What we have this week are a group of episodes that, for me, serve as a reminder that as tight as the main six are in later seasons, they all had to start somewhere. At this point in their lives, they are more like acquaintances than true friends. Rainbow Dash in Griffon the Brush Off, for example, spends that episode’s opening moments trying to avoid Pinkie, it’s not until they discover a shared love of pranking that they start to truly bond.
Griffon is a fascinating case study in what can happen when two groups of friends connect. In some cases the results can be positive, while in others they can be negative, even downright catastrophic. While it’s true that Pinkie Pie may be coming on a little strong (she is, after all, the dictionary definition of an extrovert) that does not excuse Gilda’s behavior toward her or anypony else. She is a classic example of the toxic friend, someone who makes their chosen victim think they’re cool and awesome, but when that person’s back is turned, they reveal themselves to be cruel and hurtful.
Then there’s Gilda. Given what we know about griffon culture (isolated, selfish, and bad-tempered) this is at least somewhat understandable, but again, this doesn’t make what she does (frightening Granny Smith, making Fluttershy cry, smashing Pinkie’s flying machine) even remotely acceptable. Rainbow, at least, can be counted on to stick up for her Ponyville friends when she needs to… sometimes.
I admire Pinkie’s choice to solve this problem by throwing her a party, what I don’t like is Rainbow setting pranks up when she knows Gilda will be there, and tensions are already high. She and Pinkie might appreciate a good laugh, but Gilda’s obvious frustration and discomfort should have been something she picked up on.
Honestly, early series Rainbow just isn’t written very well. Sure, she’s the Element of Loyalty and she has her good moments, but she also has a tendency to be really insensitive. This is especially jarring with Fluttershy, since according to a later episode from this season, the two of them were friends as fillies, and yet here, she only stops herself from pranking Fluttershy because Pinkie, who hasn’t known either of them for anywhere near that long, tells Dash that she’s really sensitive, to say nothing of how she acts in Dragonshy, between hinting to Twilight that Fluttershy should be left behind in Ponyville and implying that Fluttershy caused the rock slide on the mountain. Way to be loyal, Dash.
And then we have Twilight Sparkle, our poor series protagonist. She doesn’t come off very well in Griffon the Brush Off, ascribing Pinkie’s difficulties with Gilda to Pinkie being jealous, and suggests that maybe she’s the one with the attitude problem. Twilight, as much as I love her, is just flat-out wrong here. Pinkie is the least-jealous mare in Ponyville, she’s just concerned for Rainbow. (The good news though is that Twilight eventually realizes her mistake, and apologizes at the end.)
Then there’s Boast Busters, where Twilight spends most of the episode refusing to use her magic in a duel against Trixie because she’s afraid her friends will see her as a braggart. While this is understandable, her fears are unfounded. The ponies state point blank that they’re proud to have her as a friend, and that she should embrace her talents for what they are instead of trying to hide them away.
While Trixie and Gilda are both broadly similar characters, (a dominance-seeker and show-off with a tendency to look down their muzzle, or beak, at the residents of Ponyville) Trixie at least is allowed to have a few moments hinting at her future redemption in season six, especially when she admits to everyone that she just made up the Ursa Minor story to make herself sound more important… (And then she runs off into the night as egotistical as ever. This trait is so baked in to her character that it’s still there as late as episode 20 of season nine.
On the subject of ponies who have difficulty being at the center of attention, I have to admit: I really don’t like how Fluttershy is written in Dragonshy. Yes, the ending where she takes the dragon to task by calling him out for hurting her friends both directly and indirectly makes up for it a little, but good grief, is it really necessary to have her be afraid of her own shadow and to be afraid of falling into a ravine when the gap is only about as wide as she is? And for crying out loud, she’s a pegasus! She may not spend as much time in the sky as Rainbow does, but she still knows how to fly!
Luckily, our favorite meek and mild pegasus goes through a lot of character development over the course of the series, and the episode’s ending does a lot to show that she’s capable of such change, and even in her other focus episodes, she’s never quite as skittish as she is this time.
Another pony who doesn’t come off very well is Rarity, since she seems to be more interested in looking good and fulfilling her own desires rather than contributing to actually stopping the dragon (though Twilight does call her out on this). True, this does establish that she does have a selfish side, but at the cost of also ramping up her vanity. Her plan to get the dragon to leave by buttering him up as if she’s Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit almost works, right until he notices she’s stealing from his hoard, which just pisses him off even more. Nice going, Element of Generosity.
At least in Look Before You Sleep, pointing out Rarity’s considerable flaws makes a certain amount of sense, since she’s being directly contrasted with Applejack. That episode’s conflict arises when the two of them get caught up in a thunderstorm due to an argument over how best to prepare the town’s trees for the high winds. Twilight invites them in for a sleepover, and the underlying tensions make it difficult for anypony to have fun.
If you ask me, I think Applejack was right to point out that Rarity’s focus on the details rather than the big picture is what caught them in the storm in the first place, but likewise, if Applejack had listened to Rarity’s warning about the falling tree, they could’ve avoided causing accidental property damage to Twilight’s house, to say nothing of actual physical injury. (It sure seems like our favorite neurotic purple book nerd is concussed due to the tree falling through her window…)
What keeps it from being a total disaster is, for me, Twilight’s adorkable enthusiasm at having her first ever sleepover and wanting it to go swimmingly, and the undeniable chemistry that Applejack and Rarity have together, even when they’re snarking at each other. (For more, check out the Equestria Girls episode Rollercoaster of Friendship.)
At this point, the series seems to be alternating between poorly-aged episodes and nicely-aged ones, not unlike the infamous Star Trek movie curse where all the odd-numbered ones are terrible and the even-numbered ones are good. Following the pilot, I’m none too fond of Ticket Master, Griffon the Brush Off, and Dragonshy, which are episodes 3, 5, and 7, but quite like Applebuck Season, Boast Busters, and Look Before You Sleep, episodes 2, 4, and 6.
Unluckily, the next pair of episodes seem set to continue this trend, as we’ll discuss in the next entry.
Leave a Reply