Equestria Forever: Fall Weather Friends/Suited for Success

One of the things that makes this show so interesting are the contrasts between the six lead characters. You have, for example, Twilight Sparkle’s blue-blood background yet her general common-mare personality, contrasted with Rarity’s background as a country-born mare with the desire to become a Canterlot aristocrat.

But the contrasts are more obvious with four of the six, since they’re all voiced by the same two actors: Andrea Libman for Pinkie and Fluttershy, and Ashleigh Ball for Applejack and Rainbow Dash. Here, the differences are stark: Pinkie is loud and hyperactive, and Fluttershy is quiet and withdrawn. Libman pitches her performance perfectly, making it difficult to tell she’s voicing both characters, even when they’re in a scene together.

But the strongest contrast in my opinion is the one between Rainbow and Applejack, and this episode does an excellent job at emphasizing it. Sure, AJ and Rainbow are both strong ponies with a desire to compete, but they both have very different ways of going about things. AJ prefers to do things honestly (befitting her Element) while Dash is willing to cheat and cut corners if it means she wins. As she says, “I hate losing.” (Who wants to bet that if she took the Kobayashi Maru scenario, she’d cheat like Kirk did?)

Of course, even Applejack’s principles crumble as Dash does everything possible to prevent her from winning, from using her wings in the Iron Pony competition to switching signs around during the Running of the Leaves. AJ soon starts cheating as well just to get back in the game, and the end result is that both of them lose, thanks to everypony else easily outpacing them.

Truth be told, I was never very fond of Rainbow Dash in the early seasons. She reminds me a little too much of the Tenth Doctor: a loud and brash egotist with a boasting problem. She has some good moments (“Sonic Rainboom” springs to mind, as does “Read It and Weep” in season 2, and season 3’s “Wonderbolts Academy,” which is her best episode out of the first 3 seasons) but for most of her focus episodes, she’s a hard mare to like. (She gets better though.)

Then there’s Applejack. She comes off much better than Rainbow, perhaps because scriptwriter Amy Keating Rogers likes her best, and it shows, given how she’s written here. It’s hard to begrudge her too much for sinking to Dash’s level only when she can’t play fair any further, and the secondary moral she demonstrates (about the importance of being a good sport) is an important one.

But there’s a third lesson at play here too, and it’s an old chestnut: “Slow and steady wins the race.” Granted, in this case Twilight came in fifth, but for all of Rainbow’s teasing about Twilight’s booksmarts, her strategy (take her time until everypony else has tired themselves out, then sprint to the finish) is one practiced by many real-world racers. And there’s something objectively delightful about the group librarian having a race number of 42.


Let’s move on to “Suited for Success,” an episode that is, I believe, not just a highlight of the show’s first season but of the entire series, entirely because of the excellent character work that makes this incarnation of the franchise shine so brightly. The episode is deceptively simple: Rarity makes dresses for her friends in advance of the Grand Galloping Gala. But it turns out to be so much more than that, becoming a musical version of a situation any freelancer or small business owner has gone through before.

Let’s start, though, with what it does for Rarity. This is her first time where she gets to be in the spotlight, and the truth of the matter is that, based on her behavior across the preceding 13 episodes, it has no right to be as good as it is. Sure, she gave half of her tail to a sea serpent in the premiere as a mark of her generosity in the pilot, but her actions in the episodes since suggest that she is vain, concerned only with her appearance (and those of other ponies) and little else.

For example: when Applejack first shows signs of exhaustion after making a mess of the award ceremony in “Applebuck Season,” Rarity expresses worry about the state of her mane, rather than Applejack personally. Her attempt to convince the dragon to leave the cave in “Dragonshy” fails not because she can’t butter him up, but because her own desire for gems and gold causes her to get carried away, and he notices her greed. And in “Look Before You Sleep,” her desire to make the loose branches look nice is part of what causes her to get caught in the storm with Applejack.

Based on all of the above, a casual viewer would probably be thinking that Rarity’s position as Bearer of Generosity was something of what TV Tropes calls an Informed Attribute: “Something is said to be X, but not shown to be that way.” The show insists she’s generous, but it also repeatedly paints her as a vain egotist, hardly a subversion of the stereotypical girly girl she was intended to be.

At least until this episode, of course. In 22 minutes, everything we think we know about Rarity is thrown entirely out the window as we see why she is the way she is. Yes, she’s obsessed with a pony’s appearance, because she is a fashion designer and that’s literally her job. She wants everypony to look their best because they could be potential clients, and because she really does care that much about her fellow pony. The generous part of her isn’t just a MacGuffin, it is literally part of who she is. She doesn’t just offer to make Twilight a dress for free, she insists upon it even in spite of Twilight’s understandable protests.

But her intrinsic generosity isn’t just what makes Rarity special. The episode goes to great lengths that she’s not just a businessmare, but an artist too. Some ponies express themselves through paint or the written word, Rarity expresses herself through clothes. That’s part of why she gets so upset when the first fashion show is such a clusterbuck, the dresses that the girls designed are an affront to her artistic sensibilities, as well as a harsh judgement on their part of her own value and worth. She locks herself in her room wallowing in self-pity because, I feel, she suffers from an inferiority complex.

Granted, the show never outright says she does, but look at who she is: this is a pony born in a small village widely considered by some of the Canterlot elite to be a podunk backwater, and she knows that for all her talent, she won’t make it in the industry unless she changes herself, so she starts cultivating a posh accent to make getting ahead easier.

This was actually fairly common in some industries: Patrick Stewart changed his accent from his natural Yorkshire one to a posh received pronunciation one when he was first learning to act, taught to him by Ruth Wynn Owen. (Who was, incidentally, a witch. She was a friend of Patricia Crowther, herself a Sheffield native, and one of Gerald Gardner’s Wiccan initiates. Which means there’s only two degrees of separation from my favorite Trek captain and the guy who founded my religion!)

Anyway. By the time the series begins, Rarity must’ve had some success in Ponyville at least, (she has to afford all that material somehow, and is probably living in her shop to keep costs down) but no chance at a big break until Hoity Toity enters the picture. When the first fashion show proves to be a disaster, it’s only natural for her to fall apart like she does, if I were in her position I would have too. If no one thinks her designs are any good, then she must be a terrible designer, and therefore the only solution is exile.

Of course, she’s wrong. She is a good designer, and working with clothes is such an ingrained part of her that she can’t help but wonder what exactly one would need to wear when going on self-imposed exile. Moreover, she can clearly recognize talent when she sees it, given her reaction to the job her friends did on her own Gala dress. That gives her the confidence boost she needs to show Hoity Toity her first designs, and of course he loves them.

Shifting gears a little, let’s move on to the causes of Rarity’s breakdown. As I mentioned earlier, the episode’s main plot is that she makes Gala dresses for her friends as a favor. However, the girls aren’t happy with the end products and start asking for changes, stressing Rarity out almost to the point of madness (watch her mane get increasingly messy in the second half of her song).

This exact situation is something every freelancer and small business owner has experienced. I’ve even gone through it myself, in one of my previous lives as a freelance audio editor. Like Rarity, I would spend ages working my hardest on a project, only to have my client dismiss all my hard work because it didn’t sound like he wanted it to sound. In a few cases, I’ve redone entire projects just to make that client happy, because otherwise I don’t get paid.

But of course, I’ve been on the other side of this as well, as the commissioner. Granted, I’m more easy to please than the girls were here, but I’ve heard many a horror story from various artist friends of mine about how awful some people they’ve worked with have been. A common refrain: the problematic customers all think drawing (or writing, or sound editing) is easy, when in fact it isn’t, and that assumption bleeds over into their behavior toward their chosen victim. (Not for nothing are these the exact same people framing generative AI as a “release” from the “torturous” process of drawing or writing. IT’S NOT TORTUROUS, YOU IDIOTS! WE DO THIS WORK BECAUSE WE WANT TO!)

Of course, it’s one thing when you’re being paid to do work for a total jackass, and quite another when you’re doing it for free. I know some artists who, if they offer showing drafts of a work to the commissioner, will allow suggestions or specific desires from paid clients but not unpaid ones. And that, in my view, is entirely fair. This person is taking time away from their paid work to draw you something for free, the absolute least you can do is show appreciation. That’s not to say you shouldn’t voice concerns if you have them, but there is a line, and Twilight and the girls are a good example of what can happen when it’s crossed.

Speaking personally, I have a confession to make: Twilight really is the pony I love best, but Rarity is a very close second, and this episode is one of the reasons why. In fact, it’s only gotten stronger over the years, now that I know how it feels to be in both Rarity’s place as well as Twilight’s. I also feel I relate to Rarity personally, as I like to think I’m a generous and empathic person who likes helping people, and inspiring them to be their best selves.

Watching this episode now a decade and a half after it first aired, it’s a good reminder of what drew me to the show in the first place. Character work like this doesn’t come often in children’s television, and certainly not from a franchise as focused on selling toys as this one. If I ever had the occasion to convince someone to watch the show, this would be the one I’d pick. Between the sublime character work, the wonderful music, and excellent dialogue, you’d be hard-pressed to find a better example in the rest of the children’s TV landscape.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑