Hey Casters, welcome back! This week, Ethan and Lena go grave-robbing in the cemetery at Greenbrier, with Lena’s Aunt Del, who can see through time, and cousin Reese, who is basically a Caster version of a lie detector. (Only more accurate, presumably.) The goal? Uncover the Book of Moons and hopefully stop Lena from going dark… without incurring the suspicion of Del, Reese, Macon, or Amma.
Needless to say, that’s gonna be a bit of a tough job. Let’s see if they can do it, shall we?
We begin with the first part of the deception: A party for Aunt Del’s birthday. But that’s just the pretext: we pick up the action later that same evening, with Ethan and Lena guiding Reese and Del through the graveyard toward Genevieve’s grave. And after a bit more wandering and trying very hard not to arouse Reese’s suspicions, they arrive at the gravesite…
And see an actual, real life ghost.
Just check out Ethan’s description: “She was only partially materialized, a mix of cloudy haze and light, fading in and out as the air moved through her ghostly form, but there was no mistaking it. It was Genevieve, the woman in the painting. She had the same golden eyes and long, wavy red hair. Her hair blew gently in the wind, as if she was just a woman sitting on a bench at the bus stop, instead of an apparition sitting on a headstone in a graveyard. She was beautiful, even in her present state, and terrifying at the same time. The hair on the back of my neck stood on end.”
Spooky, isn’t it? Visualizing it creeped me out when I first read the books, and even now, it’s still eerie to read about.
Anyway. Ethan and Lena go about finding the book… after reluctantly telling Del and Reese what they’re looking for. And I do mean reluctantly, because at one point Reese reads Lena’s face and discovers they’re looking for a book, but not anything more than that. Lena has the idea to let Del tell them if the book is there or not, since she can see real deep into the past, and that idea proves so interesting that even Genevieve can’t help but be curious!
And sure enough, it works. The Book is indeed there, buried with Genevieve, and she wants Ethan and Lena to take it – so they can right a wrong. This is what I like about Genevieve: she may have been a Dark Caster, but she was still a good person… which makes the fact that Lena is echoing her so much all the more interesting. Being Dark doesn’t necessarily make one evil.
All the same, Ethan and Lena dig into the grave and grab the book from its resting place… and Lena uses her magic on Del and Reese, to prevent them from spilling the truth to Macon. She’s been practicing her magic recently, and according to her, “I Shifted the Book out of their minds. I guess you could say I erased it. They won’t remember it, because in their reality, it never happened.”
Which is both awesome and scary all at the same time. And all Ethan sees when she does it is this: “I saw green sparks in her eyes, and the curling motion of her hair as it caught the moonlight, the Casting breeze. It was almost as if I could see the magic churning around her in the darkness.”
One of the things I’ve really come to appreciate about this series, especially now that I’m a witch myself, is that the magic in the series is, by and large, invisible. Sometimes we can see the effects, but not always – the kind of advanced glamour magic that Lena is using here relies on eye contact, concentration, and sheer willpower as much as magical strength.
Once again, I wish we had a version of this book from Lena’s perspective, just so we can get a glimpse into some of the spells she’s been working: “Little things. Teletossing Pebbles. Interior Illusions. Time Binds, but those are hard.” All of that sounds fucking awesome, and I wish I knew how it worked.
But alas, we’re stuck with Ethan, our resident Mortal. He doesn’t seem to like that Lena used her powers on her own family like this, and I understand why – it’s a bit more amoral than we’re used to seeing from her. It’s one thing if she’s casting a harmless jinx on the cheer squad, and another if she’s trying to hide the Book from prying Caster eyes.
But I can see her side of things too. She wants to keep herself from going Dark on her birthday, by any means necessary, and if that means a little memory alteration, then that’s something she can live with. One could argue she’s skirting the edge of the Wiccan Rede by doing this, but I’m reluctant to make that argument, since I don’t think Lena is particularly religious.
Having said that, Aunt Del does let off a couple of mild Caster oaths in this chapter: she twice refers to a Great Mother, and throws in a “For star’s sake” when trying to talk Ethan and Lena out of digging up Genevieve’s grave… which makes me wonder if the Duchannes-Ravenwood family follows some sort of spiritual path after all. Dianic Wicca, maybe? (Minus the transphobia, of course.) I certainly don’t see them setting foot in a church anytime soon.
We move along to our next chapter, which finds Ethan and Lena doing ever more morally grey things… or at least as morally grey as a book series for teenagers can go. For Lena it was using her magic on her aunt and cousin, and for Ethan it’s forging a note and cutting class to read the Book of Moons.
Well, okay, Lena is reading it, since she’s a Caster and can touch magical books. Ethan can’t without hurting himself, but being an idiot, he tries anyway. Multiple times. (Ethan, my boy, you are the dorkiest dork in all of Dorkland.) Lena, meanwhile, busies herself with the actual research, and explains to Ethan how this whole Claiming business is supposed to work:
“For most Casters, it’s a conscious thing, just like it says here. The Person of Power, the Caster, Casts the Eternal Choice. They choose if they want to Claim themselves Light or Dark. That’s what the free will and agency is all about, like Mortals choose to be good or bad, except Casters make the Choice for all time.”
“They choose the life they want to lead, the way they will interact with the magical universe, and one another. It’s a covenant they make with the natural world, the Order of Things.”
I find it interesting how many fictional witchcraft series put a magical spin on the choice of good and evil. Charmed has a system like the one in these books where a witch has 48 hours to choose whether she’ll be good or evil, and no one is allowed to try and tempt her toward one side or the other. And, as with Caster Claimings, the choice is permanent.
In normal circumstances, it’s clear that a Claiming is meant to be an affirmation of the given Caster’s personal sovereignty, but Genevieve’s actions in 1865 violated that same sovereignty for her descendants. She didn’t want Lena to go through what she went through, and so she gave them the Book to try and help them out.
The second half of Lena’s statement, regarding the choice and its broader ramifications, reminds me a little of the various concepts of Wiccan ethics – namely the Rede (‘An it harm none, do what ye will’ and the Threefold Rule, where good deeds are magnified in like form back to the doer, as are bad deeds.
The difference though is that while all Casters must be Claimed, not all Wiccans follow the Rede or the Threefold Rule. It’s just advice, not an iron-clad law like some people seem to think. I follow both of them because I find them to be helpful checkpoints in deciding what to do – the one time I considered hexing someone, I felt so awful about the very idea that I backed away from the whole thing in the end.
Lena then describes what it actually feels like to be Claimed: “You feel this energy, this power moving through your body, almost like you’re coming to life for the first time.” This quote stuck with me for a while, because that’s pretty much what I felt when I initiated myself into Wicca last May. Standing there in a cast circle, with my gods welcoming me home, I found myself filled with new energy, just like what Lena talks about. It was my Claiming, and it was an incredibly powerful experience.
That’s the thing I love about these books, especially now that I’m a real-life Caster girl. I understand Lena’s world more than I ever did, and it makes me appreciate it all the more. I still yearn for the more supernatural abilities she displays, (like for example, enchanting her viola to play itself) but even if I can’t have those, my own powers are still pretty awesome.
Ain’t magic wonderful?
Leave a Reply