to Gatwa. I even managed a piece on Death of the Doctor, a Sarah Jane Adventures episode! (And somewhere, I have a piece on the Space/Time minisodes… I just have to track it down.)
Point is, that’s six years of writing about 20 years worth of TV. Not bad at all, is it? And I’ve done that while also managing to find my own voice as a critic. Far from being a bad clone of Elizabeth Sandifer, as Sam Maleski once said of me, my style is entirely unique. Who else would think to write a post on Kill the Moon that’s filtered through Wiccan Sabbat lore? I’m pretty proud of that one. Someone in the Eruditorum server said to me after it went up, “Yeah, in the sea of people giving capital-t Takes about this story, this and the TE entry are the only ones I’d consider necessary reading.”
Very high praise indeed, being favorably compared to the woman who was, is, and will always be the best Who critic out there. I really feel like I’ve made it as a critic now. Faced with the apex of your career, what’s left?
Answer: moving on to other things. Wolf Trek alone will probably keep me busy for a long time, even when the Paramount+ era of Star Trek comes to an end. I’ve got some more Arcbeatle projects to work on, including a long-gestating Beatles book, the sci-fi series Starlight Endeavours, and the inaugural projects of AP’s Trek crit division: Writing the Future, a book of mine about Star Trek: The Next Generation, and About Space, an episodic look at Trek in the style of About Time by Tat Wood and Lawrence Miles.
My immediate focus will be on Four Sides of the Circle, the successor project to Off the Beatle Track. Four Sides will focus on the Beatles’ solo efforts, since I’ve mined pretty much everything I can out of OTBT. By sheer coincidence, two of the albums I need for that series arrived this week, so if that isn’t a message from my gods that now is the time to switch gears, I don’t know what is.
Needless to say, I’ve got plenty to write. No blue box necessary.
Since it’s my last chance to say it though, a few words of thanks. To Sean, Jim, and all the rest of the good people at Arcbeatle for making Back to the Eleventh Hour, and all our future projects, come to life. To Frez and Fruitbat, for letting me bounce essay ideas off you and sharing my drafts. To my Patreon patrons, for letting me make money off this whole writing thing. To Sophie, for helping me stay the course no matter how bad it got.
To Elizabeth Sandifer, for helping me to realize all this was possible. And to Matt Smith, Karen Gillan, Arthur Darvill, Alex Kingston, Jenna Coleman, Peter Capaldi, Michelle Gomez, Pearl Mackie, and Steven Moffat, for inspiring me in the first place.
But most of all? I’d like to thank all of you, my readers. Everyone who’s ever shared my work on their social media, commented on a post of mine, or even just quietly viewed my words… you are why I do this. Why I am driven to write, no matter what. Nothing of what I’ve done these past six years would be possible without you, and I am immeasurably grateful, and honored, to be doing this.
As I write this, it’s a little after 11 PM Eastern time, on Friday, November 15th, 2024. I have, quite literally, gone back to the Eleventh Hour. But everything’s gotta end some time, otherwise nothing would ever get started. Snow isn’t snow until it falls.
So now, at long last…
Doctor…
I let you go.
-L.M.
What a lovely farewell. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks. ❤ I’m glad you came along!
LikeLike