One of the really interesting (read: depressing) things about how Equestria Forever has aged since I first began working on it 5 years ago is how little world affairs have changed between 2020 and now. When the first version of this post went up on my Patreon, it was just after that year’s presidential election, which saw Joe Biden defeat Donald Trump, and the results were greeted with celebrations and a sigh of relief.
At the time, everyone thought that Biden’s election meant a turn away from the racist xenophobia of Trump’s first term… but 4 years later, Trump got re-elected, doubling down on his classic routine of division and suspicion of The Other: transgender people, Mexican immigrants, Democrats in general, and Black people, among other groups.
But the thing was, Trump’s elections in 2016 and 2024 didn’t happen in a vacuum. The seeds were there from the very beginning, as exemplified in the first of this week’s pair of FIM episodes, “Bridle Gossip.” This episode originally aired December 10th, 2010, roughly a month after that year’s midterm elections, which saw Republicans take the majority in the House of Representatives after a campaign largely deemed to be referendum on the administration of Barack Obama, the first Black president of the United States. (Who they all hated and demonized at every turn, even before Trump entered the picture.)
Given all the racist fear mongering going on in 2010 and 2025, one would hope, given that Equestria is a utopia, that ponies would be more high-minded than the humans watching their antics on TV. Unfortunately, “Bridle Gossip” proves that not to be the case. We open with shots of Ponyville apparently abandoned, as the townsponies are all hiding in their homes, away from the frightening zebra that has appeared to enact some evil deeds and perform dark magic… or go shopping.
Yeah. Twilight, to her credit, reacts to the fears of her friends with skepticism and sarcasm, pointing out that the others’ fears are entirely baseless. They have nothing to be afraid of, but they’re letting their fears of seeing someone entirely different from them run away with them. The ponies are being racist, whether they mean to or not, stoking fears of the other among themselves, the same kind of fear that led to the aforementioned Republican House majority in 2010, and the elections of Donald Trump in 2016 and 2024.
In case I haven’t made it abundantly clear already, “Bridle Gossip” is a racist episode. I don’t think it’s intentionally racist, not in the way something like The Talons of Weng-Chiang in Doctor Who is, but it’s still racist. This is more of a The Celestial Toymaker situation, where the story is centered around a character who doesn’t represent Europe and is assembled out of a hodgepodge of cultural signifiers that end up creating a generic Chinese person, or in this case, a generic African zebra. (The good news is Zecora’s voice actor, Brenda Crichlow, is Black. Which is more than can be said for casting Michael Gough to play an “Asian” person.)
The other part of the episode’s conflict comes when Twilight and her friends wander through a field of blue flowers, which are called Poison Joke. They are cursed flowers which afflict anyone who wanders through them with some kind of magical malady. Twilight believes there’s no such thing as curses however, deriding them as fake magic because they aren’t something you’re born with, but created artificially.
Which, given the episode’s various other problems, is not exactly a great thing for the lead protagonist of your ensemble series to say. (For crying out loud, I’ve been hearing similar rhetoric from TERFs regarding trans people for years and years.) And that’s before you get into the fact that curses are, in fact, real things that you can do as part of a magical practice. I don’t do those things because I follow the Wiccan Rede and the Three-fold Rule as closely as I can, but the option is out there if you feel you need them.
But I digress. Where Twilight’s characterization falls down for me is when she blames the fact that her horn has blue spots and flops around on Zecora, rather than her own mistakes. And for that matter, so does everyone else. Oh, and Spike mocks everyone’s afflictions by giving them insulting nicknames, just like The Orange Guy. Perhaps the worst of them all, for me anyway, is Fluttershy’s: her voice drops down an octave so she sounds like, and is voiced by, a guy. (Blu Mankuma, who also voiced the dragon in Dragonshy). Great! So now we have racism and transphobia! Just what I need, when I have previously gone on for ages and ages about how wonderful this show is!
The worst of it is, I like Zecora as a character, I really do. Her take on magic is very interesting, given the resonances to real-world witchcraft, and she goes on to have much better episodes as a central character than her introduction ever was. But as the saying goes, you only get one chance to make a first impression, and the (largely white) show staff whiffed this one hard. Making matters worse is that for the entire rest of the series, Zecora is the only zebra we see, it’s not until IDW’s Season 10 comic book run that we see more of her homeland.
In that first issue, Twilight (acting in her role as Princess of Equestria) sends Applejack, Zecora, Tempest Shadow, and Rockhoof to Farasi, (a Swahili word meaning horse) much to Zecora’s shock and anger. She is enraged that Applejack chose their destination without consulting her, and correctly points out that for all Applejack knows, she could be sending them to a place where Zecora isn’t welcome, or would be in danger. In the span of 3 pages, Jeremy Whitley spares more thought for the problematic aspects of Zecora and the show’s treatment of her than anyone else has, and for that, he should be applauded.
But let’s be honest: Zecora’s background shouldn’t have been relegated to the show’s spin-off media. It should’ve been done within the series itself, using the same care and attention to detail afforded to, say, the history of Applejack’s parents. It shouldn’t have traded in stereotypes in the character’s original introduction. It should’ve put more thought into doing more with Zecora than making her out as generic stand-in for Africa, an actual continent, rather than a country. But it didn’t even try.
Luckily, the next episode, “Swarm of the Century,” is much better. This is the one where the ponies discover parasprites, a species of cute and colorful insects that eat stuff in advance of a visit from Princess Celestia. Insects that multiply rapidly, and frequently at that. In other words: the Tribbles from Star Trek. Indeed, what Worf says in the Tribble episode of Deep Space Nine applies equally to parasprites: “They do nothing but consume food and breed. If you feed that thing more than the smallest morsel, in a few hours you’ll have ten tribbles, then a hundred – then a thousand!”
“Swarm of the Century,” therefore, is a hugely important episode of the series even if it doesn’t look like one. It’s the earliest instance we have of the show inserting jokes and references for the amusement of viewers well-beyond that of the target audience, in the tradition of cartoons like Looney Tunes, Animaniacs, and Adventure Time. You can draw a straight line from this to season five’s “Slice of Life,” which focuses on the show’s background characters (including a group of six that we’ll get to in due time) or any of the Daring Do episodes, starting with season two’s “Read It and Weep.”
And that’s before the whole Star Trek invocation. You can’t talk about that series without mentioning that it completely invented the concept of fandom that we all know: an insanely creative group of people, primarily adults, collectively expressing the love of their favorite thing by doing everything from writing songs to cosplay, artwork, and fan fiction. Indeed, I’d go so far as to say that MLP’s fandom is just as creative and devoted to its favorite thing as Star Trek’s, so it’s entirely appropriate to have this episode refer to its older distant cousin. Thus, “Swarm of the Century” invents the adult pony fandom as we all know it.
Next time: one of the first season’s stand-out episodes, and an early series classic to boot, plus the proper introduction of three characters that you can’t help but fall in love with, even if it takes a little while.
Leave a Reply