Wolf Trek: The Ensigns of Command

Captain’s log, stardate 80905.8: Data attempts to convince the leader of an endangered colony that his people must evacuate the planet or face extinction at the hands the Sheliak who are claiming the planet to colonize.


A couple of interesting things happened to me when I sat down to watch this episode: a flock of crows, a bird considered sacred to the Morrígan, roosted in a tree right outside my window. Then in my Discord server, we picked up a conversation about the usefulness of violence in reaction to displays of power by fascists.

And then I got to see a Star Trek episode where the normally peaceful Data has to resort to violence in order to make a point, while Picard successfully prevents a planetary extermination campaign by exploiting the finer details of a treaty. None of these events seem coincidental.

The question today seems to be, “What is the purpose of violence in the face of the intractable?”

The discussion began last night, when a New Zealand friend of mine posited that violence was the only reasonable solution to the burgeoning authoritarian state that American government has become. He said, “Like if the Democrats clearly do not care about the people, and the Republicans never will, it feels like the only way to actually make change is by just deciding to go full out violent to overthrow the system. I don’t see how the Democrats can ever really come back from this and prove they’re all that different from Republicans.”

I want to reiterate that not only is my friend a foreigner, he lives ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE PLANET. He does not have a single solitary horse in this race, and for that matter, I don’t think he knows what the fuck he’s talking about anyway. The Democrats as currently constituted do not have a chance at salvaging their reputation, but if the uniformly incensed reaction to their capitulation vis-a-vis the shutdown is any indicator, that delegation will look very different in 2027 than it does now.

Which gets at a point I tried to make in one of my responses:

“Battles happen. War happens. I am not trying to deny those things, or to suggest that violence should be avoided at all costs. Rather, it should be absolute last resort.

Right now, I think it would be fair to say that most Americans still believe in the possibility of the ballot box to effect needed political change, and the fecklessness of the national Democratic Party will inspire them to support, or even become, candidates who are willing to fight. Every person is able to contribute something to a battle, it doesn’t just have to be shooting at things with guns.

My concern is what will happen if we stop using ballots and start using bullets to solve problems. Because then, who are the casualties going to be?”

Much of the conflict in this episode centers around Data’s attempts at getting the colonists of Tau Cygna V to leave their world so they don’t get killed by the Sheliak, an alien species who view humans as an inferior lifeform, and as a result would have no problem whatsoever with glassing a colony if it means they get to move their own people in.

Poor Data spends the bulk of the episode dealing with Gosheven, a thoroughly unlikeable man whose pride and vanity leads him to not only treat Data like an object rather than a person, but to dismiss his warnings about the Sheliak entirely out of hand. Gosheven believes that his colony can beat back the “invaders,” and it’s not until Data uses a phaser to destroy the colony’s aqueduct that he finally understands how completely outmatched he’d be in a fight.

As Data puts it:

DATA: I can reduce this pumping station to a pile of debris, but I trust my point is clear. I am one android with a single weapon. There are hundreds of Sheliak on the way and their weapons are far more powerful. They may not offer you a target. They can obliterate you from orbit. You will die never having seen the faces of your killers. The choice is yours.

Gosheven’s position is repeatedly stressed to be the wrong one – not only will he fail to get the Sheliak to turn back, he’ll die before he even manages to fire off one shot, and that’s if he has any planetary defenses in the first place. (Which I doubt, given the low technology level of the colony.) 

So, what is the episode advocating for here? That we should all just give up and abandon all that we love in the face of overwhelming superior firepower? Absolutely the fuck not. Because this, my friends, is when we get to talk about Picard’s half of this episode.

While Data is busy planet-side, Picard tries to negotiate with the notoriously difficult Sheliak to try and get them to give him more time to complete the evacuation. But the Sheliak are obstinate, refusing over and over to give him what he asks for. He’s an inferior lifeform to them, why should they care about what he wants?

What Picard eventually does is two-fold. He first has the Enterprise intercept the Sheliak ship to prevent it from moving anywhere, then studies the treaty and finds that he can select a third-party arbitrator to resolve any dispute… such as the one they are currently facing. So he finds one that just so happens to be in the middle of a six-month hibernation cycle, and the Sheliak, unwilling to deal with an even longer delay to their plans, give Picard the three weeks he needs in order to complete evacuation procedures.

The case that episode writer Melinda M. Snodgrass (who contributed another beloved Data episode, “The Measure of a Man,” last season) was trying to make is not that we should roll over and give in to superior forces, but that violence as problem solving should only ever be used as a last resort. It got toned down when the episode was rewritten, but something of it still comes through in Brent Spiner’s performance, and it corresponds nicely with Picard using the Enterprise as a shield in order to protect the colonists.

Which brings me back, at last, to the discussion in my server. There’s a quote in Priestess of the Morrígan that I want to reiterate here, because I think it’s relevant both to the discussion of violence in the real world, and in the fictional world of Star Trek:

“What strikes me the most is how much her children think they are unworthy of her. That if they trudge onward, without rest, without sleep, without care for themselves, that will somehow prove they are good soldiers. Prove they are worthy. They think she wants them to destroy themselves on the battlefield. “Do they not see I am trying to save them from that fate?” she says to me. “I will see them off the battlefield. I will see them to victory. I would have my ravens thrive. What good are they to me broken and dead upon the battlefield?”

This is the thing. The Morrígan is a goddess of war, yes, but she does not revel in or glorify war like some people (such as the current Secretary of Defense) sadly do. When she goes into battle, she does it with the goal of accomplishing something. What she is trying to achieve is peace. But to get there, there will have to be a battle. And battles take many shapes and forms. We must adapt as well if we are to survive.

Joe Biden may have been an ineffective president, even a negligent one, but he was right about one thing: we are in a battle for the soul of this nation. We have been for a long time – if John Beckett is to be believed, the Morrígan saw this moment was coming long before the rest of us did. And she’s been building an army ever since.

Not a traditional army in the sense of guns, swords, and armor, but of priests, priestesses, druids, and witches. She knows full well I am not physically capable of fighting – that’s not what she needs me to do. She does not need another Data in the town square brandishing a phaser. What she needs is someone who can wield her words like some people wield a sword, like Picard in his dealings with the Sheliak. She needs someone who can stand up and show others a path they can take in her service.

I have tried, in the year I have been her raven, to become that person. And she’s noticed my progress: my ritual for her last Samhain was joyful, full of pride for the progress I’ve made. I still have more work to do, but she trusts me to put my muzzle to the grindstone and do that work.

When the news of the election results came in on November 4th, a song suddenly popped into my head – “Morrighan’s Quest” by Laura Powers. The chorus goes, 

“Black raven queen of night

She brings her strength and might

For victory”

I mentioned that to some fellow devotees I know, and said that “No, she isn’t coming to save us… but she *will* fight alongside us. And that’s enough.” My friend added, “we will save us and she will grant us the strength and ferocity to win.”

And we will win. It will not be easy though, to quote again from Woodfield: “There will be battles you win and battles you will lose. But know this. I watch over those who are mine. And you will win the war.”

I trust her, and I trust in my fellow Americans, the ones putting their bodies on the line in order to stand up to Trumpian fascism. They don’t know it, but they’re all doing the raven’s work – just like I am now, writing this. 

Rise to the battle. Let’s get to work.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑