Across the Universe: A Hard Day’s Night (The Interstellar Song Contest)

Scraping the bottom of the barrel, but some context: In 1977’s Eurovision, the Swedes performed a song called “Beatles” that paid tribute to… well, you can probably guess, and “A Hard Day’s Night” was one of two songs mentioned in the lyrics. (The other was “Yesterday.”) So, it’s a thin connection, but it’s all I’ve got.

Anyway, this is a strange episode for me to write about. For one thing, I’m not British, so 90% of the Eurovision stuff completely flew over my head – I only recognized Graham Norton because he’s kind of infamous in Who circles for interrupting the program on two separate occasions, both times by accident – once during Rose, and then again in The Time of Angels. Now we have this.

For another thing, this is transparently Doctor Who doing what it did a lot during the first Davies era, commentating on current events via the show itself – Aliens of London/WW3 was transparently a story about the War on Terror, the Bush administration’s invasion of Iraq, and Tony Blair’s involvement in the same.

What this episode calls back to (and my BFF Frezno and I have both touched on this) is 2015’s The Zygon Invasion/Inversion, another Doctor Who story that felt like it was commenting on the Current Political Moment – in this case, ISIS-style terrorism, immigration, the rights of minority groups, and right-wing politics.

As I noted in that episode’s post in The Midnight Hour, that episode has aged extremely weirdly. It was already weird in 2015 itself – that was the year ISIS was in the news seemingly every week beheading journalists, and in the political arena, though Donald Trump hadn’t yet become the nominee or even president, a lot of the things he was saying presaged what he would do as the fascist-in-chief, both in his first term and his second.

ISC is another episode that has aged weirdly, and in this case it’s even worse. As Darren Mooney notes: “The Interstellar Song Contest exists in a very different context than was originally conceived. According to Davies, four scripts for this season had been completed by June 2023. By 16th October 2023, Davies confirmed that “a lot“ of the season had been written. In other words, if The Interstellar Song Contest was not finished by the time that Israel launched its invasion of Gaza on 27th October 2023, it was certainly close to completion.”

And literally the night before this episode aired, Israel qualified for the final, to be broadcast on the night of the episode. Ncuti Gatwa was supposed to read the results of the British jury (adding a layer of meta-ness to the whole thing) but dropped out. A reason was never given, but there are some corners of fandom who believe it may have something to do with the ongoing Gazan genocide by Israel.

Which, you know, lends the anti-Hellion racism that runs through the episode some uncomfortable subtext. Mooney believes there’s a reading to Cora’s plot where she’s meant to be a stand-in for Palestinians and how they’ve been demonized by seemingly THE ENTIRE FUCKING WESTERN WORLD, and I can see how he gets there, but it doesn’t work because then that would imply, going by the actions of Kid and Wynn, that some Palestinians are terrorists.

Like, Darren, this isn’t “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield.” There isn’t actually any real-world equivalences you can point to here. It’s like trying to read Bonnie T Zygon’s terrorist splinter faction as an ISIS stand-in even though there’s really nothing in the text of the episode that can be read as a metaphor for their particular demands as a group or their brand of fundamentalism. 

If ISC is gesturing toward anything, it’s corporate-driven environmental destruction for the sake of profit. The never-named Corporation ransacking the planet Hellia for honey flavoring is a sci-fi version of Nestle taking water from aquifers in Michigan and California so they can sell it back to us in bottle form. And as someone who is a part of a religion based, in part, on the worship of nature, I am deeply angry about the ongoing pillaging of OUR ONLY PLANET by short-sighted corporate fat cats.

But while we’re at it, let’s dig into the anti-Hellion angle a bit. I don’t think it’s wise to read this as a metaphor for discrimination faced by a specific minority group, but it does work as an invocation of discrimination toward minority groups in general – something Juno Dawson would know a lot about, since she’s the first transgender woman to write for Doctor Who on television, having previously penned The Good Doctor (my favorite Thirteen story) and some Big Finish Torchwood.

Cora is Black, and someone in the audience during her performance (according to my subtitles) is heard to yell “GO BACK TO WHERE YOU CAME FROM,” the favorite line of every racist white Trump voter who so much as breathes in the same space as a person of African descent. Trump’s busy deporting all the brown people he can get his tiny little hands on, meanwhile white South Africans have the fucking red carpet rolled out for them.

And then there’s Wynn, the Hellion who gets shouted at by the director: “I took a chance on you. No-one employs Hellions, but I did,” she says, which sounds a lot like what they’ll say about trans people once the Supreme Court decides we don’t have nondiscrimination protections in employment… or anywhere else.

Literally, this was the headline about an hour before I watched the episode: “Far Right Federal Judge Rules Gay And Trans People Can Be Discriminated Against In Workplaces.” This, in an atmosphere where Trump’s trans military ban has been allowed to go into effect by the Supreme Court, which is also expected to rule on our right, or lack thereof, to gender-affirming care in the Skrmetti case, and it sure looks like they’re going to vote against us.

Because that’s the world we live in. This is a world where an evil racist Nazi who looks like a blonde Oompa Loompa can get elected president twice. Where my fiancee can get told by Extremely Online Muslims that she’s haram for acting on the “sin” of being trans, let alone marrying a transgender Wiccan girl. Where some old transphobic bitch like Zuzannah Budapest can go to PantheaCon and hold a ritual for “genetic women only” twice – once in 2011, and then again in 2012.

Doctor Who, at least, gestures toward a world where we can move past this sort of hate. Cora’s song is met with applause from the audience, (eventually) which does show that a pro-Hellion movement remains possible. It’s a much-needed moment of optimism in an episode that is otherwise very bleak, what with the whole “Die Hard at Eurovision” angle and the Doctor straight up torturing Kid, as if to remind us that he is still not a good man, and today is not a day to find out why he has so many rules.

And then, before we really have a chance to take all that in, suddenly we’re being thrown into the season finale: the Doctor and Belinda learn that Earth is destroyed on May 24th, 2025, the TARDIS doors get blown into the console room thanks to an explosion, and then we find out that Mrs. Flood is actually a regenerated version of the Rani from the Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy years.

And then she bigenerates, and her new incarnation is essentially the RTD equivalent of Missy, minus the gender change. Some people might ask whether we’re scraping the bottom of the barrel in terms of returning villains in this new era, what with bringing in Neil Patrick Harris to play the Toymaker (who goes at it like John Simm’s Master in The Sound of Drums) but I don’t think so.

Why? The Master is pretty much played out thanks to Chibnall wasting Sacha Dhawan, and Big Finish has basically laid claim to the Meddling Monk, so the Rani is pretty much all we’ve got left. If nothing else, Archie Panjabi’s performance is immediately compelling in exactly the same way Michelle Gomez’s was eleven years ago.

On to Wish World it is, then.

PS: Stay tuned to the Doctor Who Reviews channel on YouTube. Why? Four words:

The witch is back.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑