At this point, we are roughly halfway through the first season of Friendship is Magic, and so far I would judge that first half as uneven but with definite signs of promise, kind of like early season 1 of TNG. Episodes like the opening two-parter, “Applebuck Season,” “Boast Busters,” “Look Before You Sleep,” and “Swarm of the Century” make it clear the show isn’t afraid to tackle relatively simplistic lessons with humor and, in places, a little drama. Conversely, episodes like “Dragonshy” and “Bridle Gossip” make it obvious that a lot of work still needs to be done in refining the characters and avoid falling into traps.
Luckily, this next group of four episodes (two in this post and two in the next) make up the strongest run of the series to date: “Winter Wrap-Up” has Twilight attempting to figure out where she fits in when trying to participate in a Ponyville tradition, “Call of the Cutie” sees the show expand its cast of focus characters beyond the main leads by focusing on ponies who are a little closer in age to the target audience, “Fall Weather Friends” is a great early example of Applejack and Rainbow Dash’s chemistry with each other, and “Suited for Success,” as well as containing one of the show’s best early songs, fleshes out Rarity’s character in ways that make her truly as lovable and relatable as any of the other six leads.
Let’s start with “Winter Wrap Up.” At this point in the series, Twilight has been living in Ponyville for quite some time now, and she’s making an effort to participate in the town’s traditions and become part of the community. Surely, an event as complicated as the titular winter wrap-up (so named because in Equestria, the ponies are responsible for changing the seasons) would be perfect for a methodical and organized pony like her, right? Well, not at first.
Twilight’s intentions are perfectly sound. Her desire to participate in the wrap-up exactly as described (mainly, by not using her magic) is entirely within her character, this is the same mare who had a by-the-book sleepover just a few episodes ago. The problem is, being a studious bookworm reliant on magic to solve problems means she’s completely up a creek when she has to do anything else, like building a nest, ice skate, or push a plow. Her inability to do these things causes Ponyville to fall even farther behind in wrapping up winter than usual, and all seems lost.
Until, of course, Twilight uses the other type of magic in her arsenal: not the flashy stuff like when she enchants the plow to roll by itself, but friendship magic, the magic of bringing ponies together in pursuit of a common goal, the same magic that defeated Nightmare Moon and kept her in Ponyville in the first place. For all the grief the fandom gave the show staff for making Twilight a princess at the end of season 3, it’s important to remember that her ascension was part of Lauren Faust’s original game plan, and this episode is the first step in that journey.
It’s not often that we get to see a character arc like this, where a commoner (or whatever Twilight’s original role in Equestria’s social ladder was) ascends to ruler of the country, and not even because of marriage or a family member dying. Ironically, while Equestria’s government is obviously more of a monarchy of some sort, (or rather, a diarchy) Twilight’s character arc throughout the first three seasons is more akin to something found in a presidential system, such as in the United States.
Even more specifically, Twilight’s eventual role in this episode (which we’ll call Winter Wrap Up Coordinator) actually seems to mirror Barack Obama’s early years as a community organizer in Chicago before moving on to the Illinois Senate, the US Senate, and then the White House, though her role as Celestia’s student and then Ponyville’s librarian means she’s a closer match to Elizabeth Warren. (There is no American equivalent for her role as the junior Princess of Friendship that she fills for the bulk of the show’s run, however.)
Speaking of feeling out of place in a given social group, let’s shift gears to “Call of the Cutie.” That episode aired in January 2011, following a brief break, and focuses on Apple Bloom, Applejack’s little sister. Here, she’s dealing with a similar problem to that of Twilight in “Winter Wrap Up”: namely, she feels out of place among her peers because she’s the only pony in her class who doesn’t have a cutie mark, the symbol that depicts what a given pony is best at doing.
Aside from being an obvious metaphor for puberty, (which raises some odd questions about how exactly ponies age, especially since the CMC’s character models remain the same until about two weeks before the end of the series) the situation in which Apple Bloom finds herself is intensely familiar to anyone who remembers their middle school, high school, and early college years.
I can completely understand Apple Bloom’s desire to get her cutie mark as quickly as possible, because I was the same way when I was first questioning my gender identity. I didn’t know who I was or who I wanted to be, and I wanted to leap onto the first halfway plausible “answer,” irrespective of what my friends in the trans community said.
At first, I tried sticking with what was familiar, like Apple Bloom does when she tries selling apples: mainly, trying to live under the impression that I was a cis boy. It was all I had known, despite secret wishes to be something other than that. Several times during my first year or two in college, I almost ordered black market hormones online, but never actually followed through, partly because of cost and partly because I’d have no way of hiding the evidence of my transition from my parents, whom I assumed (correctly) would be horrified when they eventually found out.
Needless to say, that idea didn’t last very long. No matter how much I tried to deny it, I couldn’t ignore the voice in my head insisting that I wasn’t myself, that being a girl was what I really wanted. As with Rainbow Dash’s suggestion that Apple Bloom try a variety of tasks to find what she’s good at, I went about expressing the feminine side of myself however I could, whether by asking a very select group to address me as Lena, to changing my fursona species from wolf to a fictional feline race known as chakats, or roleplaying various scenarios in which my unicorn OC was changed into a mare, either through magical means or simply by crossdressing.
Finally, I accepted the truth that Twilight tells Apple Bloom before she goes to Diamond Tiara’s party: “A cutie mark is something a pony has to discover for herself.” And so I did, primarily because of clothes. I bought whatever feminine items I could grab from Amazon, from a black blouse with floral lace sleeves to a women’s pony shirt and a tube of blue lipstick. Some of it worked and some of it didn’t, but there was no doubt I was happier, at least a little bit.
And then, in January 2015, I had my moment of acceptance. A friend of mine from California sent me some old bras from her first few months of transition, and on the day they arrived in the mail, I had a mini photo session while my roommate was out of the dorm for the holiday weekend. In one of the pictures I took that day, I’m wearing an off-white t-shirt with Vinyl Scratch and Octavia on it, with one of the bras on underneath, stuffed with napkins. Looking at it from an outsider’s perspective, you’d assume I already had breasts, albeit small ones. When I saw how I looked and what it meant though, I realized that was how I wanted to look, not just in private but for the whole world.
And then… everything came to me in a rush. My egg hatched, and I finally accepted myself for what I was: a transgender woman. It was scary and wonderful and frightening and amazing, and I spent the rest of the four-day weekend feeling like I finally understood myself. And, as with Apple Bloom with Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo, I hd a warm and welcoming sisterhood of fellow trans women ready to bring me into their ranks.
In other words, that was the day I earned my cutie mark.
Leave a Reply