Across the Universe: Power to the People (The Robot Revolution)

I find it somewhat ironic that literally the day after my big Final Ever Doctor Who Post goes up on WordPress, here I am writing about Doctor Who again. Then again, I said I was going to do this, so here I am – the Let It Be to “She Says Hello”’s Abbey Road. And we aren’t even doing a Beatles episode this year!

Instead, what we’re doing is pretty bluntly an episode where Doctor Who and his new companion, Miss Belinda Chandra, do battle with Elon Musk. True, Alan the Dweeb isn’t running a social media site, a rocket ship company, a car company, and the US government, but on the other paw, he’s also pretty transparently living the Muskrat’s wettest of wet dreams, what with being a video gamer who becomes a robot and turns a formerly peaceful planet into an authoritarian ethnostate where women are meant to be effective non-entities outside of “breeding.”

So, okay, he’s somewhere between Elon Musk and JD Vance. And British. I’m sure he’ll vote for Reform once Keir Starmer calls a snap election in a doomed effort to save his cratering approval numbers. What can possibly go wrong?

(Answer: I see your Nazi America and raise you Nazi Britain.)

But anyway. Unironically, I adored this episode. It’s not just the fact that Belinda Chandra feels like even more of a Clara-esque companion than Ruby Sunday did, but it helps. There’s flashes of Rory in there too, insofar as she’s a nurse who isn’t afraid to call the Doctor out on his shit, but for me, the biggest point of comparison is actually from his previous era: Martha Jones.

Let’s rewind, if you will, back to 2007. Like Fifteen, Ten is traveling alone after having said goodbye to his former companion, a blonde-haired woman whose name begins with R (Ruby and Rose) at the end of the previous season. He next meets up with a non-white woman (Martha and Belinda) at a hospital, and said medical professional finds herself swept up in strange, unexplainable events that the Doctor (who spends much of the story in disguise) has to get her out of.

Robot Revolution isn’t just RTD getting back to where he once belonged and writing aggressively political Doctor Whoagain, this is him looking back on, and actively revising, his own work. In The Star Beast, we saw him quite literally go back to the circumstances surrounding Donna Noble’s mind wipe in Journey’s End and do some narrative substitution with it, transforming what had been the Doctor’s greatest failure into Donna’s moment of heroism and joy, while standing alongside her Black trans daughter, no less.

Similarly, Robot Revolution is RTD deciding to take the character archetype Martha represented and do it over pretty much entirely. Martha was presented as someone who was trying to be a doctor but hadn’t gotten there yet, Belinda is a straight up nurse, and that is not presented as being less important. She and the Doctor are equals this time, and that makes all the difference.

(Besides, I’m pretty sure that if the Doctor did try to treat Belinda like he treated Martha, Rory Pond would somehow find a way to come back to life, leave New York, and kick his ass. You do not fuck with nurses.)

As I noted back in my post on Smith and Jones, Martha was a forerunner for what Clara was during series 8 and 9 – the Doctor, only human and a Londoner. 18 years later, Davies now finds himself being able to revisit that idea, having now seen exactly what he was gesturing toward with Rose, Martha, and Donna back in the 2000s.

RTD loves Clara Oswald. He straight up said as much in #515 of Doctor Who Magazine, the great big Steven Moffat tribute issue: “And nestling at the heart of the show is Doctor Who’s very own problem category, the Companion, a title inherently subordinate to the Man. Until Clara comes along! Companion to every single moment in the Doctor’s life. A woman so strong that in her first appearance, and her last, Death itself cannot stop her.”

Moffat single-handedly redefined the role of companion, and while Chris Chibnall largely went his own way during his era, RTD picks up that baton and runs with it following his return. Watching Robot Revolution, it’s pretty easy to see that RTD didn’t just watch the Moffat years as a fan like the rest of us did. He watched it and took notes. And then, not only did he play the “What Would You Do As Showrunner” game, he’s now going ahead and doing exactly what he noted down on this metaphorical piece of paper.

RTD’s new era, in terms of tone and vibes, is a throwback to his first era, of course. But so much of it is also filtered through the Moffat years, making this era a true successor to that seven-year period. Last season gave us RTD’s take on the Impossible Girl arc, crossed with the fairytale magic of the Pond years.

Series 15, by all accounts, looks like Series 5 redux, down to the date of the series finale (6/26/2010 and 5/24/2025) being the day the world ends, but with a companion who definitely feels like the Clara Oswald of series 8 and 9, just as Ruby echoed Clara as of series 7.

And honestly, I’m here for it. No one could’ve imagined, back in 2005, that twenty years later Doctor Who would still be on screen, with RTD in charge once again, remixing and playing with its own greatest hits. But why not? At a time when the entire freaking world seems to be burning down, Doctor Who can and should be an oasis.

Because that’s the other thing about Robot Revolution that I like. This Doctor Who is not afraid to get political. Belinda’s ex, as I noted at the beginning, is basically Elon Musk. To do a story critiquing the techno-fascist dystopian country that America is rapidly descending into, with money from a company that has spent seemingly every day since January 20th kowtowing to Trump and the fascist movement controlling him, is to stand up and say what this program’s values are.

Earth, in 2025, is a planet of the incels. America is being ruled over by people who are profoundly anti-woman, the kind of people who watched The Handmaid’s Tale and went, “This is what we want to do the next time we’re in power.” And sure enough, that’s exactly what they’ve been doing, cliche as it feels to say so.

Just the day before this episode aired, the US House of Representatives passed the SAVE Act, a bill that is pretty explicitly designed around taking the right to vote away from women, poor people, minorities, and others, while preserving it for white men. (And given the fascist leanings of the government right now, I’m sure they mean only for conservative white men.)

And RTD, as he has done since he returned, has stood up and loudly said “No.” The Robot Revolution is a story about a woman of color saving the day, and becoming the second half of the show’s first ever non-white TARDIS team, at a time when such moves would be regarded as “DEI”, the right’s new favorite buzzword to describe anything that doesn’t cater to them specifically.

This is a call to action. Davies, through this story, is demanding that we stand up and not just resist fascism, but work to destroy it. As Simon Le Bon writes in the Duran Duran song “Point of No Return,” ‘We’re the ones/Who can feed the ground/So this poison tree, don’t grow again.’

And there’s every sign that Americans are listening. Organized resistance to Trump and Musk has been happening all year, most notably in the form of TeslaTakedown protests that have been going on at Tesla dealerships. While there are rumors that Trump will try and invoke the Insurrection Act on the 20th of April and fully launch us into a remake of Nazi Germany, I don’t think it will work.

This is the United States of America. This country began because we deposed one mad king, we can and we will do it again. They can try to shut us down, they can try to imprison us for our speech and our associations. They can try to chain us all irrevocably.

But it won’t work. Because we are stronger than they are. We can win, and we must.

And RTD has shown us how.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑