Claim Yourself: “The Real Boo Radley”/”A Fork in the Road”

Hi again, Casters! Sorry I’ve been gone a while, I kind of lost my groove what with… well, pretty much everything to do in world affairs. But I’m getting back to it now, so let’s talk magic, shall we? 

This week, we reach a pivotal moment in the story of Ethan and Lena, and it’s something I’ve been looking forward to writing about for a long time. We get to see the moment where Lena formally comes out as a Caster to Ethan, but as we’ll explore when we get to it, he’s not really terribly surprised.

For now, we focus on “The Real Boo Radley,” where Ethan does the unthinkable and visits Ravenwood Manor a second time… and has his first encounter with Macon, Lena’s uncle. 

We don’t start there though. We actually begin with Ethan having a bit of an insomnia episode, during which he and Lena start Kelting, (the term used to refer to telepathic communication between two Casters) establishing the mental connection between them that lasts for the rest of the series.

After that, Ethan goes to school the next morning, though not before being warned away from Lena by Amma (again). I don’t think Amma’s concerns regarding her arise out of any personal animosity – when they do meet later in the book, they get along perfectly well. It’s more about what Lena represents, in the magical sense. Because she hasn’t been Claimed yet, she’s an unknown quantity, and Amma is just afraid Ethan will get hurt if he gets too close.

Thing is though, our Ethan (like most protagonists in YA lit) is too stubborn to let Amma, or even Lena herself, stop him from trying to find out more about what Lena’s secret is. After all, if he wasn’t, we wouldn’t have a book!

Ethan’s monologue during the scene where he and Link drive to school contains one of my favorite lines in the whole series: “When we were in the eighth grade, Mrs. Lincoln ripped the cable box out of the wall because she found Link watching a Harry Potter movie, a series she had campaigned to ban from the Gatlin County Library because she thought it promoted witchcraft.” 

Nothing aggressively dates this series quite like Mrs. Lincoln being against Harry Potter because of the wall witchcraft thing. That made sense in 2009 because the movies were still out and the release of Deathly Hallows was still a fairly recent event, but in the 2020s, I think it’s a pretty safe bet that Mrs. Lincoln would actually be pro-Potter, on account of how deeply conservative a writer Rowling was and is. (And also TERFery. That too.)

Anyway, Ethan’s in a bit of a mood, and it only gets worse as Link updates him on recent goings-on. The Gatlin phone tree is in overdrive thanks to what happened with the window in the last chapter, and the stage is being set for Lena to be put through absolute hell for the remainder of the book.

At the center of it all is Mrs. Lincoln, Link’s mother, and one of the foulest individuals this side of Beverly Keane in Midnight Mass. If you’ve seen that show, then you know who Mrs. Lincoln is: devout Christian, deeply right-wing, and carrying a visceral hatred of anyone different… such as, for example, the niece of Gatlin’s resident recluse. Small wonder Lena drives home rather than put up with Jackson’s bullshit for the day. I would too.

The main action in the chapter comes that night, when Ethan (after telling Amma that he’s going to the library to work on a history project) finally goes to Ravenwood, and gets wrapped up into having dinner with Lena and Macon. His intent is to find out more about the locket, but he ends up getting way more than he bargained for… including our first hints at a connection between Macon and Lila (Ethan’s mother) that will go on to become a key part of Beautiful Darkness.

But first, dinner with Macon. I just love the way he’s introduced: 

“I couldn’t believe I was standing in front of him. The mysterious Macon Ravenwood. Only, I really had been expecting Boo Radley—some guy trudging around the house in overalls, mumbling in some kind of monosyllabic language like a Neanderthal, maybe even drooling a bit around the edges of his mouth.” 

“This was no Boo Radley. This was more of an Atticus Finch.” 

“Macon Ravenwood was dressed impeccably, as if it was, I don’t know, 1942. His crisp white dress shirt was fastened with old-fashioned silver studs, instead of buttons. His black dinner jacket was spotless, perfectly creased. His eyes were dark and gleaming; they looked almost black. They were clouded over, tinted, like the glass of the hearse windows Lena drove around town. There was no seeing into those eyes, no reflection. They stood out from his pale face, which was as white as snow, white as marble, white as, well, you’d expect from the town shut-in. His hair was salt and pepper, gray near his face, as black as Lena’s on the top.”

Atticus Finch, it turns out, is exactly the right descriptor for Macon. He’s as Southern as my fiancee is, and classy as all get out, not to mention hospitable, what with his immediate invitation to invite Ethan in for dinner, over Ethan’s and Lena’s respective objections. It’s also abundantly clear that he deeply loves his niece, and their rapport is an absolute joy to behold. 

I’ve always had a fondness for manor houses like Ravenwood. There’s just something about them that appeals to me, perhaps because I’ve never lived in one myself, and likely never will. Ravenwood is one of my favorite such places, right next to Halliwell Manor from Charmed. The eBook version of Beautiful Creatures even has an illustration of Ravenwood’s front room, and it’s considerably more grand than what he saw in “Greenbrier.”

Ethan, correctly, pretty quickly realizes that something is up with the house – he just doesn’t realize it’s magical. Lena’s attempts at denying it really don’t help. She tries, not very successfully, to either deflect Ethan’s questions or to make Macon’s own hints come off as being more normal than they actually are. 

And then, as Ethan goes to explore, we learn (as noted before) that Macon and Lila knew each other. Ethan is pretty understandably freaked out by this, but before he has time to process, they all go off to eat dinner. Everything seems to be going well… and then Ethan brings out the locket.

Immediately, it all changes. Candles go out, and Macon becomes visibly angry. As Ethan blurts out pretty much everything he and Lena know so far, Macon practically explodes, and the sheer contrast between that and the warm, polite gentleman he was at the beginning of the chapter is still haunting.

And then he says this: “Five months. Do you know what lengths I will go to, to keep her safe for five months? What it will cost me? How it will drain me, perhaps, destroy me?”

There’s way more going on here than Ethan knows, and while he’s starting to suspect something’s up, he doesn’t yet have the full picture.

That changes at the start of “A Fork in the Road,” the very next chapter. After an argument with Lena regarding all the bizarre, supernatural occurrences he’s witnessed, and Lena’s constant evasiveness regarding the same, he asks her to tell him what exactly makes her so different from anyone else he’s ever known… and she says no, because all she wants to be normal, at least for a little while.

And then, later comes the big moment. Lena arrives at Ethan’s house in her pajamas, and he goes down to meet her, sitting on the steps of his porch. And we get one of my favorite scenes in the entire series, and a very relatable one to anybody else who’s read these books and happens to be queer. Coming out can be, and often is, a terrifying experience – I’ve had to do it twice, nine years apart, and it really doesn’t get easier.

So, when I first read this section of the book, my heart went out to Lena. I wanted to hug her, because I know exactly how she’s feeling:

“I don’t really know how to do this. I’ve never had to say it before, so I don’t know how it will all come out.” 

I rubbed my messy hair with one hand. “Whatever it is, you can tell me. I know what it’s like to have a crazy family.” 

“You think you know crazy. You have no idea.” She took a deep breath. Whatever she was about to say, it was hard for her. I could see her struggling to find the words. “The people in my family, and me, we have powers. We can do things that regular people can’t do. We’re born that way, we can’t help it. We are what we are.” 

It took me a second to understand what she was talking about, or at least what I thought she was talking about. 

Magic. 

I was afraid to ask, but I had to know. “And what, exactly, are you?” It sounded so crazy that I almost couldn’t say the words. 

“Casters,” she said quietly. 

It’s cliche to say that queer people are brave for being what we are. In an ideal world, we wouldn’t have to come out at all, we could just be trans or gay or what have you and everyone would be fine with it. But we don’t live in that world. We live in a world where to be trans, in about half of the United States, is to be a third class citizen, and they’re certainly trying to make it that way at the national level too.

And the thing is, I’m not the only person who’s realized this dynamic. As Kami Garcia says in the movie companion book, “There’s a different sensibility in a small town. We changed a persecution of race to a persecution of difference. In our universe it began with outsiders, then moves on to Casters. Whether it’s racial or religious or sexual orientation, there are people being pushed to the fringes because they don’t fit into the mainstream.”

While being a Caster isn’t a perfect analogue for queerness, it’s definitely in the same territory. It wasn’t hard for me to see a lot of myself in Lena back then, and I will go to the Summerlands saying that this scene, in particular, was the moment I fell in love with her. 

And admittedly, I wanted to be her. She’s smart, she’s funny, she’s quirky, she’s a writer, she’s an introvert, and she’s not afraid to speak her mind. And like me early in my transition, it takes her a while to grow into herself, and she has to do a lot of internal exploration to get there. But once she does, she’s unstoppable. And so, I became her. I named myself for her, and as a Wiccan, that means I’m a Caster now too. I even named my Book of Shadows A Caster’s Chronicle, in her honor.

The rest of the chapter is pretty quiet, just Ethan and Lena talking as Ethan reassures her that despite her fears, their families aren’t that different. It’s a very sweet moment, though Ethan does admit toward the end, at least to himself (and thus to us) that Lena being a Caster is more of a bigger deal than he lets on.

But I get why he said it wasn’t. He can see the pain Lena is in, and he wants to be there for her. To let his own confusion show risks losing her forever, and he can’t have that. But now that the veil of secrecy has been lifted, they can grow closer together, as friends and as partners.

And it all starts in the next chapter, when they go on a date.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑