Wolf Trek: Up the Long Ladder

Captain’s log, stardate 80291.8: Signals arrive from two colonies, one of which is found to be a motley collection of ‘primitives’, and the other, a group of desperate clones whose gene pool is fading. When these extremists target an Enterprise away team, Picard is forced to take action.


Remember “Code of Honor?” (I know, I don’t want to either, but here we are anyway.) This week, we suffer through the equivalent of that for Irish people. To hear Star Trek tell it, my siblings in the Emerald Isle have clearly not evolved since the 1600s, which would be big news to me, as a proud member of the Irish diaspora, and to various friends of mine who live in that country.

But what makes “Up the Long Ladder” even worse is that, because where “Code of Honor” was written by ignorant white people, “Ladder” is at least partially the fault of Maurice Hurley – TNG’s head writer as of season two. As Melinda Snodgrass explains, “It was intended to be a commentary about immigration, because I hate the current American policy. I wanted it to be something that says sometimes those outsiders you think are so smelly and wrong-colored, can bring enormous benefits to your society because they bring life and energy. That’s what I was going for. Now my boss, at the time, was Maury Hurley, who is a major Irishman and leads the Saint Patrick’s Day parade. When I was describing to him what I wanted to do, I was trying to come up with an analogy, and I said it was like a little village of Irish tinkerers, and he loved it so much he made me make them Irish tinkerers. I said okay, and that’s how it came about.”

Irish Americans, pretty justifiably, hated the final episode. And so did Colm Meaney, AN ACTUAL IRISHMAN. Regarding an attempt by the DS9 writers to put a leprechaun into the episode “If Wishes Were Horses,” he made them change it to Rumpelstiltskin because of the offensive stereotype. He said, “Using caricatures or cliches of any nation is not something Star Trek is or should be into.” 

First of all, he’s right. Second of all, WHERE THE HELL WAS THAT IN NINETEEN FUCKING EIGHTY NINE?!

I get that it was meant to be an immigration storyline – certainly, America has never had good immigration policies, just look at what was going on in the Reagan/Bush years of the late 1980s, or the Trump years, or the Obama years, or the Biden years, or the Dubya years, or the…

Basically, our immigration policy is always in need of a good satire. But “Up the Long Ladder” isn’t fucking it.

So, instead… well, I can’t talk about “The Wounded” (my second-favorite TNG, and an amazing Irish episode by dint of essentially starring Colm Meaney) until we get to season four, so instead, let me direct your attention to yet another of my fanfics, In this case, the story “Learning Curve.” 

It is very heavily inspired by my favorite movie, Wolfwalkers – a gorgeous hand-drawn animated film from 2020 that is inspired by the old Irish legend, the werewolves of Ossory, who are said to become wolves by leaving their bodies behind when they sleep, as Mebh and Robin do in the film.

Like “Up the Long Ladder,” “Learning Curve” centers around an alien world with Irish people on it, but most of the Irish beings on the planet are mythological creatures instead, rather than humans. They are being subjugated by a group of English colonists, all of whom are deeply anti-magic, and anti-Irish as well. (And if you know your Irish history, you can probably see where I’m going with this.)

I want to state also that this wasn’t just me, an American who has not been to Ireland yet, trying to write about a culture I’m not a part of. I do have Irish ancestry, and the character of Aífe MacMurrough, Gem’s XO in this story, is Irish herself and was created by an Irish person. I worked very closely with her on this story, since I didn’t want to run the risk of offense.

So, much of “Learning Curve” is focused on Aífe, since she has a more direct stake in the affairs of the Draiochti than her captain does. Gem’s half of the plot is my take on another TNG staple: the Prime Directive episode.

I have no great love for Prime Directive episodes. Just recently we had “Pen Pals,” with that great big argument in Picard’s quarters on the ethics of saving a civilization that is in immediate risk of death, and the crew of the Enterprise (until Data forces the issue) are all ready to leave the pre-warp aliens to their fate, out of fear of contaminating the native culture… or something.

That said, the situation Gem is faced with is somewhat more complicated. The planet had already been contaminated thanks to the presence of the English colonists, so her goal instead became damage control, so as to prevent any further harm done to the natives of the planet. Inciting a revolution may’ve gone beyond the requirements of the job, but on the other hoof, no one can prove they were actually involved with it.

All of that said, there are ways to write a story about Ireland in a way that actually respects the land, the people, and the culture. Even in a sci-fi setting like Star Trek, there should be no excuse for choosing to deal in stereotypes and false assumptions. As well as being morally repugnant, it’s just lazy writing as well. 

If there is anything good to be said about this episode, it’s the wonderful scene where Picard and Riker are in the cargo bay, watching as the rural Irish attempt to get used to their new living quarters. At one point, Picard turns away to regain control of himself… and when he turns back around, he’s laughing. Riker asks if he’s okay, and Picard replies, “Sometimes, Number One, you just have to bow to the absurd.”

All that laughter was entirely improvised! As scripted he’s supposed to be angry, but in the final version, Stewart and Frakes ad-libbed their dialogue, entirely to preserve the take. And you can’t even tell it’s improv! That’s how good they are at acting, those two.

Anyway. Thank goodness that’s over. 

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑