Hi again, Casters! This week we are just past the halfway mark for Beautiful Creatures, as Ethan and Lena begin their quest to find the missing Book of Moons, while juggling all the other stuff going on in their lives – mainly, Jackson High’s continued intolerance toward Lena, and whatever the fuck is going on with Mrs. Lincoln.
Let’s jump right in, shall we?
The chapter begins with Ethan, Link, and Lena heading off to school together, while Ethan’s narration informs us that something is certainly brewing with not only Mrs. Lincoln, but also Mrs. Snow and the rest of the Gatlin DAR. “We’ll get her outta our school, one way or another,” Mrs. L is quoted as saying.
As we discussed all the way back in February’s post on “Collision”/“Broken Glass,” Gatlin really is uncomfortably reminiscent of small-town America. This is a town where all the TVs everywhere blare Fox News 24/7, and at the time these books were written, chances are most of the population would’ve seen President Obama as a Kenyan Marxist Muslim dude. South Carolina’s electoral votes have gone to the GOP in every presidential election since 1980, so Gatlin being a Republican stronghold makes perfect sense.
I’ve lived in towns like Gatlin before. My old hometown of Wentzville is a small city in Missouri, part of the decidedly deep-red St. Charles County. I remember seeing McCain-Palin signs in the neighborhood during the ’08 election, while my parents had an Obama-Biden sign in our yard. Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan won a mock election at my high school in 2012, and of course, when Trump was elected the first time, there were Trump-Pence signs everywhere I looked.
Needless to say, I know what it is to be an outsider like Lena, or like Lila. As Ethan tells us: “The way she told it, she was such a criminal even the most God-fearing church ladies got bored of reporting on her; she did the marketing on Sunday, dropped by any church she liked or none at all, was a feminist (which Mrs. Asher sometimes confused with communist), a Democrat (which Mrs. Lincoln pointed out practically had
“demon” in the word itself), and worst of all, a vegetarian (which ruled out any dinner invitations from Mrs. Snow). Beyond that, beyond not being a member of the right church or the DAR or the National Rifle Association, was the fact that my mom was an outsider.”
And it’s only gotten worse in the 16 years that have passed since 2009, when this book was published. Over the last weekend of May, Sen. Joni Ernst was at a town hall. As she answered a question, someone broke into the room and shouted “PEOPLE WILL DIE!” in regard to the recent malevolent MAGA murder budget passed by the House a few weeks ago.
Ernst’s response? “Well, we’re all going to die,” which was callous enough on its own. In a sarcastic “apology” video that made the rounds on Bluesky a few days later, she said, “I made an incorrect assumption that everyone in the auditorium understood that yes, we are all going to perish from this Earth. So I apologize. […] But for those that would like to see eternal and everlasting life, I encourage you to embrace my lord and savior, Jesus Christ.”
Truly, Joni Ernst is who Mrs. Lincoln would be if she’d decided to go into national politics, down to the evangelical Christianity. She’s cold, cruel, heartless, condescending, and so many other things that her lord and savior would despise – and I say this as someone who was raised Catholic. No doubt, she’d look at me, a fiercely devout Wiccan, and accuse me of being a Satanist instead.
(For the record, no I’m not. Wiccans do not believe in such a concept as absolute evil. That’s a wholly separate faith tradition, not that I’d expect either Mrs. Lincoln or Joni Ernst to care about such nuances.)
The really scary thing about Mrs. Lincoln, though, is that people like her hold all the levers of power right now in the federal government. From JD Vance to Paula White and Mike Johnson, right-wing Christianity is effectively the official religion of the United States government, and may one day become the state religion as well, free exercise clause be damned.
All of this is a very long way of saying that as much as it would’ve sucked to live in Gatlin during the Obama years, to do so under Trump would probably be a horror show of epic proportions.
And speaking of horror shows, our heroes arrive at Jackson to find that some sort of protest is going on against “violence,” a not-too-subtle dig to the window-shattering incident in English that we talked about in February. Lena aptly describes it as a witch hunt… which gives the phrase a whole new meaning considering that she is, after all, a witch.
And then it gets, if possible, even worse. Ethan is invited to join this new club that’s being formed, (the Jackson High Guardian Angels) and then Mrs. Lincoln says, “What would your poor mamma say, Ethan Wate? What would she think about the company you’re keepin’? […] I’ll tell you what your mamma would say. She would cry. She would be turnin’ over in her grave.”
Ethan, naturally, is not about to let that kind of insult pass without firing back a shot of his own. As he tells us, “Mrs. Lincoln didn’t know anything about my mother. She didn’t know my mom was the one who had sent the School Superintendent a copy of every ruling against book banning in the U.S. She didn’t know my mom cringed every time Mrs. Lincoln invited her to a Women’s Auxiliary or DAR meeting. Not because my mom hated the Women’s Auxiliary or the DAR, but because she hated what Mrs. Lincoln stood for. That small-minded brand of superiority women in Gatlin, like Mrs. Lincoln and Mrs. Asher, were so famous for.”
His verbal response is perfect: “‘Good for you, Ethan.’ That’s what my poor mamma would’ve said.”
The next chapter is a short one – Ethan goes to visit his aunts and finds them raising wild baby squirrels. Over his objections, he’s told to go out and bury nuts in the backyard, so the squirrels can practice looking for them. Doing this, and discovering that one of the other townsfolk was buried with her recipe book, gets him to realize where the Book of Moons might be: With Genevieve, in her grave.
In the same chapter, we also learn that Gatlin was founded because of the Ravenwoods. The first generation of Ravenwoods came to the town that would become Gatlin in 1781, the last year of the Revolutionary War. According to Ethan’s Aunt Prue, “They were farmers, and it turned out Gatlin County had the most fertile soil in all a South Carolina. Cotton, tobacco, rice, indigo-it all grew here, which was peculiar on account a those crops don’t usually grow in the same place. Once folks figured out you could grow just ’bout anything here, the Ravenwoods had themselves a town.”
Which makes the fact that the townsfolk, like Mrs. Lincoln and her ilk, are so damned hateful toward the Ravenwood-Duchannes family all the more ironic, as Ethan himself notes in the next paragraph. He adds, “I wondered how Mrs. Lincoln would feel about that. I bet she already knew, and it had something to do with why they all hated Macon Ravenwood so much.”
What it all comes down to, I think, is that same small-minded superiority we saw at the end of the previous chapter. We’re seeing more and more of that kind of thing these days, like when right wing Christians go to the Supreme Court and demand a license to discriminate against LGBT Americans because baking a cake for a couple of lesbians is against the bakers’ “sincerely held religious beliefs.”
(And of course, only Christians would get to make that excuse – I don’t imagine they’d ever let a Wiccan do it.)
Ethan’s response to that earlier scene, and Lena’s own when she uses her magic to blow all the fliers away and out into the wind, is wonderful. Standing up for what’s right, even when you know the entire town is against you, takes courage. And it’s the kind of courage we desperately need to see more of, in this dark time of encroaching fascism and Christian theocracy.
May we all be as courageous as Ethan Wate and Lena Duchannes.
Leave a Reply