Welcome, witches, to a very special edition of Wiccan Reads! If you’re reading this on Patreon, then you join me on the one-year anniversary, to the week, that I began my studies in witchcraft. (My Book of Shadows was created on May 16th, 2024, so I consider that to be anniversary day.) If you’re reading this on WordPress, then you join me on the day that I am on a train to Salem, Massachusetts, where I’ll be getting married. (And of course, being a tourist.)
Given the significance of both dates, I can think of no better way to celebrate than by re-reading the book that started it all: Margot Adler’s Drawing Down the Moon, a history of Neopaganism in America. It’s often considered one of the foundational texts for a new witch, and no surprise – as you’d expect from an NPR reporter, Adler covers her subject with all the depth such a project requires, while staying journalistically neutral. While the emphasis is on Wicca, (which makes some sense, as Adler was Wiccan herself) other forms of neopaganism get their moment to shine as well, from Egyptian reconstructionists to the Church of All Worlds.
The book was originally published in 1979, but was re-published three times: once in 1986, 1996, and finally in 2006 – the most recent, and last, revision. (Adler died in 2013, so something tells me there probably won’t be a 2026 version.) While the language is somewhat dated in places (particularly as regards trans people) Adler is, to be certain, no TERF. (Which is more than I can say for one of her interview subjects – Zsuzsanna Budapest.)
But by now, you’re probably going, “That’s all well and good, Lena, but what about you?!”
Well, let me explain. Drawing Down the Moon was the very first book on witchcraft I ever read. I woke up one morning in mid-May, turned to my wife-to-be, and said: “I want to study witchcraft.”
This desire didn’t come from nowhere: I’d spent the preceding two weeks throwing myself back into the Caster Chronicles novels, from which I took my name, and for Some Reason, Lena’s specific status as a Caster hit me more strongly than it ever had before. I wanted to be her, or as close to her as it’s possible to get in the real world. And that meant studying witchcraft.
So, when I told Sophie what I wanted to do, she handed me Drawing Down the Moon and said, “Start with this, and tell me what you think.” So I did… and my life was never the same again.
Now, just to emphasize how significantly this book changed my life, lemme give you a recap of my spiritual journey. I was born into an Irish Catholic family, and so for approximately the first half of my life, (1994 to 2008) I was raised Christian. On some Sundays, we’d go to church, and I remember my dad (who’d been a choir boy in school) singing the hymns with everyone else. In middle school I’d spend my Wednesday nights at PSR, or Parish School of Religion, learning about God and Jesus and reading the Bible.
During the summer, I’d go to Vacation Bible School with my friend Jesse, and hang out with him. I owned a bunch of Alice in Bibleland books, and several different copies of the actual Holy Bible – including a white one that I got for First Communion in 2005. I watched VeggieTales obsessively – around 2007 or ’08, my dad took me to a Slackers store in St. Charles, and I bought a VeggieTales DVD (The Wonderful World of Auto-Tainment) and a copy of the Beatles’ White Album. (Which, tbh, got played more than the DVD ever did.)
And by all accounts, I’d stay Christian, even though I never quite vibed with the faith. It was just What I Did as part of the family… even though our Christmases and Easters rarely, if ever, involved Jesus. (We weren’t that devout.) Still, I’d pray to St. Anthony if I lost something, I had a deep-seated fear of being sent to Hell after dying, and I thought Jesus was a generally cool guy.
And yet, Christianity never fit me. Even though I graduated PSR and could have been confirmed if I’d wanted to be, like Mom had been when she was in her late teens, I simply never was. After PSR finished up I focused on guitar lessons, and then… I just drifted away from the church. No formal crisis of faith, I just quietly made an unannounced departure. (Talk about an Irish goodbye.)
I then spent the entire second half of my life as an atheist, or at the very least agnostic. But this, too, didn’t fit: Sophie has described me as being decidedly uncomfortable in my atheism, as if I was looking for something to believe in, but couldn’t find it yet. None of the organized religions I knew of seemed to fit me, but what was left?
That, dear reader, is where Drawing Down the Moon comes in. At the start of chapter 2, (“A Religion Without Converts”) Adler asks how it is people become Neopagans, and explains: “In most cases, word of mouth, a discussion between friends, a lecture, a
book, an article, or a Web site provides the entry point. […] A common phrase you hear is “I’ve come home,” or, as one woman told me excitedly after a lecture, “I always knew I had a religion, I just never knew it had a name.”
That’s about how it was for me. After reading the first chapter and hearing about what Wicca was, I could feel something stirring in me. I had found home, and said so to Sophie. After half a lifetime searching, I had finally found (to paraphrase the U2 song) what I was looking for. Paganism in general, and Wicca specifically, was the religion I needed.
I blew through Drawing Down the Moon in five days – I started it on May 15th, and finished it on May 20th, 2024. When I wasn’t reading I started building my Book of Shadows, cast my first spell, and generally threw myself into the Craft with an enthusiasm that, looking back, takes me by surprise. Where had all this come from?!
If I had to guess? It was always there, from literally the day I was born: October 17th, two weeks before Samhain. It was there in the fact that “Crows” is my favorite Gothic Archies song, since it’s about a sacred bird of the Morrigan. It was there in the fact that I love and get excited about thunderstorms, because I see them as an expression of not only the power of nature, but as the closest thing there is to the feeling I get whenever I do a particularly intense bit of magic.
I was yearning for this, my entire life. And though it took me 30 years to find it, I know I found it at the right time.
My name is Lena Mactire, and I’m Wiccan. And I always will be.
Thanks for everything, Margot Adler. Blesséd be.
Leave a Reply