Captain’s log, stardate 80885.2: While Picard and the crew of the Enterprise races against the clock to launch a probe, a culture of experimental nanites accidentally released by Wesley threatens to render the Enterprise uninhabitable.
In Star Trek fandom conventional wisdom, it is usually said that the third season of TNG is generally regarded as when the show finally starts to become the seven-season cultural behemoth that took the world by storm in the early 1990s. The show begins to look like itself – the opening credits now begin with that famous blue nebula shot, the uniforms have actual collars now, the colors are brighter and more vibrant, and the camera work more cinematic!
There’s a beautiful panning shot near the top of the episode that looks like nothing TNG has ever done before, made all the better in the HD remaster that has long since become the way to watch this series. (True, you can also see all the acne on Wil Wheaton’s face when he sits up, but hey! That’s TV for ya.)
The title alone works on multiple levels here – yes, there’s the main plot regarding the nanites, but also it feels very much like the show is evolving too. Gates McFadden has finally returned to the general joy of everyone involved, and Michael Piller, the show’s newest head writer, is already making his presence known – we get more to do regarding Beverly and Wesley here than we did for TNG’s entire first two years.
But let’s go back to the first meaning of “Evolution,” and see how it ties in with the second one.
The first thing to notice here is that this isn’t just another Wesley episode, but one that revisits the show’s first attempt at such a thing. In “The Naked Now,” Wesley was both the cause of, and solution to, the episode’s problem. As the trope page notes, “Wesley used a fraudulent voice command (which in itself is unusual) and took control of the entire ship,” putting him in prime position to “solve” the problem he created. The boy-king of Engineered Heroics if ever there was one.
Blessedly, things go very differently this time around. Wesley setting the nanites loose wasn’t something he did on purpose, like with the fake Picard audio clips from “Naked Now,” but a genuine accident that is justifiably portrayed as wrongdoing. Sure, he gets off pretty easily, but at least now there’s reason for it – the nanites weren’t trying to hurt anyone.
Contrary to his reputation in fandom, Wes isn’t written as the “Mozart”-type figure that the Traveler said he was anymore. He’s just an ordinary seventeen year old boy with the study habits of Twilight Sparkle prior to her enforced move to Ponyville at the start of Friendship is Magic. This actually makes him more relatable to the kids watching the show at home, especially the introverted types.
Where the episode really shines, though, is the character of Paul Stubbs. He is explicitly meant as a stand-in for early-series Wesley, down to the conversation in the shuttlebay early in the episode:
STUBBS: I have never doubted for a moment that this day would come, Wesley. And I suspect that some day it will come for you as well. I see a lot of me in you. In my youth, they called me a vunderkind. Do you understand vunderkind?
WESLEY: It’s German, isn’t it?
STUBBS: It means wonder child. It is reserved for those of us who achieve early in life. Now the burden is yours.
WESLEY: Burden?
STUBBS: To fulfill your potential. You will never come up against a greater adversary than your own potential, my young friend.
For literally the entire rest of the episode, Stubbs from this point on (as I described him to Friend of the Blog Freezing Inferno, who I know is reading this) is nothing but a condescending little bitch. Aside from the over-inflated ego, he treats his experiment as though it’s the biggest and best thing ever to happen in human history, up to and including being willing to murder the nanites and put the Enterprise crew in mortal peril.
And unlike Wesley in season 1, who got a free pass because he was a Main Character, Paul Stubbs doesn’t get off anywhere near that easily. One of my favorite scenes in the whole episode is near the last quarter or so, when Stubbs not-so-subtly threatens Jean-Luc with his job and JL tells him, in not so many words, to go fuck himself:
PICARD: Doctor Stubbs, if you were a member of my crew, sir, I would-
STUBBS: But I am not a member of your crew, sir. I am a representative of the highest command of the Federation, which has directed you to perform my experiment.
PICARD: If any man, woman or child on this ship is harmed as a result of your experiment, I will have your head before the highest command in the Federation.
You see?! Realism! This is exactly how early Wesley should have been treated, rather than being granted the privilege of sitting in Picard’s command chair for no apparent reason beyond Wunderkind-ness. Wesley, bless him, is trying to earn the privilege he has as helmsman of the Enterprise, and frankly, good on him – he has a better head on his shoulders than Paul Stubbs does.
I will note one other wonderful thing about “Evolution” – the gradual shift away from pure episodic storytelling and toward something more arc-based. Obviously, Deep Space Nine will take that format and run with it, but it’s evident even here. While TNG never completely abandons its roots as episodic TV, there’s a difference between, say, Remmick listing off random season 1 episodes in “Coming of Age” and what happens in “Evolution.”
Recall the main plot of the episode. The conflict is generated primarily by mechanical creatures that can replicate themselves, learn new skills, and adapt using a collective intelligence. At one early stage, they even produce a “synthetically generated image” (read: AI hallucination) of the only enemy they can possibly understand…
The Borg.
“Evolution” is, essentially, a Borg episode in which the Borg do not actually show up. Granted, the nanites are far more benevolent than the Borg are, but still! The threat to the Enterprise is the same, minus the whole assimilation thing. They are still more than capable of bringing the Enterprise crew to their knees, even if all they do is use their power to blast the greatest hits of John Philip Sousa at top volume.
And of course, the Borg evolve as well – they gain a queen in First Contact after being an otherwise faceless race in their previous TNG appearances, and in “Võx” they transcend their own cybernetic origins and make the leap into regular biology, when it is revealed that inserting Picard’s Borg-altered DNA into anyone who uses a transporter has made it possible for the Borg to assimilate everyone in Starfleet.
How fitting, then, that the last self-contained season premiere in TNG should trade so heavily in how the Borg work, given who we’ll see again at season’s end.
I love this show. ❤
Leave a Reply