In what has to be the most obscure song title I have ever chosen for this series, “Can You Take Me Back” is the title of the song fragment sung by Paul McCartney at the very end of what is otherwise a John song, “Cry Baby Cry,” from 1968’s the White Album. It’s not much of a song, but its title certainly feels decidedly apropos for the current moment, both within Doctor Who and outside it.
Since the beginning of the Trump era, an epoch of time that really starts when he announced his 2016 presidential campaign and is on-going, we have been living in a veritable flood of nostalgia. Various TV shows from the 1990s have gotten reboots or continuations of varying lengths – Roseanne, Full House, Mystery Science Theater 3000, Animaniacs, Charmed, Will and Grace… all of those have been brought back to life, and the trend became so prevalent, so quickly, that Animaniacs satirized it in its own series premiere.
And it’s only gotten worse since then. After Joe Biden conspicuously failed to stop the growing fascist threat when he had the opportunity and the means, voters rejected Kamala Harris in last November’s election and instead made Donald Trump the first president since Grover Cleveland to serve two nonconsecutive terms, green-lighting America’s TV president a reboot of his very own.
And as with most reboots, the second take is worse than the first.
Just in the three months since he was inaugurated, we’ve seen him burn down most of the federal government’s infrastructure, disappear immigrants, throw foreign college students into the glorified penal colony that is the state of Louisiana, launch an ongoing assault on transgender people, and just last Thursday his Gestapo agents arrested a sitting judge for the “crime” of doing her job.
“Make America Great Again,” he’s told us. As though we were great once, and have since become Not Great. When that exactly was is up to interpretation: Trump himself seems to think that was the McKinley administration, while his cabinet feels a strong hankering for the 1950s, before the Civil Rights Movement, and Elon Musk wants to take us all back to apartheid South Africa… albeit fused with 1940s Germany.
And what is pop culture doing? The nostalgia craze seems to have died down somewhat, as most of the aforementioned reboots have been canceled due to the bottom falling out of the streaming bubble. Even Doctor Who itself, a reboot that just crossed the 20 year mark, may be on the chopping block.
Enter Russell T Davies.
I remember the day he was announced as returning to Doctor Who, and retaking his former position as showrunner. I was thrilled: after 5 years of Chibnallian maladministration, here was someone who knew what the job was and how it worked. And to his credit, Doctor Who in the second Davies era seems to be a very smooth operation. Series 14 was a bit of a rough patch, but he seems to have gotten back to himself with series 15, turning in three separate episodes that feel like vintage Davies.
Including this one, which actually is vintage Davies.
Because, dear reader, what we get this week is a Midnight sequel… albeit one that owes a great deal to Steven Moffat, filtered through RTD’s own desires to engage, even obliquely, with the world in which the show is being made. This is an episode that takes the audience’s assumed nostalgia for the Tennant years and turns it against them.
Sure, it’s the same creature as from Midnight and again the presumed figure of suspicion is a blonde woman, but where Sky’s lesbianism was a quick line of dialogue that flew past so quickly you wouldn’t notice it, Aliss’s deafness is part of the plot. “Don’t turn your back!” says a member of a minority group, on a streaming service owned by a company that has done nothing else but turn its collective back away from trans people and toward Trump… who will continue to extort them because this is a guy who thinks in terms of mafia movies.
I think by now, we can safely say that RTD is anti-nostalgia. Or at least, anti-doing the same show but everyone’s older and grayer because 20 years have gone by. Sure, he brought back Ten and Donna, (sort of and literally respectively) but the 60th anniversary triptych was very much a soft reboot of the reboot, with The Giggle functioning as the true series finale of the BBC Wales era Davies himself established.
This brings him at least ideologically closer to Michael Chabon of Star Trek: Picard. Say what you will about that show, but I honestly appreciated how both seasons of that series brought back old friends and enemies and attempted to go somewhere new with them, whether it’s allowing us to meet Data’s surrogate daughter(s) in season 1, or wrapping up the Picard/Q story by having the latter essentially say “I love you” to the former, just as TNG fans on Tumblr have been insisting for a long time.
Then we got the one-season show that was technically called Star Trek: Picard, but may as well have been called Star Trek: The Previous Generation for all the shits Terry Matalas gave about Agnes Jurati’s Borg Cooperative, the relationship between Seven and Raffi, and everything else set up in Picard that he then decided to ignore.
You know what? I’ll just come out and say it. Picard S3 was the Star Trek equivalent of Rise of Skywalker, but with the added ignominy of various Reddit keyboard warriors loudly demanding STAR TREK LEGACY so they can have more fun playing with 30 year old toys instead of boldly going anywhere that isn’t where everyone has gone before.
All of which is to say, I am glad that RTD is at least trying to do with Doctor Who what Star Trek has largely failed at doing. However long his second era lasts, we can at least say that it wasn’t content to spin on its wheels, chasing the illusive rush of nostalgia at the expense of all else.
At the rate he’s going, we might be able to say that series 15 was Doctor Who’s equivalent of the final Beatles song, “Now and Then” – a last gasp of brilliance from a sixty year old cultural institution that was previously believed to be old news.
And speaking of old news, Ruby Sunday next week. (Ruby Tuesday’s on the phone to me…)
Leave a Reply