Hello, old friend. And here we are, you and me, on the last page.
They said you don’t like endings… but it was you who taught me that everything has to end sometime. Otherwise, nothing would ever get started.
So… let’s talk about this particular ending, shall we?
In the end, the bullshit about the Rani and Omega doesn’t matter.
That’s the hilarious thing about this particular finale – it’s RTD subverting his own expectation! For the last 20 years, in all eight of his finales, (including End of Time and The Giggle) the returning villain from the show’s past is framed as The Big Deal, the being the Doctor must stop if he is to save the universe. That was how it was with the Daleks, the Cybermen, the Master, Davros, Rassilon, and the Toymaker.
But this time? The two Ranis are just neatly tossed away at the half-hour mark, complete with the Obligatory Joke that’s so obvious, even I saw it coming, and my only exposure to The Two Ronnies was that Sarah Jane Adventures minisode where one of them showed up to play a Slitheen. One gets the sense that Davies invented bigeneration entirely so he could pay it off with that joke later on!
But honestly, it’s a relief. After so many seasons with the same basic plot element, it’s nice to finally subvert the whole thing and turn the entire second half of the episode into, essentially, a final farewell for the Fifteenth Doctor. That wasn’t the original plan, I think – the German Disney+ leaked a pic of what appears to be 15 dancing with Rose Noble in a nightclub, and such a scene never happens in the episode… which leaves you with the impression that Gatwa’s exit was abrupt, like Eccleston’s before him.
Honestly, it’s kind of a shame to see him go so soon. See, when I wrote the Twice Upon A Time post last November, I said that I’d keep blogging about Doctor Who until Gatwa regenerated. And at the time, I assumed that we’d be looking at the usual three seasons, with a regeneration at Christmas 2027. Three seasons has been the norm since Tennant’s first incumbency, and a Christmas regeneration has been going on since Smith – note that I’m defining that as being when the actual change occurs.
So why is this happening at all? Rumblings I’ve heard from spoiler threads indicate that this is largely happening because Gatwa got sick and tired of waiting around for a season 3 pickup order from Disney, and was desperate to go and look for other work. Add in implied difficult relationships with the producers, and suddenly it all begins to crystallize. The Gatwa era is over, just when it seemed to be finding its feet.
The ending of a Doctor’s era is always hard to come to terms with – Goddess knows I spent most of 2013 mourning Eleven when his incumbency came to an end with Day and Time. Twelve’s departure, too, was hard to go through. And I know the 13 era has its fans, so they probably went through the same sense of melancholy I did 9 years earlier.
And speaking of 13, what a genuine delight it was to see Jodie Whittaker make an unexpected return to the series. I’d always hoped that, when RTD’s return was announced, that she’d stick around for season 14, just so we could see what she’s like with decent dialogue… and now I got my wish, after a fashion.
It may have only been a few minutes long, but in those few minutes, RTD manages to A) prove beyond a doubt that Whittaker was the right woman for the part in 2018, and B) blow Chibnall’s entire era completely out of the water. I particularly liked that she told 15 which controls to manipulate – she finally got the hang of those new systems after all! And with her first Big Finish audios coming out soon, it seems to be a great year for those of us who want more of 13 without Chibnallian dross. About damned time, too.
But I digress. I’ll admit I’ve known who the 16th Doctor was for about two or three weeks now, so I wasn’t surprised to see Billie Piper’s face appear at the end. How it got there was more important, anyway. But even with this foreknowledge, I found I wasn’t really all that bothered about it, which surprised me. I’ve really liked 15’s era, so why am I so ambivalent about it ending?
Some of it might just be that my era of the show, the Moffat era, ended 8 years ago and nothing the show has done since has quite stayed with me in the same way. But I don’t think that’s entirely it.
We have to consider what the TV landscape looked like in the mid-2000s, when the show first returned 20 years ago. Broadcast TV was the only game in town, the infrastructure for streaming television simply didn’t exist yet. Seasons of a show ran for much longer than they do now – this was the era of 22 episode seasons for a 45 minute American drama series, when you really had time to get to know the characters and fall in love with them.
But all that has changed. Ever since Netflix shook things up in the early 2010s by pivoting to streaming TV, we’re getting shorter seasons every year, and how many seasons we get is up to the capricious whims of streaming executives, rather than by ratings.
And then there’s the fact that those seasons are taking longer and longer to be released than ever before, for increasingly diminishing returns. What’s the point in watching if you can’t predict that it’ll be renewed, and if it is, you’ll only get less than 10 episodes for your trouble?
So that’s half the reason I’m largely not bothered with the departure of 15: I still feel like I barely know him. At only eighteen episodes, this is about the equivalent of killing off 11 in The Doctor’s Wife, of all stories. Gatwa’s era is the third-shortest of the entire modern series – only Eccleston in 2005, and Tennant in 2023, are shorter.
And yet… that doesn’t feel like the entire answer. Because even in those thirteen episodes, the Ninth Doctor still develops and changes. When he meets Rose Tyler in her eponymous debut story, he’s isolated and lonely, brushing it off with Northern snark and a blunt demeanor. But by The Parting of the Ways, he’s been healed of all the weight he was carrying, and he goes into his next life unencumbered. 15 doesn’t have anything like that… and now, never will.
Which, I admit, does sadden me a little. It’s harder than ever for a show like Doctor Who to flourish in today’s media landscape, where everything has to be a gargantuan hit just for an outside chance at a renewal, and you have to have deep pockets just to get the damn thing filmed. In an ideal world, we’d still be cranking out 13 episode seasons every year, and Gatwa would be coming to the last third of his second season, rather than the final episode.
But then again, I don’t think you could revive Doctor Who in this day and age. The circumstances that allowed it to come back in 2005, and grow into the massive, world-spanning hit it became, were a product of that era and that culture. In the ephemera of 2020s television? Forget about it. The Doctor’s on borrowed time, and from here on, any episode we get is a miracle in itself.
But maybe that’s the lesson we take from all this: treasure what you have, when you get it. Tomorrow is promised to no one, after all.
What I can say for certain is that this post marks the end of my career as a Doctor Who critic. Excepting some essays on EU material from Eleven’s era, my days writing about this show really are over now, in terms of blogging. I wish Billie Piper well, and I’m looking forward to watching her era when it comes out, however long it lasts…
But not writing about it. That ship, my friends, has sailed away. Let it be, indeed.
So… final thoughts then, on this show that’s changed my life in ways I could never have imagined fifteen years ago?
That’s… surprisingly difficult to land on. When I started back in 2010 with series 5, I was fifteen years old, in the middle of my teen years. I didn’t know who I was yet. ‘Still cooking,’ as the saying goes. Certainly I couldn’t have imagined realizing my transness, finding the love of my life, launching a career as a professional writer, and even becoming Wiccan. That would’ve been a bit much for teenage Lena… but I love the woman I’ve become.
I mean, it’s all right there in my Doctor’s dying words: “We all change, when you think about it. We’re all different people all through our lives. And that’s okay, that’s good, you’ve got to keep moving, so long as you remember all the people that you used to be.”
Those words comforted me when I most needed to hear them, and they comfort me now, all these years later. So I guess what I’m trying to say is… I wouldn’t be who I am today if I hadn’t watched The Eleventh Hour in a 480p 10-part YouTube rip fifteen years ago. Small moments have the power to change entire lives, after all.
So, there we go. Thanks for everything, Doctor. I’m laying down my pen, but I’m glad your adventures are still going.
And you know what else? It’s been an absolute joy.
Leave a Reply