Equestria Forever: Feeling Pinkie Keen/Sonic Rainboom

After a four-episode stretch of promising television, we return to the status quo for season 1: alternating terrible episodes and very good ones. In this case, our first entry is “Feeling Pinkie Keen,” our first Twilight-centric episode since “Ticket Master,” and just like that one, it requires somepony to be bent wildly out of character in order for the plot to work.

By this point in the season, we have a pretty good idea who Twilight is: a magical prodigy with some tendencies of obsessive-compulsive disorder, a certified genius, and total bookworm with poor, albeit improving, social skills. And Dave Polsky, in his debut episode for the show, trades all that away to turn her into a haughty quasi-atheist who, despite allegedly being a scientist, undertakes her experiments with the goal of being proven right than actually discovering the truth.

To be fair, some of her attitude may be explained by the sheer number of injuries she sustains over the course of the episode, up to and including having a piano fall on her head. All that physical abuse (and mental stress) certainly did a number on her mood. And Polsky appears to be approaching the storyline as a shoutout to the Wile E. Coyote and Roadrunner cartoons, so of course Twilight has to be awful, the episode wouldn’t work if she wasn’t.

Even so, this is absolutely not the kind of episode she should be involved in. It would, however, be a perfect fit for two characters whom we won’t meet for a while yet, but are nonetheless relevant to the topic at hoof: Sunset Shimmer and the human Twilight Sparkle. (Yes, there are two of her.)

Allow me to explain: between seasons 3 and 4, a spinoff series of movies (and later, a combination of web shorts and TV specials) debuted called My Little Pony: Equestria Girls. The eponymous first film introduced the character of Sunset Shimmer, who occupied the role of Celestia’s student shortly before Twilight. A comic book prequel reveals she originally wanted to become a princess, and attempted to force Celestia to make her one, in spite of Celestia telling her repeatedly that such a status must be earned, as it was with Twilight.

Sunset is eventually dismissed, and she flees through a magic mirror to a world populated by pastel humans. In the first movie, she steals Twilight’s Element of Harmony and takes it back to the human world, intending to create an army of teenagers she can use to return to Equestria and exact revenge on Celestia, and only Twilight, together with high-school age human versions of her five best friends, can stop her.

If that had been it for the EQG franchise, we would’ve had a decent redo of the pilot and an interesting in-between story illustrating how Twilight adjusts to her new role as a princess. Instead, that first movie launched an entire spinoff series, with Sunset serving as the leader of her group in all subsequent movies and specials.

In the second movie, Rainbow Rocks, a plot point is introduced: Sunset’s friends are able to “pony up” (sprout pony ears, wings where applicable, and long ponytails that look like actual pony tails) when they play music, and in one of the Friendship Games prequel shorts, Sunset takes it upon herself to investigate it.

Let’s look at what both of these stories have in common: we have two intelligent unicorn scientists, Twilight and Sunset, confronted with a scientific impossibility: respectively, Pinkie Sense and pony ups, and there’s a scene in which the unicorn hooks her friends up to some analysis equipment and attempts to conduct an experiment.

But here’s where their approaches diverge. As I said earlier, Twilight spends the entire episode working backwards to “prove” that Pinkie Sense doesn’t exist, even as everything she does blows up in her face, proving the opposite. True, she does eventually come around to the idea, but only after being attacked by a hydra, and all because she refused to admit she doesn’t understand something.

Contrast this with what Sunset does. She freely admits she doesn’t understand something, and rather than stand on a literal soap box pontificating about how it violates all principles of magic in Equestria, she accepts that the pony ups are simply a quirk of how the human world’s magic has developed since she brought it there in the first movie. And of course, her attitude is entirely different: she’s not looking to have an assumption confirmed, she truly does want to find out how the pony-ups work, and when they defy all possible attempts at measurement, she simply rolls with it and moves on.

Of course, if Twilight had taken Sunset’s attitude when investigating Pinkie Sense, we likely would have a very different episode than the one that actually aired. So instead, let’s apply the episode toward her human counterpart instead.

The human world’s version of Twilight (hereinafter SciTwi, her fandom nickname) is introduced in Friendship Games as Sunset’s foil, in other words, presenting the closing of the circle that began with the first movie as she and Sunset swap narrative roles. As an alternate counterpart to Pony Twilight, SciTwi provides a partial answer to the question, “What would Twilight be like if she never went to Ponyville?”

The answer: a friendless and withdrawn young scientist. However, there’s a twist: SciTwi’s isolation doesn’t come from simply being more interested in research than friend-making, but because the students at Crystal Prep Academy flat-out despise her, and are perfectly willing to throw her under the bus if it means beating Canterlot High in the Games.

So how does all this relate to “Feeling Pinkie Keen?” It’s very simple: Twilight’s borderline contemptuous behavior toward Pinkie Sense is entirely inappropriate for a pony who once defeated an alicorn with the power of friendship, but it makes perfect sense for SciTwi, who grew up attending a school run by a psychologically and emotionally abusive headmistress. It would still be unacceptable, but it would at least be understandable from a characterization perspective.

However, swapping one Sparkle for another would just be polishing a turd of an episode. It would need a full-scale rewrite (in other words, swapping Twilight for Sunset) in order to become worth watching. And at that point, you’re not really talking about the same episode anymore.


I had a thought as I was watching this episode in preparation for writing the blog post. My question was, “Why is Rainbow Dash unable to adequately perform the Rainboom until the end of the competition?” The answer has nothing to do with her self-confidence issues or Rarity’s selfishness once she has her wings, and everything to do with Rainbow’s status as the Element of Loyalty.

In the episode, Rainbow states that she was able to perform the Rainboom only once before: when she was a filly. And it wasn’t just happenstance that time either, as “The Cutie Mark Chronicles” reveals that back then, she was defending Fluttershy from bullies at flight camp, only for the bullies to challenge her to a race. Rainbow accepts, intending to defend Fluttershy’s honor.

And that, I believe, is key. In the finale of the fifth season, Starlight Glimmer time travels back to the day of the race, she does everything possible to prevent the Rainboom from occurring, up to and including telling the bullies not to tease Fluttershy. No bullying, no need for Dash to race for her friend’s honor. (To say nothing of putting Twilight in the awkward position of endorsing bullying…) And with no rainboom, Twilight and her friends never meet, leading to any number of apocalypses… and a barren wasteland where once was life.

Of course, Starlight’s scheme does eventually fail, and Rainbow is able to complete the race, perform the rainboom, and earn her mark. Years later, she meets Twilight (again) and the rest of the main cast and has a role in causing another powerful magic rainbow, this time via the Elements of Harmony, because she chose to stay with her friends in the forest rather than join the Shadowbolts.

That’s why, in the end, she’s the only one who can save Rarity when her butterfly wings dissolve into nothingness and she falls to certain doom. She is Rainbow’s friend, and Rainbow’s personal code of ethics would not allow her to stand by and watch as her friend plummets to her death. And that, as I said at the beginning, is why she’s able to perform the Rainboom in that moment: saving Rarity’s life took precedence over winning a competition.

For all the grief I’ve given Dash over the last few weeks, “Sonic Rainboom” really is one of her standout moments as a character, and probably the very first time that she actually works as a character in the first place. In other words, “Sonic Rainboom” is for Rainbow what “Suited for Success” was for Rarity: an episode built entirely around showing the focus pony at her best. (Which makes the fact that Dash saves Rarity all the more appropriate, IMO.)

Next week: A CMC double feature, with bonus Fluttershy!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑